if communism was conceived by a Jew then why are Jews so anti communism/socialism?

Question

i'm talking about the late great MARX.

Answer 1

because they live a double parrallel existance perhaps, and this was needed to shape the future of the world....XXXX

Answer 2

On questions like this, I look at the premise and usually I find the premise to be wrong. The purpose of a question with a false root is usually to arouse hatred of some group.

Karl Marx was raised in a Lutheran family. His father was converted the year before he was born.

But let me ask the question another way. If Jesus was a Jew, why are christians so anti-semetic?

Answer 3

The concept of a society where all people work together equally and share equally was conceived by a Jew (Marx).Foolish though it was,Marx,the Jew,can not be blamed for the evil which sprang forth from his concept.The Russians,who were Catholic at that time of revolution and upheaval killed somewhere around 22,000,000 of their own people to accomplish a Communistic Society."Link 1"

Answer 4

Karl Marx was an atheist of Jewish descent.

I think if you research a bit you will find many people of Jewish descent are or have been Marxists, or atheists or have converted to Christianity.

Jews who are religious would oppose the atheistic dogma of Marx and communism for a variety of reasons. It is anti-entrepreneurial by nature and that is very foreign to the traditional Jewish work ethic.

Answer 5

Probably because Stalin, the master of world communism for so long, orcestrated campaigns of persecution of the Jews. Coomunism has therefore become synonimous with anti-semitism, so it's natural that Jews would end up hating it.

Answer 6

There is not always a connection between a persons faith and heritage, and their intellectual work...

And Israel is nothing if not socialist in its government and social infrastructure.... health care, community service, National Service etc. and the whole point of Israel is to give a home and place of sanctuary to the Jewish people.

So it's ridiculous to say they are anti-socialism, regardless of what is thought about their foreign policies.

Answer 7

You are making the false assumption that Marx's religion had anything to do with his economic theories. You should really take a course in logic.

Answer 8

Marx never spoke for the whole Nation of Jewish people from the beginning of time. It was his own theory, but had nothing to do with the beliefs of the Jewish people.

Answer 9

Jesus was a Jew, but Jew's don't follow Christianity. I'm sure some Jews were socialist, as it was the intellectual fad of the early 20th century.

Answer 10

Marx,Freud,Einstien.....etc were all jews.
Jews are main contribuitors in human development but this shouldn't imply that the (discovery,conception,theory...) made by an jew should be revered by all jews.

Answer 11

Do you agree with everything your political forebears did?

Hitler was not a Christian; a nominal belief in God doesn't make anyone a Christian and he was influenced more by atheistic ideas.
His ideas about race come from the great messiah of Atheists, Darwin.