according to the Bible the dying Jesus said, "father why has thou forsaken me?

Question

" In the context that many Christians hold as true, that Jesus was perfect Jesus's statement must be true. So in that context why did Yahweh forsake Jesus? Also within the context of the concept of the trinity how could one part of the trinity forsake another part?

Answer 1

Hi. One has to assume the human part was feeling desperate.

Answer 2

The Egg Theory of explaining the trinity. An egg shell is not an egg. An egg yolk is not an egg. An egg white is not an egg. However all three put together make up an egg. The father, son and Holy Spirit are one God (YHWH). The three of them work together with one mind and one purpose but are separate entities.

Can you peel an egg? yes, you can separate the shell from the egg. Jesus was separated at the moment of death from the Holy Spirit and the Father. He was taking the punishment for all sin. At that exact moment, he was forsaken by God (YHWH). That did not last though because He was raised again and reunited with the Father and the Holy Spirit.

Answer 3

I'm losing count as to how many times I've answered the question.

What Jesus was doing was quoting Psalm 22. A messianic psalm written by King David 1000 years prior to Christ's death. Read the Psalm and read the gospel account of Jesus' death and notice all the other correlation.

The point is Jesus was alluding to himself being the Messiah.

Answer 4

That was my first question to a Biblical scholar and he said it was a misinterpretation of the language, then he launched into a diatribe of the other misinterpretations with notes, histories and I got bored before I got an answer. Truth be told, this guy speaks 6 ancient languages, never cashes a paycheck, probably told me a secret but I would have had to listen for 2 hours. I listened for 5 minutes, got lost in his story and didn't care. The answer is in biblicists, if you can stand to listen.

Answer 5

Jesus asked, that doesn't mean that the forsaking actually took place. The meaning behind the question is to show that even Jesus wanted an end to His suffering. He wanted to get on to the next phase of His prophecy. Even I myself have looked up and said, "please don't forget about me, I am tired and weary and need your strength go carry me on." It is meant to show a connection to everyone, Jesus was a person just like we are, He felt like we feel, it is a way of demonstrating the relation to human realism.

Answer 6

He shed His triuneness for 30+ years so that He would become the true sacrifice for sin and complete the blood covenant !!! The innocent dying for the guilty !!! Justification [JUST AS IF I HAD NEVER SINNED] Remember the Garden of Eden and the the blood covenant that God initated with Abraham plus the purpose of the temple to bring the sacrifical animal to as a reminder of the blood covenant !!! Would you go thru the painstaking detail of the following site to broaden your theological knowledge !!! http://www.bibleprophesy.org/introwedding.htm

Answer 7

it was a dicotomy of sorts at this point. For once and for all, the Word of God became the sin of the world and could not be one with the father. This so dramaticaly affected nature that a great earthquake caused the temple vail to tare. The immortal Word of God literaly died for all of mankind and was forsaken by his God. What an amazing feet... what a painful one as nature itself was perverted simply to restore man to God.

Answer 8

Christians believe Jesus Christ (Yeshua) is God during the trinity. not 3, yet one. Triune or Tri-team spirit - Trinity. The son represents God as guy, interior the flesh, individual who may be tempted, individual who can cry, experience discomfort, starvation and flow during the struggles that we as human beings can relate to. it rather is the suitable occasion that could be set for us as human beings. The prophecy of the messiah comes from Judaism. "The Lord your God is one". The messiah is a factor of God, and God is a factor of the Messiah. interior the e book of John, Christ pronounced "I enable you be responsive to the certainty, formerly Abraham substitute into born, i'm". This substitute into Jesus Christ (Yeshua) calling himself God. The Quran ignores the Jewish prophecy of the Messiah. The virgin start. the entering Jerusalem on a "Donkey", The prophecy's of Isaiah with reference to the advent Messiah. The Quran additionally substitute into written a procedures after the recent testomony, and 1000's of years after lots of the previous testomony.

Answer 9

I'll assume that this is a serious question and answer you seriously.

God the Father forsook Jesus on the cross because Jesus became sin for us. He took on all mankinds sins and became our substitute and paid the penalty of death on the cross. At that time he was totally abhorant to God the Father, who is holy and pure and cannot look upon sin, and was totally cut off from God.

How can this be? I don't know. How can it be that God can just speak the universe into existance? God does not give us an understanding of HOW, only of WHY.

Answer 10

Jesus took the burden of sin for all man kind. Once that burden was placed on Jesus and he represented sin, God in heaven can not be part of sin and turned His back and separated Himself from the resemblance of sin. Jesus being Immanuel, God with us, felt as a man what it was like to have distance from what was Holy and pure. Then when it was done Jesus said it is finished and our way to salvation was prepared and we are set free if we accept Jesus as our Lord and savior. Isaiah 7:14 Sovereign and Lord Jesus, which means absolute power without measure, fully God, lacking nothing

Answer 11

Remember, Jesus was truly both God (second person of the trinity) and man (born of a women). As a man, He was not always aware or fully aware of His share in the Divinity. He suffered and died as a man like unto us except sin (perfection). He was not truly forsaken by God the Father, but felt the same pain as we all do at times that maybe God is forsaking us. His faith, as a man, was tested, but He prevailed in it.