Selfish of him or selfish of me?

Question

My husband and his family do not celebrate Christmas whereas my family and I do (we're of different religious backgrounds)
We have an almost two-year-old little boy.
Here's the dilema: His parents want to keep our son for two weeks right during the Christmas holidays, as that's when everyone in their family is off, and although they don't celebrate Christmas, they still get together (like a reunion type thing ) They have a big family and this is when people are able to get together.
My family, though, is really looking forward to spending the holidays with our son, as am I.... we've already bought gifts for him and a stocking and everything. Everyone's excited....
My husband is telling me that it's selfish of me to want to keep our son with us for the holidays when we see him all the time and his family hardly ever gets to see him (they live across the state) and I think it's selfish of him and them to not keep him the couple of weeks before Christmas. Who is right?

Answer 1

Neither is right :) Arguing over this doesn't do any good, because niether side will see the opposite's. Both parties are being selfish.

So the answer is easy. A compromise. Take the 2 weeks that are spread out over christmas, and divide them between time spent with both families. 1 week a piece for the little one to get to experince both families holiday traditions.

Answer 2

2 weeks is too long for a 2 yr old to be away from mom. Not only that, you and dad should have Christmas with YOUR child. Compromise by letting child spend several days with in laws during the "reunion." However, consider having dad accompany HIS child. This will give you a well needed break and time to prepare for Christmas. Most importantly, make sure that you, dad and baby wake up in your own home Christmas morning. THIS IS THE BEST ANSWER!!

Answer 3

I feel he's being selfish for the simple reason that his family doesn't celebrate Christmas, why does his family have to see the kids during these two weeks, if they don't celebrate Christmas? The kids are going to miss opening gifts on Christmas day--something all kids look foward to do. You guys have to get together and do the right thing for the kids.

Answer 4

I variety of believe the guy who says existence isn't all approximately you, even though it additionally isn't approximately residing for others. while does the "you" on your existence are available if extremely is your existence? I agree that it is egocentric to assert that it is egocentric. yet does not propose i think of it is top. I do have faith issues get extra appropriate in case you hold an open ideas. If it does not (i'll get numerous hate for this) then you definately in all likelihood weren't waiting to take on the international. it definitely relies upon on the place you grew up, the form you have been stated, and the moral values you have been taught as a baby. it is all my opinion.

Answer 5

your fam should have christmas get together early...celebrate christmas early and open presents...hes 2 he wont know the difference...
this is why it is stated in the Bible that you shouldnt be "unequally yoked" with your spouse...meaning your beliefs...for this prime delimma...
and if your fam DOES get to see him all the time...then come on...
this is the compromises that you guys have to deal with as a result to be together and have diff religious beliefs...
there are a ton of more Christmases to come...

Answer 6

you are right. your the mom. they should not expect things out of you simply becuase they are your inlaws. your the mom, of course your going to want to have your child with you @Christmas time

Answer 7

both are right, both are selfish! best bet is to split the kid's time evenly between families.

Answer 8

you are just going to have find a middle ground that works for both of you! Good luck :)