Why do Muhammed and Jesus disagree at every point?

Question

If islam is the successor to Christianity why do they disagree utterly

Jesus saves a girl from stoning

M'mmed says it's ok for a woman to be punished in this way

why rewrite that with the masculine attitude at the time

They came to arrest Jesus and he submits

They come for m'mmed and he fights back and kills them

He laid seige to mecca and destroys asll the christians there, yes it was a christian country bvefore an islamic one,

Jesus says no marriage in heaven
M'mmed says there is amrriage in heaven

Jesus confirms the 10 commandments
So does Moses
They live thousands of years apart and say the same message

Jesus gave himself up to his transgressors as he lived by his words:thy shalt not kill

If jesus never said eh was the son of God why did they kil him

and if it is Judas who you cliam was actually killed instead
then the jews still saught to kill jesus originally, so why did they seek to kill him

Just that one question for my muslim friends

Why did the Jews kill jesus

e problem is They keep disagreeing whereas islam says your prophets are our prophets so why don't they agree

In the book of revelations the angel Gabriel shows John the end of time,

so why come along 600 years later to give muhammed a new law on how its ok to stone women for adultery after the Jesus said it was not

Infact what more was there for Gabriel ot ponit out to anyone after what she showed John?

Answer 1

Oh and that's not all. You forgot....



Jesus was born of a virgin.
Matt 1:18-25
Muhammad was born of human conception
Ibn Hisham pp.68-69

Jesus served God as a child.
Luke 2:39-52
Muhammad was an idolater
Sahih Bukhari vol 6, p. 453

Jesus preached the Gospel at God's command, and lived on donations of others.
Luke:416-21 and 8:1-3
Without being commanded by God, Muhammad began to steal from others and live on their goods.
Ibn Hisham pp. 281

Jesus proformed miracles.
Mark 3:9-10
Muhammad could not perform miracles.
Qur'an 29:41

Jesus made blind eyes to see.
Luke 18:35-43
Muhammad made seeing eyes blind
Sahih Bukhari vol. 8 p. 520

Jesus made the lame to walk.
Matthew 9:2-8
Muhammad made the walking lame.
Sahih Bukhari vol. 8 p. 520

Jesus healed the withered hands.
Matt 12:10-13
Muhammad cut off the hands of others.
Sahih Bukhari vol. 8 p. 520

Jesus raised the dead.
John 11:1-45
Muhammad had the living killed.
Ibn Hisham p. 308

Jesus forgave His opponents.
Luke 23:34
Muhammad had his opponents murdered
Sahih Bukhari vol. 5. pp. 248

Jesus set the condemned free.
John 8:1-11
Muhammad comned the free and led them into slavery.
Ibn Hisham p. 468

Jesus preached the Gospel in the chosen temple.
Luke 20:1
Muhammad prayed in the Ka'ba when it contained hundreds of idols.
Sahih Bukhari vol. 1 p. 151
TIM958

Jesus preached against divorce.
Matt 5:31-32
Muhammad preached divorce and allowed tempory marriage with compensation.
(Mat'a)
Qur'an 2:230, Sahih Bakhari vol. 7. p.8

Jesus was sinless.
John 8:46
Muhmmad was sinful.
Qur'an 47:21 and Qur'an 110

Jesus gave himself as a sacrifice for all mankind
John 1:29 and 10:18
Muhammad died unexpectedly of illness (which he himself said was due to a poisoning attempt)
Sahih Bukhari vol. 5. p.510

Jesus rose form the dead on the third day after His death and later assended into heaven.
Luke 23 and 24
Muhammad was buried in Medina on the third day after his death. His tomb is visited by pilgrims every year.
al Tabari vol.9. p.208

Jesus was God's word and God Himself.
John 1:1 and 14
Muhammad was only a warner.
Qur'an 29:49

Jesus lives!
Muhammed is dead.

Answer 2

This is one of the best examples of a question to illustrate the Galatians 5:17 conflict to be posted as of 6 November 2007.

As it turns out, Islam is a martial religion based on Muhammad's war experiences of the 8th Century A.D.--he had a major enmity for the preexisting pantheists among his native Arab nation, who had forced him from Meqah, and contempt for the Byzantines, the Yemeni Jews, and the Orthodox Church. As documented in the first half of the Quran, Muhammad retrenched his forces at Madinah and exacted vengeance on all comers in what I understand to be a long series of assassination raids (better documented in the Hadith); the siege of Meqah was the climax of this string of wars--the Byzantines were, I estimate, Muhammad's primary target, and the Jews and Christians both secondary targets and equally valid from an ROE perspective (see Surah 9).

Y'shua was (or should I say, still is?) the epitome of one who lives by the Spirit; the historical record indicates that Muhammad was the epitome of one who lives by the flesh.

Answer 3

Very well questions and you have got very well solutions. Bottom line is *no person's superb*. There are severe sins and there are daily sins; regardless sins are sins. This query is a well reminder for us to *observe* that Jesus, Muhammad, Buddha, (the entire enlightened mens) taught us at the same time they had been alive that the Universal God gave *us* the *correct* to LOVE, and did *no longer* deliver us the correct to JUDGE. If WE in all places the sector might be in concord with God, this international might flip again right into a paradise as the way in which of Adam and Eve had.

Answer 4

This is not a direct answer to the original question, but as a Christian, you have got to STOP comparing Mohammed to Jesus. Jesus is our Savior and the son of God. Mohammed is a prophet.

Answer 5

Jesus is from the one true God. the other is of Satan. Look at their prophecy of their end times messiah and look at the book of Revelation.

The reason Jesus was killed is because He had to be. In order to save EVERYONE who wants to be saved, He had to die, to be the perfect sacrifice, the FINAL passover Lamb.

The Jews did not kill Him, He blinded their eyes to the truth so they would push for Him to be killed. It had to be that way.

But don't be confused, they were forgiven before Jesus died. So they are not the "bad guys".

Answer 6

Muhammad is a false prophet. It really bothers me that islam includes previous prophets and Our Savior to mislead people.

God Bless.

Answer 7

The old testament prophets had some serious fights you know.

To be honest, Jesus was probably the most lenient.

Answer 8

in abrahams time

he had 2 babies


ishmael and issac

issac was the descendant of jesus and ishmael was mohammad


the devil used the slightest lie to turn people from the one true LIVING God who is jesus.

Answer 9

Because both religions are full of crap. There is no such thing a Jesus or Muhammed. & for you buybull thumpers this is what god thinks of women & children

In Deuteronomy 22:28-29 it says that if a man rapes a virgin, he must marry her and also pay her father 50 shekels for humbling her. How wild is that, do you think that would fly today?

1 Samuel 18:25-27 may just be one of the most disgusting things ever written. Saul sells his daughter to David. But he didn't want money, noooooo, that would be too normal... he wanted 100 foreskins from Philistine men. David gave him 200 foreskins. What the hell is with foreskins? Couldn't he get ears? Or how about fingers? This is disgusting. And women certainly be offended that one of their kind was traded for 200 bits of severed penises.

Women are below men in the pecking order again in 1 Corinthians 11:3-9 where it is made crystal clear that God over Christ, Christ is over man, and man is over woman. After all man was not created for woman, but woman was created for man.

Women are not allowed to talk in church, in fact the idea of them speaking in church is shameful. This is made very clear in 1 Corinthians 14:34-35. Women are to remain silent, and if they have any questions they are to ask their husbands at home after church.

Not only are women inferior to men, but they should treat their husbands as they treat God. Check this quote out from Ephesians 5:22-24 "wives, submit yourselves unto your own husbands, as unto the Lord. For the husband is the head of the wife, even as Christ is the head of the church: and he is the saviour of the body. Therefore as the church is subject unto Christ, so let the wives be to their own husbands in every thing."

1 Timothy chapter 2 is another chapter that is dedicated to saying women are below men, and also says women are to dress plainly. But let's take a harder look at where women stand in this chapter. It says that women are to learn in silence without subjection... they cannot teach nor "usurp authority over the man". It also makes it clear that Adam was first, then Eve. And the Garden of Eden thing, with the forbidden fruit... well that was 100% Eve's fault. Women are gullible, yet conniving.

It amazes me that there is a women, who could read the teachings of the Holy Bible, and call herself a Christian. How many Christian men are using these teachings to justify abuse? It's sickening.

Exodus 21:15, 17 both say that if a child hits or curses his father, he is to be killed.

Leviticus 20:9 says that if a child curses his mother or father he is to be put to death.

Deuteronomy 21:18-21 requires stoning to death any child who is stubborn or rebellious.

Proverbs 22:15 says you should beat your foolish children with a rod.

And for those who are saying "those are Old Testament laws that no longer apply"

"Full well ye reject the commandment of God, that ye may keep your own tradition. For Moses said, Honour thy father and thy mother; and, Whoso curseth father or mother, let him die the death: But ye say, If a man shall say to his father or mother, It is Corban, that is to say, a gift, by whatsoever thou mightest be profited of me; he shall be set free. And ye suffer him no more to do ought for his father or his mother; Making the word of God of none effect through your tradition, which ye have delivered" -Jesus Christ, as quoted in Mark 7:9-13.

Answer 10

becuase Jesus is God and muhammed is just a man!


God loves you....God bless