How the Americans could understand the big contribution that all immigrants provide to their country?

Question

Please try to be realistic.There is no americans that would work in the fields,the warehouses,manufacturers or the production lines,it's just no way they would do that.U.S. is already paying the price for turning it's back on illegal immigrants.Please recall the full history of the United states and Mexico there were always big tides between them.Even do,I always noticed that all illegal immigrants pay their taxes to u.s goverment,because there is no way you perform in a company without showing a social security number,whichever is fake or good.and all taxes are substracted from the pay check.it's rare that employees pay cash in the U.S.

Answer 1

#1 Yes immigrants do contribute to this country - they can do so as LEGAL immigrants. But you state "to their country?" - if they are illegal immigrants, this is NOT their country. They do tend to send a lot of money back home. One of Mexico's largest source of income is from all the US dollars being sent home by the illegals.
#2 You are wrong about no Americans wanting these jobs. I have personally worked in those areas when younger. The problem is the low wages those industries pay due to the illegals driving wages down.
#3 - Big tides? What are you talking about?
#4 Yes illegal aliens do pay sales taxes etc. MOST companies do subtract payroll taxes applying them to fake Social Security #'s.
#5 "it's rare that employees pay cash in the U.S." - Do you mean employers???

Answer 2

OK you pay no income tax that not helpful and your 39 child that refuse to learn english so we have to hire pay for a teacher that can tech them not helpful and you own no property so you dont pay property tax either on that either that is not help you get free healthcare we pay for thats not helpful and the the hospital are closing because your not paying your fare share thats not helpful and making it hard for everyone and the waiting is take so long poeple are die in the ER waitind for there turn that really not helpful ! And the wellfare line is over load with your people that are here to work that a joke and very un helpful see how you ve payed no thing but we do that real not help because we need to make up the wage that you drive down instead of up thank your so much nothelpful and the jail and prison are overful with your poeple and that real not helpful ether see how that come out my check my health ins keeps going up because your freeloading and your bring disease over the broder that real is not helpful and your say your doing the work we dont want to do WHO THE BLank was doing before you got and this is the one really gets me out 35milion of u so call worker the no onr to pick the fruit and the veg and dieing in the field this not not help and why you say your here in the first place is that helpful and the farmer are loss the property to the banks because your not helping really not helpful and we import are food from china depending on them and money goes to them and we are getting sick and die because they have no care for us this so not helpful and this is just a few why dont you list some that your helping us with we why dont you people go home all 35 miilon of and make your country a better place and be a great nation and we can do more good for each other instead of listen to your demands this would be REAL HELP FOR U AND ME!!!!!!

Answer 3

Excuse me, but I work on a production line. So do THOUSANDS of Americans. Thousands more would be if criminaliens didn't come here and steal our jobs. A plant in New Bedford MA recently got raided and over 350 criminaliens got arrested. Guess what? The plant opened the very next day, with all new employees, ALL LEGAL.

IF you are holding a Social Security card and are illegal, that is FRAUD and you should be in prison on felony charges. Any company who is hiring criminaliens should be fined as such under the current laws of this country.

Answer 4

This myth about no-one else performing some of the work that mexicans do is just that, a myth. We got along before without them and we will get along in the future just fine without them. AND...... What many forget is that there are Millions of illegals standing on corners every day in the USA waiting for someone to come along and hire them for a "day" job. These are "cash under the table" jobs where no taxes are paid. Then they go to the Post Office and I have to issue them a money order to send back home to Mexico. The "do gooders" have to wake up and admit that Illegals are hurting all the rest of us.

Answer 5

Nonsense.
Total myth, lies and fraudulent half-truths.
Cash in hand is the way it has always been done as it is untraceable- and most illegals do not have US bank accounts.
Production lines can be automated, as can farm harvesting- look at Australia and Japan for good examples.

Furthermore, up until 1960 the population of the US was 90% white, 9% black and 1% other- including Hispanics and Asians. 1960's were the high-mark of US society- full employment , a massive economy and well-respected and very positive reputation world-wide (even the Soviet's admired the US of the 1960s). The US GDP per capita was at the highest ever and has not ever returned. Only Japan has managed to attain such a high GDP per capita.

After the traitor Ted Kennedy allowed the borders to be opened in 1965 to all manner of low-grade imports- the nation steadily went downhill.

Now US wages are as low as 1931 in proportion to Cost of Living and also as a percentage of GDP.

Thanks Mexico for stuffing up the Economy with low-grade, low-skill rapid-breeding nitwits.

Illegals= TRESPASSING CRIMINALS and JOB-STEALER'S

Answer 6

I believe that Americans would do the jobs that you have mentioned if they were paid a decent wage. I believe that the companies that hire illegal immigrants do so because they are looking to pay less for the work that they need performed.

Answer 7

No problem with LEGAL immigrants.

Major problems with ILLEGAL ALIENS:

The biggest "contribution" that I see is they have singlehandedly driven the wages down on jobs Americans WOULD do if the criminals who hire illegals didn't hire them.

Probably the next largest "contribution" is the social services that are denied to LEGAL citizens as a result of illegals leeching off OUR system.

Shall I go on or are you getting the picture yet?

What part of ILLEGAL don't you understand?

Answer 8

The US Government census counted Mexican as White, And some as black until the mid 1970s. When they included the "Hispanic" Category to the census, So all Census results until the Census of 1980 Mexican Americans were included as Whites.

The Bracero Act (guess worker Program) was in Effect from 1942-1965, The passage of Civil right legislation in 1965. ended discrimination in Employment. Which also started the Unionization of Mexican and Filipinos workers in the United Farm Workers Union.

It is true undocumented are doing the jobs that are not wanted by Americans. Many jobs are available now if the Americans wanted to do them, They are not applying for them, and they won't!

Los Angeles Times/Bloomberg poll - June 7-10 2007

"do you think illegal immigrants mostly take jobs that nobody wants or do they mostly take jobs away from Americans who needs them"

jobs no body......take jobs
wants.................away...... Both.....unsure
56%................27%......11%........6%
http://www.pollingreport.com/immigration.htm

Answer 9

You are wrong. Illegal aliens are driven by greed as are those who hire them. These are not people who 'contribute' to anyone or anything that they cannot benefit from directly. I would bet that if an employer knows that an employee is an illegal alien they are only showing income taxes are removed from the employees check but are not submitting them to the government. this is the mentality of illegal aliens and those who hire them. It is all about them.

Answer 10

Virtually everything you said is untrue. You are either grossly misinformed or just a liar. Americans understand perfectly well what the so called 'contribution' of illegal alien invaders from Mexico is. A 80 billion dollar cost to the US taxpayer.