According to logic...?

Question

if ~X then X is true if ~X is false
therefore
If "God doesn't exist" then "God exist" is true if "God doesn't exist".

Go ahead, pull out your Logic 101 textbook, guys and gals...

I really just wanted to see how the answer differ when this question was switched around...it is a pointless question. Like saying if x is true, then 'not' x is false.

http://answers.yahoo.com/question/index;_ylt=AqY.1biQ0oMFGt.LlXzWJuLty6IX;_ylv=3?qid=20071102082440AADcMXc&show=7#profile-info-uFRZGW85aa

Answer 1

Stupidest thing I have ever seen...

Answer 2

Sarcasm is the bottom variety of wit and in easy words an fool would assume that all and multiple which will be customary is already customary. i assumed that at your age (glaring out of your avatar) you would have outgrown infantile nonsense. first of all enable me inform you that God will be shown scientifically. 2d enable me inform you that issues we usually evaluate no longer obtainable like being in additional advantageous than one position jointly, or vacationing in time, really takes position billions of cases each and every second. This bizzarre international of god and impossibility is termed quantum physics. Now wait a short at the same time as longer at the same time as QP finishes it is experiments and it is going to coach you God. you could sit down there like an overgrown baby believing you're so smart, at the same time as the likes of me pity you. yet remember you do not understand each and every thing and by technique of pretending you do you merely make sure how ignorant you truly are. attempt questioning up some smart, grown up questions which have purpose except to placed human beings down.

Answer 3

You're making the assumption that God doesn't exist is false. You can't just jump to conclusions like that. Even though the argument is valid. It is very very bad.

Answer 4

If the bible is the inspired word of God, then it must be true and God must exist. If God exists, then the bible is his inspired word and is indubitably true. But if the bible is true that means God must exist and must have written the bible as his inspired word. Therefore, (a priori AND a posteriori) if the bible is the inspired word of God, it must be true and He must exist! Yay!! I proved it!!
(Aristotle would not approve, but he was a pagan.)

Answer 5

Your initial premise is false.

'God doesn't exist' does not equal 'God exists'.

There is no need for the 'if' statement.

Its like stating if ice = fire, then water = fire.

Which would be logical, accept that fire doesn't equal water to begin with, so the whole premise is not needed.

Answer 6

you posted this earlier today. While true, what does it matter? This is completely trivial.

edit: ok, except that your explanation is wrong... it should be:

If "God doesn't exist" then "God exist" is true if "God doesn't exist" is false.

The logical structure is:

~X -> (~~X -> X)

since ~~X->X is a tautology, any implication which ends with it is a tautology as well.

Answer 7

So your saying if I can't think logically then god is true?

Sounds about right to me.

Answer 8

God exists until I have proof he doesnt :P Everything is designed ! so x = what ever you want it to .

Answer 9

Blah blah blah.... come back after you've grown a brain.

(I'm beginning to suspect that you're an atheist who's trolling to make theists look bad.)

Answer 10

oh really?makes a bit of sense for a sec

Answer 11

well that the same as when there is dark ther would be light
love to hate
born to die

And above all life to death....