Do Christians owe the Jews Israel because their messiah caused the dispersion of Jews from their holy land?

Question

Jesus caused destruction by the sword to Israel, the dispersion of those left, and their humiliation.

Answer 1

Jesus didn't cause it; the Romans did. You need to go back and read some history; the Jews weren't forced out of Israel until around 70C.E. - forty or so years after Jesus died. The Ha-Mered Ha-Gadol ("the great revolt") of the Jews occurred between 66 - 70 C.E., and culminated with the destruction of the second Temple (of which the "Wailing Wall" in Isreal is the only part still standing), the Bar Kochba Rebellion (about 132 C.E.) and the fall of Masada, and the dispersion of the Jews, AFTER the Romans massacred or enslaved many, of course.

The Christians don't owe us a thing, and for our part, we generally don't really have a lot to do with them.

Answer 2

Palestine 5000 years ago passed by Jerusalem escaping his people Ibrahim (a s) he was welcomed as a guest over here by king Salem which later the city carried his name as city of Salem oor salem later jerusalem he bought a piece of land in hebron and lived south of hebron were later his grand son left to Egypt and have that luxury life for almost 2000 years and once they were ill treated they came to Palestine capturing the land ,to do so it took them over a hundred years and again they bought a piece of land to build a temple which later they were expelled and the temple was distructed 2000 years later they again but this time with the help of big powers in the world contradicting with the previous history were big powers was not in favor with them and again they captured the land but again not all the land the same as 2000 years ago strange enough those who denied Palestine all knows the fights of shamshoon the fights of david(a.s.) its sham which means lebanon syria palestine all through generations lliking to arabs unity it occurs 1958 between syria and egypt and the new country has got a name different than syria or egypt but rarly forign people can understand the meaning of unity between arabs or may be they do understand it but hate having such a thing happening

Answer 3

No. The Christians do not owe the Jews anything. The focus is on God, and what He will do with Israel in Zechariah 14, which is coming soon.

Answer 4

Abraham and Sarah had only one child and that was Isaac.
Abraham and a servant had a child too and that was Ishmael.

Isaac was the ancestor of the Christians.
Ishmael was the ancestor of the Muslims.

Now, Abraham was promised a land to be occupied by his ancestors. But, he had two sons. The other legitimate and the other illegitimate. But no matter, both were his sons. Now, the confusion is.

Who shall have the promised land.......

The descendants of Isaac or Ishmael?

Answer 5

NO.

The Jews failed to recognize Jesus as the Messiah and God removed His protection from them. Disastrous results followed naturally.

United Nations re-established the nation after WWII.

Answer 6

This had to do with Bar Kokhba, not Jesus. In 132 AD the second Jewish revolt against Rome, lead by Bar Kokhba, had disastrous results for the Jewish population.

Answer 7

Be Carefull !
God give the Jews the deed to Israel. That's the only land to be recorded In the Bible where God forever give the deed to land. It was and still Is the Jews !
In trying to part this land will bring the Hand of God and His wrath.

Answer 8

Jesus didn't cause the destructi of Jews but he prophesied what was to happen.

Answer 9

The Lord is the caretaker of the Jews. As much as they have suffered, they will be equally compensated. God's timeframe is different from your 2 dimensional understanding.

Answer 10

That is an incorrect assertion on both counts.