What's God's reason for aborting babies by miscarriage?

Question

Saw it on a question earlier, someone said it was for a reason. What reason is that? And perhaps when a woman has an abortion, it is what is meant for her to do?

Answer 1

God has nothing to do with it

The commonest cause of miscarriage is a genetic abnormality of the feotus. A hormonal imbalance in the mother can cause it as can an emotional disturbance. Over-enthusiastic sexual intercourse, abnormalities of the uterus, drugs and medical disorders in the mother can also be a cause. Trauma such as a motor car accident can bring on a miscarriage in what was going to be a normal pregnancy.

Sometimes the cervix does not completely seal as it should once pregnancy is established. If this happens then a miscarriage can occur, generally after the 12th week.

Answer 2

There are some Christians who
say (because they have been
taught) that everything that
happens in any life and especially a Christian's life, is
because God has ordained it and caused it to happen. that is far from the truth. that would make us all puppets on
a string and God moves us about here and there as He
wills.
the truth about miscarriage
is that the egg or the sperm
was imperfect and so it was
flushed out of the body. God
did give us the perfect way to
make babies and if that deviates in any harmful way,
it usually miscarries...sometimes not.
These people usually say when someone dies,"Oh that
was God's will". that's hogwash and a lie. There are
a million reasons why that
person died, none having to
do with god's will.

Answer 3

In the world things happen.Should we blame God for it? Why does deceases come.Why do we loose what we love the most? Is it a testing of ones faith or is it a sin we have done?
The body has a function and just like anything else it can abort a kidney or child,or life. Does it have to be a reasoning behind it? God said just follow me! We go through things we do not understand but he says just follow me. People may say that it was our fault. But God said follow me. You may lose something,but God says follow me. As people we make bad decisions and abortions my have been one of them.Yet Jesus said follow me. God sends a comforter for these storms and recovery from sins. Does it matter what is said about us? God said come to me. It is him that gives us rest.
God knew it would happen and he knew already what to do. Isaiah 53. He died just for this reason. He justified our life and we are vindicated from the pain we endure.

Answer 4

Miscarriages have various motives for occurring. one component i learnt is with reference to the genetic code for one. If some thing is going incorrect at concept with the matching up of genetic code form the mothers and dads (could nicely be random, or pre deposition, not mothers and fathers fault). If the DNA would not journey suited the newborn won't be able to advance suited, so the newborn will miscarriage.

Answer 5

It's simple: because of man's sin. It's due to man's fallen nature since the beginning of time: Adam and Eve. God doesn't 'kill' babies. Miscarriages happen as a result of sin as well. Just as people are prone to disease and illnesses, women are prone to having miscarriages. We are all human and are fallible; subject to pain, sickness, sorrow, etc. - all due to the fallen nature of man. God is the Creator and thus, is the ONLY one who has the right to take away life, except for the death penalty, which He has given man the right to carry out as the ultimate punishment for murder. As the bible says, the hairs on our head are numbered, meaning that we all have an appointed time to die. Whenever our time is up on this earth, that's it.

Answer 6

Hi, thanks for asking. I will answer as best I can from a Christian point of view.

If I understand your question, it seems you are asking whether it is fair for God to kill, and what this has to do with us having the choice to kill or not. Or put another way, I might ask: Why can God kill while we are forbidden to?

Or perhaps you are merely asking the reason why God does certain things. If this is true, and you are asking why God does certain things, I confess that I do not know, partly because that question becomes very hypothetical.

So then, why can God kill? Why isn't He held to the same standard as us? If He can kill, then why can't we?

These questions have to do with a few things. Who is God? God is perfect, holy, merciful. He is just; that is, He judges sin. God is our Creator. God is the one that created us and set up our rules. He is not held to the rules that He set up for us to follow. Case in point: "You shall not murder." This commandment forbids murder in all its forms, including abortion. Based on this, we can conclude that it is not right for us to abort a child.

We are also not to attempt to usurp authority over God. We like to think that we can predict God or do things better than Him. We want to be God. This was part of the temptation offered to Eve in the Garden: The serpent said that she and Adam would become "like God, knowing good and evil" if they disobeyed God's commands. We are prideful and foolish to think these things, because God's ways are higher than ours. We like to think that we should control our own biology and 'edit' the world as we see fit, whether it means hurting other people, dishonoring God, or whatever.

Is God wrong when He judges sin? Or is He wrong when He has mercy on one person and not another? In essence, isn't God free to exercise His own will in whatever way He wants? The answer to the last question is yes. We know that He is good. We should not question His motives, because His mind is higher than ours and entirely pure. For Him to be wrong would be a contradiction to His character. By contrast, it's entirely easy and common for us humans to mess up.

I apologize that I cannot answer this question more thoroughly. There is more that I could write, but I do not know if you will receive what I have already put here. I can't know because this is just Y! Answers, not a continuing dialogue. But if you would like to continue this discussion, send me an email. I will get back to you if and when I can.

May God bless you.

Answer 7

Ah yes...same thing with cloning:

"We shouldn't play God"

"Well, didn't he give us dominion over the Earth? Also, if God didn't want us to do this, why would he give us the capabilities for us to?"

"Uh...well, you still shouldn't do it!! It's wrong against God!!!"

"And have you spoken to the Big Man lately? In person?"

See...it could be used for a myriad of things. I agree, if there is a God, and if he miscarriages them "for a reason" maybe it's his will for that woman to have an abortion....ah well...I doubt you'll get many positive answers from theists here....good luck and hope this helps! ^_^

Answer 8

Ummm. GOD doesn't abort babies. Any death is not by God's hand. Satan is the whole reason behind death in the first place. God created us to live in Eden. Adam and Eve chose poorly and now humanity is doomed to suffer death at one time or another. I do believe that the souls of miscarried babies go to heaven. God is faithful, he is taking care of all of His children, born and unborn. if anyone is to blame for death, evil and suffering it is Satan himself.

Answer 9

Look up the definition of the word abort. Its not the same as Miscarriage.

Answer 10

God does not cause suffering or death. He just allows it as remedial suffering, that Mankid will repent as one. Mankind is a corporate being in relation to God. It is everybody's fault that the innocent suffer or die. Because of the sinfulness of this world, the fault of everybody, evil entered and got a good grasp. Now it sows suffering everywhere. Even if you're a saint, you can be attacked. Why? Because you are its enemy.