is there real proof that prayer has achieved any thing?

Question

i just looked on the answers to someone elses question and was shocked to see how many people said prayng could remove evil from the earth. People cant honestly believe that can they. It seems like the thing someone would do if they claimed to want to help others but cant be bothered

but what you claim to be evidence of prayers working could just be evidence Psycho-Kinesis (PK). what i mean is ther proof that god answers our prayers or is it the power of our mind that achieves things. which is no more of a miracle than changing something with your hand

Answer 1

The 1986 Philippine EDSA Revolution

The Philippines is regarded as the only Catholic nation in Asia. The Filipinos have been suffering for 20 years of tyranny. So on Feb. 22, 1986, the Archbishop of Manila called all the people to go into the streets for prayer. The people armed with rosaries and prayer faced the soldiers armed with high-powered guns in the streets. The people then asked the soldiers to pray with them. The high-ranking officials of the army were just waiting for the President to say one word and they will kill all the people in the streets. But on Feb. 25, 1986, after three days of praying in the streets of Manila, the president decided to just leave the country. God has answered the prayers of the Filipinos. It was a bloodless and prayerful revolution won by the people of God.

The Battle of Lepanto

In 1571, The Ottoman Turks had this mighty fleet. It was even considered invincible during that time. The Turkish fleet has even 12,000-15,000 Christian slaves as their rowers. They were closing in to Europe for the Islamic conversion of the land. Knowing, that the Christian forces were at a distinct material disadvantage, St. Pope Pius V called for all Europe to pray the rosary. And on October 7, 1571, the Christians forces crushed the mighty Turkish fleet preventing the Islamic Invasion of Europe. At the hour of victory, St. Pope Pius V, who was hundreds of miles away at the Vatican, is said to have gotten up from a meeting, went over to a window, and exclaimed with supernatural radiance: "The Christian fleet is victorious!" and shed tears of thanksgiving to God.

Both the Filipinos and the Christian forces prayed the rosary of the Blessed Virgin Mary. As Catholics, we do not worship Mary but ask for her prayers. It is the same thing that Christians ask another Christian to pray for them.

These are real proofs that prayer has achieved glory!

Answer 2

Well, I agree that praying can't remove evil from the earth. After all, according to Isaiah (a book Christians love to use and misuse while ignoring certain key verses in the text) God creates evil. So praying against it wouldn't be of any use...

I think prayer works if you're convinced of it. Not because I think God necessarily processes every single prayer and "makes it happen." I believe the human mind, when in the right place and in the right attitude, can accomplish many things. Try praying for the oppurtunity of a new job. If you believe in your prayer, you'll notice all sorts of oppurtunities you hadn't before. Is that because God is answering or because your mind has been made more alert by the mental programming of the prayer? Hm...

Answer 3

a million) this is the main powerful factor. it somewhat is a team of historic injuries that one particular eschatological sect from the middle east grew to dominate most of the Western international. Had some battles at night a protracted time long gone yet another direction, we would all be worshipping Odin and Thor now, in line with danger in a "state-of-the-artwork" metaphorical experience... 2) Even worse: in case you tell a ill guy or woman who a lot of persons are praying for him/her, it could unquestionably make the guy experience worse because of the fact the guy thinks "Oh no, i'm so ill that persons could pray for me?". there's a reason human beings say "we've tried each and every thing, now we are able to basically pray". 3) that may no longer a stable disprove. it could additionally propose that God is a dick or merely does not care. 4) See form 3. in line with danger he merely can't be bothered. 5) good factor. will we hassle what some undiscovered tribes interior the Amazon jungle think of regarding the universe, the cosmos, morality and the afterlife? No. So we would desire to continually no longer hassle what some illiterate tribes interior the middle east concept regarding the universe, the cosmos, morality and the afterlife. 6) They evidence that we don't might desire to hypothesize a god and are subsequently important factors. interior the comparable way that we don't might desire to hypothesize a god to describe thunder and lightning. 7) particular. some human beings won't be able to admit to no longer having the answer to a minimum of a few thing. A scientist will actually permit you realize "we don't understand this yet" while confronted with a tough question. cheating human beings will invent a narrative and because all of us do no longer understand the main suitable answer yet, we haven't have been given any thank you to disprove them. As an atheist, i do no longer believe that there is a god, for comparable motives to those you have shown above. i might opt to function one factor: all the demands and regulations of god, the "will of god", is so needless to say aligned to the demands and the choose of the clerical caste that it would be truthfully sparkling that he's a fabrication via some clever yet unethical human beings to get what they choose.

Answer 4

There is no proof because evil is not something you can touch, measure, and study.

It´s not easy to pray for another person. It takes time, concentration, and beleif that your prayer is actually heard.
Religious people beleive they are depriving the world of something very important if they don´t pray. It´s done in good intention - in friendship. If you don´t think you need it, you can still accept the good intention. no?

If a religious person can´t be bothered to help another than he should pray that he might not be so lazy.

Answer 5

There is no verifiable evidence that prayer has ever achieved anything outside of the mind of the person praying.

The most common use for prayer is to ask a god to heal someone who is ill, or perhaps dying. There have been several scientific studies which clearly show that prayer has absolutely no effect on healing. Here's a fairly recent one;
http://www.livescience.com/strangenews/ap_060330_prayer.html

Answer 6

evil cant truly b removed from the earth, not now, not by us. not even by praying 2 He who can. evil will b here on this world till its last day, evil is wat makes the world, the world, without it, it would b heaven. i can under stand where u got that last thought. looking at a person praying at the altar, u wouldnt think it would b all that hard 4 them, not much of a sacrifice. but as 4 me and my church, we pray till it hurts we get up and shout 2 God. we literally cry out. and heres the trick, we pray 4 things like healing and miracles, things we cant do ourselfs. but when we can physically make the effort to help someone, we pray that God would let us do that and give us the strength 2 get it done. ppl have been healed, parlized ppl, drug addicts, ppl with mental stuff. i could fit in a few catagories myself.

Answer 7

yes, there have been studies where groups of patients were divided into groups in order to discover if people praying for them made any significant difference in their health or speed of recovery. There were people who were being prayed for who knew it, and others who did not know it. The people doing the praying did not know or have any contact with the people they were praying for. And of course there was a group that no one was specifically praying for, including themselves. Results have shown that groups of people being prayed for, knowingly or unknowingly, have less complications, better health, and speedier recoveries then those who had no one praying for them. Possible explanations were given for the results, maybe a higher power, maybe positive energy, things like that, but the surprising results were undeniable.

As far as personally. I am living walking breathing typing proof that prayer achieved something. I was diagnosed with a rare fatal disease which the doctors said had no cure. I was supposed to be dead in a matter of hours. My parents refused to believe this, and yes they prayed intensely for me. They prayed to Jesus, and to the amazement of the hospital staff everything wrong with me went away in less than one day. Proof that prayer can work, and in my opinion, if there is a God, it's the God of the Bible, the One who claims nothing is impossible or too difficult for Him.

Answer 8

Prayer can achieve many things, although maybe not anything or everything. Not everything people pray for comes to pass (thank goodness). But in my personal experience, which unfortunately not able to verify, prayer does work.

Answer 9

If you are predetermined that you will put all evidence down to PK or coincidence, why ask?
My life has been turned around by prayer.

Answer 10

Yes, prayer has achieved something. I have had many prayers answered.
Our principal asked us to pray for her Mother in Law. The doctors found a large mass in her colon and had to remove it. She asked us to pray that it was not malignant. We did. When they did the surgery, it turned out that it wasn't even cancer. It was diverticulitis. The surgeon said he had never seen a mass that big not be cancer.

I had hundereds of polyps in my colon and had to have an ileostomy...12 inches of my large intestine removed as well as my rectum. People prayed for me. There was NO cancer anywhere.
He was able to build a new rectum, so I only had to have a colostomy bag for 4 months while it was healing.

This is proof for me and proof for many others.

Whether or not you accept is is not my problem. Believe it or not. I don't care.