Am I the only one who think Brodeur is overrated?

Question

I know I'm not going to have a lot of friends for asking this, nor do I expect many people to agree with And don't go and call me ignorant. I follow hockey more than most people. As much as I try to be I just never am as impressed with the guy as everyone else to agree with me. I think he just got lucky to be drafted by a team that only gives up 18 shots a game. If Roy or Hasek were on a team like that, they'd have twice as many cups and twice as many shutouts. Of all the goalies in the league i'd pick Luongo then maybe Lundqvist, Miller, or Hasek. When has Brodeur ever beaten Roy or Hasek? Exactly. The Save% speaks for itself. Wins aren't everything. If Roy or Hasek were to play as long as Brodeur then they'd easily have that wins record that Brodeur WILL break unless NJ starts giving up shots because whenever the Devils flop, Brodeur is the reason...just look it up.
Don't get me wrong, Brodeur is a great goalie but to consider him the greatest I think is going off the wall.

Answer 1

You are not the only one.

Answer 2

Well he is getting a bit old now so much of your reasoning is wrong. He was always overshadowed by Roy and Hasek. He probably isn't the best now, again he is getting kind of old. He will still continue playing and will eventually hold every single record. The ones he does not have he is in second and not too far off....check those stats.

So because he played on a great team he isn't the best goalie ever? Don't tell "The Great One" that....I guess the Oilers were a really bad team during their dynasty which saw them go to the playoffs like 10 years in a row and win 4 of 5 Stanley Cup titles.

Roy always had an awesome team around him....with Colorado most of his players were in the Olympics...that is pretty damn good. In Montreal the team won the Stanley Cup (he was a rookie). Even when he was on the Canadiens who had no great goal scorers they had an excellent defense that took them to the playoffs.

I am done telling you how wrong you are. You should follow hockey some more than because your rant didn't impress me. I am not a historian by any means but I know you need to show some support when you try to leave all these facts. Save % isn't the only thing that makes a goalie.

Answer 3

Brodeur will never be overrated, with all he has accomplished throughout his long career. Brodeur is keeping up with kids half his age, so being overrated is not the term i would ever use when speaking of Brodeur. Also Brodeur stacks the pads because he has been playing hockey for 20 years. Back when he was growing up every goalie including Patrick Roy (Brodeur's idle) was a stand-up goalie. This is just how they play the game. Brodeur never liked the butterfly style of play that developed in the late 90's, therefore he is the last goalie who will stand up to make a save! Plus with all Brodeur has accomplished looking good is the least on his mind, he just wants to win Lord Stanley's Cup, one more time!

Answer 4

In the event that you realized a premier doing baseball team was enjoying an underperforming one, the most obvious bet would be on the most effective performing team. But what if your plumped for staff only sidelined its three most readily useful people through new injuries could they be this type of powerful challenger to get that fit today? Zcodes System, from here https://tr.im/An1ob , will give you all that type of information to be able to have better chances of earning the bets.
The activities in Zcodes System are opted for in order that allow you to engage in high size betting at bookies because of their acceptance and are chosen using around 80 various variables that govern each sport such as for instance: player situations, accidents, staff choice, house or away team, goalies, past efficiency, predicted potential performance, coaches, functions, importance of match, rivalries and a great deal more
This is where a little bit of understanding may and almost always will derail you and where a large amount of in-depth, as much as the minute information may make you a winner. Time and time again.

Answer 5

Overated? Brodeur can win games by himself, he had 12 shutouts last year. Over 10 percent of his games have been shutouts(92 in 882 starts). He has average 24 shots against per game, not the 18 as you suggest. His highest season GAA as a starter is 2.57 and lowest is 1.88. He has to make the stops, since his team doesn't score much either. He may not be the greatest, but definitely a top 5.

Answer 6

After your stats, I had to look them up

Brodeur and Roy went head to head 9 times.
New Jersey won 6 of those games, including 2 shutouts.

Brodeur and Hasek have went head to head 13 times.
New Jersey won 8 of those games. Hasek had 2 shutouts.

Since you brought up the stats, let's compare the 3 with their all-time ranking in parentheses for goalies with 350 or more games)
Goals Against Average
2.20 Martin Brodeur (9th)
2.21 Dominik Hasek (10th)
2.54 Patrick Roy (87th)

Save Percentage
0.923 Dominik Hasek (1st)
0.913 Martin Brodeur (6th)
0.910 Patrick Roy (18th)

Shutouts/Games Played
9.17 Dominik Hasek (6th)
9.71 Martin Brodeur (9th)
15.59 Patrick Roy (27th)

Winning Percentage
0.553 Martin Brodeur (11th)
0.535 Patrick Roy (41st)
0.522 Dominik Hasek (58th)

So, using the 4 parameters that equalize everything, Brodeur finishes ahead of Roy on all counts. In almost all cases, significantly better.

Hasek has a superior save percentage than Roy AND faces more shots a game. Roy on average only faced 3 shots a game more than Brodeur. (28.27 vs 25.31)

Personally, I feel Brodeur and Hasek are both better goaltenders than Roy. I even thought of putting in Ed Belfour's numbers as well because his were better than Roy's. Prior to the 'big-pad era, Belfour's numbers were significantly better than Roy's.

Answer 7

Zcodes System is an extensive activities investing plan that was created to give you suggestions about what sports events to bet on and those that in order to avoid so that you have greater possibilities at wining.
Zcodes System, the program that you will find here https://tr.im/XecE6 is analyzing a huge database composed of 13 years'value of activities knowledge and spits out its forecast centered with this evidence.
Zcodes provides forecasts on all key U.S. activities including the NBA, MLB, NHL, or NFL.

Answer 8

Forget the Cups for a second. The fact that the guy has won an Olympic gold medal and lead Canada to the World Cup means nothing? Or how about the fact that he wears next to nothing for protection just to be more mobile playing his position?

Answer 9

he is a system goalie...He is good, but they play such a boring style of hockey they keep all his shots to the perimeter
See what happens when they get him in wide open hockey games

Answer 10

No, occassionaly we see other uninformed or foolish people make the same claim here.