why do non-Catholics feel the need to bash the Catholic Church?

Question

I asked the people who converted to Catholicism, but the Catholic-bashers took it as an opportunity to bash the Catholic Church. http://answers.yahoo.com/question/index;_ylt=AgkD37ryQvjhZ_NQgDNhzuvsy6IX;_ylv=3?qid=20070926134137AAPxuxe

I think they don't really understand the question, or they are just so high-opinionated that they think their opinions really matter. well, they doesn't!

.
edit: "their opinions DON'T matter".

they shouldn't impose it on others who don't even want to hear it.
.

trevor22in, because their opinions are taking up space.

CJ, I think your aim is to piss off the Catholics. you're just as uneducated as you sound. no more words to you. you're not worthy of my precious time.

agnostic boy, what are you doing in the Catholic Church then if you feel so unhappy being in it? by all means, leave the Church, no one's stopping you.

Answer 1

I agree. Drives me nutty how many of them spread out right lies about Catholics. I always jump to thier defense.

Answer 2

enable me answer this one. a million. Do you think of Atheists are good human beings, or purely all immorral trash? To be basic, my opinion of atheists dropped for the reason that coming right here. some are cool, yet I see way too lots hate to place you men back up interior the severe status you have been in until eventually now. 2. If I ask a query approximately Christianity, is this an attack on Christians considering the fact this is coming from a non-Christian, even thou somebody who's a Christian might have asked an identical question? relies upon on the style you ask it. i've got seen some polite questions (ie, a real choose to appreciate the respond) and a few impolite questions (ie, the two "trust me in bashing this faith" or "i do no longer choose to appreciate the respond different than to make exciting of this faith"). i will gladly answer any question i will while it rather is asserted with courtesy. 3. Is there a distinction between asking a query approximately Christianity, and making an attack on a Christian or Christians regularly? See above 4. once you're saying that we non-Christians are bashing you, what in particular does that mean, what's an occasion of "bashing". you choose the record? I for one am bored with seeing hateful questions that proclaim my faith (or any faith) as a delusion, a crutch for the susceptible minded, stupid, stupid, out dated, the gadget of idiots, ignorant, hateful, bloody, spewing rubbish, and so on. So what, you do in contrast to or trust my faith or the different, yet tutor some comprehend and that i will return the choose. 5. Do you finally end up asking the question, "If guy got here from monkeys, why are there nonetheless monkeys" or "Why do no longer we see monkeys/apes evolving in the present day". Curious, do you ever ask that when which study Evolutionist's solutions? I study them. I usually end after seeing the 1st "What a stupid Christian" remark. i'm getting much less ulsers that way.

Answer 3

The Catholic Church? "Catholic" just means "Universal". When you say "non-Catholic" do you mean unbelievers &/or Christians from denominations other than Roman Catholic?

Well, one reason might be that we're all sinners. Another, that a lot of former Roman Catholics have been hurt by that church body whether they are believers or unbelievers. Another reason, although this may be less common, is that a Christian may feel that his/her brother/sister in Christ who belongs to the Roman Catholic Church is being fed a bill of goods & wants them to hear the pure Law of God & the pure Gospel of our Lord Jesus Christ. There are many heretical, anti-biblical teachings in the Roman Catholic Church, that have & continue to hurt people in a very deep & in some cases eternal way.

Look at it this way. You have a little brother whom you love dearly. You know & see how others are deceiving him with half truths (which are much of the time more dangerous than outright lies). These lies are likely if not certain to lead your little brother into a long period of emotional, spiritual & perhaps even physical suffering. Wouldn't you want to defend your brother against the lies being told him by revealing them for what they really are--lies?

If I bash something that the Roman Catholic Church teaches, this is my reason.

Answer 4

Anti-Catholic rhetoric is just that - rhetoric. Hate for all things Catholic - and the hate shows.
Very often claims to the effect that Catholics believe X or Y are completely false. Claims that Catholics do this or do that are just as false. For example, Catholics DO NOT worship statues. Catholics DO NOT worship Mary and Catholics ARE encouraged to read Sacred Scripture.

The hatred is unjustified - but it's there and you can see it.

Answer 5

I'm catholic and the thing is that I don't go hijackin' airplanes and killing hundreds of people just 'cus my holy book says so, bombing entire cities because I don't like my neighbors or having a TV program for raising money saying that the end is near in order to live in Beverly Hills, Having 5 wifes and sing Osmond Bros. songs or Living in a comune where 1800's hasn't went away, etc. etc. etc.... so this is my answer, any of you can interpretate it as you wish!!!

Answer 6

Because they know their own manmade tradition came into existence through a rebellion against the Catholic Church, in direct violation of the stated will of God, "that they all may be one". Therefore they are hard pressed to show that what they rebelled against was REALLY BAD. Because, if the Catholic Church is all it claims to be, and all that history plainly reveals it to be, then it was their rebellion that was REALLY BAD, and the doctrinal chaos that has resulted from it cannot be the will of God.

Answer 7

I'd ask you why the Catholic Church feels the need to bash anybody who isn't Catholic...You know, the Pope saying that all other religions are inherently inferior, that sort of thing...Of course, maybe the Church is so high-opinionated that they think their opinions really matter...

Answer 8

I am not a Catholic, and I have never bashed the Catholic Church or any other church.

Answer 9

Lets see, they have killed indesrciminantly for centuries, they supported Hilter in WWII, they support the mafia in the US and in most of the world. They kill Popes when they try to reform the church, they talked Kennedy into invading Viet Nam to return land to the good catholics that Ho Chi Min took from them to give back to the people they stole it from, - do you have a few more hours.

Answer 10

the reason non-catholics (and some catholics as well) have a beef with the catholic church is because of all the mounting corruption found in it ever since the early days of its existence. not only this, but the fact that most of their practices are seen as irrelevant and unnecessary.

Answer 11

I'm a non-catholic (atheist) and I don't bash catholics - I often bash the bishop, though...