If God is a limitless being, Then God is nothing? Agree/Disagree?

Question

P1. Everything that exist has a limit.
P2. The limits of things that exist, Gives existing things an Identity.
P3. Everything that exist has an Identity.
P4 God is said to be a limitless being.
P5. God has no Identitiy,
Conclusion, God does not exist.

When I say I exist, there are billions upon billions of things that I`am not!
I was not born in Tehran, I do not have red Hair, I was not born in the 2nd century, I`am not a women etc..... etc... etc...
When one compares our limitations to the things we are, We get our identity.
I`am 25 years old. My hair is brown, I`am a black man etc... etc...

To talk of limitless beings and/or things is to talk of "Nothing." Nothing does not apply to anything. It has no limitations. Everything that does exist (Trees, Animals, Plants, Humans), has many limitations.Therefore to say that God is a limitless being, one is suggesting that God is "Nothing.

Answer 1

Arrr, it's a scurvy dog that starts an arguement from a scallywag false.

P1 thru 3 are not valid, therefore any conclusion you reach is true, i.e. If false then true. I'll leave it to you to prove the falseness for yourself, but consider numbers....

Even the assumption "nothing" is limitless is false. It is limited by whatever something that happens to exist.

Given all this, supreme beings still do not exist.

Answer 2

Hello;

I will try and answer your question. You must understand that God or the Supreme Being if you like. Is neither bound by time or space. He is everywhere at the same time. He is ALL knowing, ALL powerful. He existed for eons before anyone or anything. We cannot fully understand the whole nature of God.
He is an example, we can feel the wind, but we do not know where it comes from or where it is going. We do not completely understand electricity and how it does what it does. But it is there nonetheless. It works our computers, microwave ovens, TV and radio, but we do not see it working!

God has an identity. Father, Son and Holy Spirit. He made ALL things and keeps them in existence.

We did not create the stars and planets, yet we know they are there. Someone had to place them in their orbits, and keep them rotating on their axises! Someone keeps them from crashing into each other.

You say that God does not exist. All of nature proves the opposite. The universe did not come into its present state by accident.

You can choose to believe that God does not exist. That is your will to do so, given to you by Him. Science in all its studies and calculations can neither prove nor disprove that God exists.

Here is a little story. If you have seen the movie Apollo 13. In a scene near the end. The actor who played Jim Lovell relates this true event. Mr. Lovell was a Navy pilot during the Korean War. He was flying back to his aircraft carrier from a mission. It was pitch black, during combat missions carriers decks are completely dark. The radar in his plane was being jammed by some station in Japan. He turned on his cockpit light to read his map, this caused a short circuit in his plane. Knocking out all the electrical equipment. He was contemplating ditching his aircraft, knowing he would be lost at sea.

He continued on course where he thought the carrier might be. As he came closer, the dark sea became strangely illuminated by the algae that was sturred up by the propellers of the carrier. He followed this glow, and landed safely on his ship.

Who put that algae in the sea, knowing that it would be sturred up by a big ship, and save a lost pilots life?

Do you think that happened by accident?

Answer 3

i think of you're blending concepts. no longer something refers to a actual presences, limits examine with a futuristic realm of opportunities and expectancies. Limits proving no longer something is like pickles proving sexual selection... the conventional person makes use of two pickles on the sandwich, some people have been raised to apply greater pickles.. for this reason people are additionally raised to be gay. -The logic is so undesirable, there is not any thank you to argue it because of the fact there is not any longer adequate logic to argue. Your argument is the comparable. First, actual presence and a term for expectancies and function obstacles are unrelatable in this manner. 2d, you assume God has no limits, which even though it proves no longer something the two way here, is likewise an controversial and disagreed upon element. 0.33, there are somewhat some issues that have countless opportunities- which includes absolutely everyone because of the fact those opportunities are high ilcaculable, for that reason countless.

Answer 4

God has created, is running, and will destroy the Universe. God is the Origin and Destination of the Universe. You give your Best, God will give you Best. Ask God for help and forgive, God will help and forgive you. Remember wherever there is Happiness in Life, there will be Sorrow. To get Happiness, you must master Sorrow. For Success in Life Believe in Self and God, Learn from Past, Concentrate in Present, Plan for Future.

Answer 5

Our finite minds cannot comprehend infinity but our minds can come in touch with the Infinite One. We cannot fathom God. "Where shall I go from your Spirit? Where shall I flee from Your presence?" Psalm 139:7.

The greatness of God is to us incomprehensible. The Lord's throne is in Heaven (Psalm 11:4); yet by His Spirit He is everywhere present! He has an intimate knowledge of, and a personal interest in all the works of His hand.

The hand that sustains the worlds in space, the hand that holds in their orderly arrangement and tireless activity all things throughout the universe of God, is the hand that was nailed to the cross for us. Speaking of Jesus Christ, we read, "For by Him all things were created that are in heaven and that are on earth, visible and invisible, whether thrones or dominions or principalities or powers. All things were created by Him and for Him. And He is before all things, and in Him all things hold together." Colossians 1:16,17.

We cannot see the wind but we can feel it. Because we cannot see it, do we conclude that it does not exist? It is the same with God being infinite. The universe is infinite. Christ's sacrifice was an infinite sacrifice. Who can measure the infinity of that sacrifice? He was in the form of God. The form of God He relinquished for ever to take the form of man and this form He will retain to all eternity. His human form is now glorified with the glories of the form of God! All the redeemed will be clothed with the same glory. "The glory You have given Me, I have given them." John 17:22. Something to think about!

Answer 6

Why do humans insist on trying to understand everything within their own (tiny) frame of reference. Limitless does not mean non existent, it means that we are unable to concieve of it. It would appear that for many inability to conceive means non existence. Try a little imagination and faith, it can work wonders for your soul.

Answer 7

u know whats the funny is that u r nothing , god exist & he will punish u hard u will see just wait

Answer 8

i've always thought of G-d as being... anti-existent. the opposite of things that exist. so i would agree with your statement.

Answer 9

You went to college didn't you

Answer 10

apparently P2 is not true, but don't ask me why