Do Muslims celebrate the anniversary of 911?

Question

I will believe any Muslim who swears to Allah that they dont know of any Muslims who have ever celebrated 911 in any way.

Keep in mind, by my count, there are many many Muslim answering 911 questions on YA right now. Lets see how many will repeat the following:

"I AM A MUSLIM, AND I SWEAR TO ALLAH THAT I HAVE NEVER CELEBRATED 911 NOR HAVE I EVER MET OR KNOWN OF ANY MUSLIMS WHO DID."

Anything other than these exact sentiments is a refusal, leaving open the inference that they have or have known Muslims who have celebrated 911.

Keep in mind, there is NO PROHIBITION IN ISLAM TO MAKE SUCH OATHS. NO MUSLIM CAN POST ANY CITATION TO THE QURAN THAT SAYS OTHERWISE. ITS NOT AGAINST ISLAM TO MAKE THIS OATH AT ALL.

EDIT:

"KNOWN PERSONALLY". I AM NOT INCLUDING "BIN LADEN" OR OTHER JIHADISTS KNOWN THROUGH THE EYES OF THE MEDIA

EDIT:

So to clarify, the oath is better said:

"I AM A MUSLIM, AND I SWEAR TO ALLAH THAT I HAVE NEVER CELEBRATED 911 NOR HAVE I EVER MET OR KNOWN PERSONALLY ANY MUSLIMS WHO DID."

EDIT:

No takers so far....what a shocker.

Ahmed:

I believe you, because you swore to Allah. Yes, I am satisfied that there is a Muslim who hasnt celebrated 911 and hasnt met other Muslims in his circle of influence who have shared with him any such celebration.

Thank you.

EDIT:

How the heck is this coercion?? Holy cow...this is on the INTERNET!! WHAT ABILITY DO I HAVE TO COERCE A MOUSE IN HERE? Lunacy!

Muslims know what people understandbly believe, and constantly whine about conclusion people rightfully draw from the actions of Jihadists.

What have they lost by making such a declaration? Why couldnt you restate the oath, and then call me a jerk!

I love how some Muslims have said that they wont do it because I asked....so...if I didnt ask you would have? LOL...

Answer 1

No we dont and I dont need to prove a damn thing to you or anyone else. Take your oath and shove it.

Answer 2

I don't celebrate the attack, and I have never knew, personally, anyone who celebrates the attack.

I would gladly die to prevent such an attack, no matter what the civilians color, race, religion, country, etc etc

When will you ever see or understand that Islam never supports the killing of Civilians??
The actions of one group or two who claim to be Muslims don't represent Islam.

I know the above is an answer you are not looking for and I know that you will never change your mind about Islam, so I'll just cut/paste what you asked for"

"I AM A MUSLIM, AND I SWEAR TO ALLAH THAT I HAVE NEVER CELEBRATED 911 NOR HAVE I EVER MET OR KNOWN OF ANY MUSLIMS WHO DID." I would add, personally.

are you satisfied??

Answer 3

Whatever. I am Asian Muslim. Really want me to make an oath? Well, read this:

I AM A MUSLIM, AND I SWEAR TO ALLAH THAT I HAVE NEVER CELEBRATED 911 NOR HAVE I EVER MET OR KNOWN OF ANY MUSLIMS WHO DID.

And that include even fundamentalist Muslims in my country and neighbouring countries. Satisfied now?

911 is a sad event even for Muslims as it is when the WAR FOR TERROR by 2 leaders of terrorism (Bush and Osama) began.

Answer 4

Muslims as an entire weren't in charge for nor condoned 9/11. maximum Muslims, like maximum Christians, are fairly good, form people who in no way choose for to harm anybody. to color all Muslims by the strikes of a few is somewhat unfair and not extraordinarily vibrant. in spite of everything, if I painted all Christians by the strikes of Westoboro Baptist, i might finally end up asserting all Christians are hate mongering extremest and not applying a sort notice to declare. might you think approximately that a user-friendly assessment of Christians?

Answer 5

Everybody has known Muslims who have celebrated 9/11. However, in my experience with Muslims less than 5% of the Muslims I know approve of 9/11. (2 out of about 50).

Edit: I should probably qualify this by saying that the Muslims I know live in the western world (mostly the U.S.). I can't really speak about Asian Muslims.

Answer 6

I AM A MUSLIM, AND I SWEAR TO ALLAH THAT I HAVE NEVER CELEBRATED 911 NOR HAVE I EVER MET OR KNOWN OF ANY MUSLIMS WHO DID.

yep, im telling the truth. some muslims in my class even had tears in their eyes. yup.

Answer 7

EE KEATH, Associated Press Writer
22 minutes ago-Yahoo news



CAIRO, Egypt - Osama bin Laden urged sympathizers to join the "caravan" of martyrs as he praised one of the Sept. 11 suicide hijackers in a new video that emerged Tuesday to mark the sixth anniversary of the attacks on the World Trade Center and Pentagon.



Al-Qaida traditionally issues a video every year on the anniversary, with the last testament of one of the 19 hijackers involved in the Sept. 11, 2001 attacks. This year's video showed hijacker Waleed al-Shehri addressing the camera and warning the U.S.: "We shall come at you from your front and back, your right and left."

The new message came days after the world got its first current look at bin Laden in nearly three years, with the release of a video Saturday in which the terror leader addressed the American people.

Answer 8

WHY WERE ISRAELIS DANCING ON 9-11 ?

THERE was ruin and terror in Manhattan, but, over the Hudson River in New Jersey, a handful of men were dancing. As the World Trade Centre burned and crumpled, the five men celebrated and filmed the worst atrocity ever committed on American soil as it played out before their eyes.

By 4pm on the afternoon of September 11, the van was spotted near New Jersey’s Giants stadium. A squad car pulled it over and inside were five men in their 20s. They were hustled out of the car with guns levelled at their heads and handcuffed.

In the car was $4700 in cash, a couple of foreign passports and a pair of box cutters – the concealed Stanley Knife-type blades used by the 19 hijackers who’d flown jetliners into the World Trade Centre and Pentagon just hours before. There were also fresh pictures of the men standing with the smouldering wreckage of the Twin Towers in the background. One image showed a hand flicking a lighter in front of the devastated buildings, like a fan at a pop concert. The driver of the van then told the arresting officers: “We are Israeli. We are not your problem. Your problems are our problems. The Palestinians are the problem.”

http://www.whatreallyhappened.com/fiveisraelis.html


///

Answer 9

I'm not a Muslim, but if I were, I'm not sure I would answer this question. You are balancing real grief at the loss of life against their loyalty to their religion. It's a toughie, and I think I would just avoid it if I were them.

But I look forward to hearing from Muslims with real courage to reply.

Answer 10

in Internet i lighted a candle
when i saw those who jumped from top floors i felt if i can bye thousand candles for them
regardless the argument who did it
regardless that in the pentagon no airplane wings or tail was founded
i just feel very much with them
that grew with me much bigger that i met so many Americans and British do really sympathize with our cause in Palestine
i also meat those who care nothing for Palestinian or the killing every day there
but i started to hear that many getting every day more sympathy with us
as well as in Iraq
pple in America started to know day by day how they were cheated and how there were so many fabricated lies in arranging for the war
yes the number is growing day by day in killing those innocents
its now over 700 000 had been killed
add to that raping the little girls
i m sure you American would have more pple to sympathies with you hearing your voice coming louder and louder condemning the killing in Palestine ,Iraq,Pakistan,Lebanon.and the list is growing

i must add for sister leaz in another question there was the matter of how the alqaida was founded
in short CIA agents brought together all extremist which mostly hidden in there countries(as underground,in egypt,yemen.arabia..) with some ideological leadership.trained,supplied with arms and sophisticated weapons as to form a front against communism(Russia) so who should take blame for that!!!!!!!!!!!

Answer 11

hey ppl he asked a question that he feels is important ! so respect it please, every one deals with this 9/11 thing in a different way! and if it makes him feel better and he doesn't like the fact that Muslims (even just fanatics) celebrate this then that is one more reason to be angry! what is up with judging here???? how do we know he didn't lose someone close to him in that fiasco! have a heart for both sides!