In your honest opinion, is Madeline McCann still alive or is she dead?

Question

hal d.. you answer shows you are sitting on the fence so no thumbs up sorry.

Answer 1

dead.

and beaufort - you sound like my mother.

when i first went to a foreign land (france :D) she warned me about white slave traders.

this was in 1972.

i'm amazed that the myth is still going - and that anyone actually believes it.

Answer 2

this has got to be one of the most strangest cases of child abduction/missing child that i have come across, my opinion was that she was alive, then dead, then alive and so on. it is unfortunate about the lack of information that the police over there give out and because of it the speculation that the papers have both here and there.

what evidence is there.

we are told in the papers yesterday that fluid from Madeline was found in a hire car that the McCanns hired 20 odd days after Madeline went missing, and today they say that that is blood but the police havent stated that in official terms and i think again that the papers are speculating, then we have the possibility that it may well be planted evidence, to cover what i can only see as incompetance on the part of the police, but are they being incompetant or is there way of working a good one who knows.

what we need to see is chronological evidence and statements about the day leading up to that evening, for example:

was Madeline seen during that day by people out side of the McCann family and friends?

what was the last time she was seen by a person out side of the family and friends?

if she was seen, how long before she was put to bed?

was any of the family and friends missing after she was put to bed for a significant time or where they all together all the time?

how long was it from when the McCanns last seen Madeline and the time of her dissapearence was discovered,

how did they discover she was gone did one of them just go and check or was it after they went back, so many questions and more that we have only been told about second hand and not by them directly.

i dont know what to think untill these questions are answered to the full.

what are the results from our police with regards to the forensics or are they bound by the same laws of secrecy because it is in a foreign jurisdiction.

Mmmmmmm

Answer 3

Hi stupidboy,

Personally I think Madeline is dead, I sure hope I am wrong on this question specially after this mornings news & news in Y!A community about what the parents may have done. Firmly believes innocent until proven guilty.
Have a good AM! :0)
Additional Details: I wonder (kinda out loud) why some parents even have their kids. Proud Mom of 4 grown children & 4 grandchildren.

Answer 4

I Hope she is alive, but I despair that she is dead.
As more and more comes out about the parents
- This wasn't the only time they were left, the complaints
about the children crying, and the McCanns being seen
out in town at night on their own. Their standard of childcare
was very lax to say the least. Still hope it wasn't them though
for the sake of the other two babies.

Answer 5

Dead

Answer 6

A difficult question as we are so remote from the scene and have no real idea of the events on May 3rd. The police there have made a huge error by not securing the crime scene and not treating the crime with enough urgency. Unless the little girl, and doesn't she look a lovely kid, is found the answer will be impossible to deduce. I do not believe that the parents should be treated as guilty of any crime until the real facts are known.

Answer 7

as a mum i`d love to think the poor girl was still alive somewhere & that someone is taking good care of her but thinking realistically, the longer she`s missing the more likely it is that she`s dead. the chances are that her body will never bo found either given the size of protugal & the closeness to the coast.

Answer 8

Shes dead, statistics in these kind of cases always point to the child being found dead after this amount of time.

Answer 9

sadly i think dead and the parent know about it , i think when the mum went 2 check on her the last time, she found her dead, maybe by the child electric shocking herself, i think the child has killed itself accidently while they were away eating, they have come back found, her, covered it up so not to get done by the police 4 leaving there children alone

Answer 10

NOOOO! don't you get it yet! nobody knows anything. there are rings in forgien countries that make much money kidnapping selling girls to radical muslims in saudi arabia and bangkok.Their agents do that for a living. Kidnappers and they know what they want and how to take their time. They want what they want. Muslims accept this. You are dealing with a different variation of slave traders. All around the world. big slave trade. cute little girls like that can fetch a pretty penny. Find out how many a year are actualy stolen form familys per year. and in england. and in france and germany. they get kidnapped in sold in the the thousands. they say saudi princes prefer these girls brought up i a mamnsion and evetually are married to a prince. noting has change over there for a thosand years. grab them and run, gettem oon a private plane and they land at their new home i the deser. tjeyu evem ;earm a new lanuigage pr twp amd ;live with the rouyals. jackso n and his two white kids move over they so he could do his thing. what can we do? its the islem radicals making a little extra poicket money. they are not afraid to get caugjht. usually, they nver get caugjht they are good.