Am I the only person in the universe who knows the ether is solid?

Question

Electromagnetic waves are transverse; there are no transverse waves in a fluid; therefore, if there is an ether, it has to be a solid. Q.E.D!

If this is not my own original idea, please point me to a source who beat me to it.

E/m waves pass thru water; but water is not their medium; it is the ether in, around and thru the water molecules that transmits the e/m waves.

Sound waves in water use the water as a medium, and they are longitudinal. No transverse sound waves can exist in water because the water has no sheer strength to permit side-to-side motion of the water molecules.

Yes, there are surface waves on a body of water, but the ether has no surface; it is boundless and infinite. Anyway, all the ether theories I know of, but mine, assume the ether is a perfect gas.

Which universe? The one whose entire existence consists of p-waves and s-waves in our solid ether foam; the one whose ether foam is the cosmic foam of a sub-universe; the one whose cosmic foam is the ether-foam of a super-universe.

Ether theory is out of fashion because general relativity works without it.

Gotta go now. Be back Tuesday.

http://www.bautforum.com/
against-mainstream/
61052-fractal-foam-model-universes.ht

Answer 1

NO, I won't the theory of the ether has been out of fashion, unneeded and disproved ever since the 18th century.

Light; radio waves are photons, don't need a medium to "flow" through. They are composed of discrete particles called photons. The "fluid of outer space" is something that was popular in the Victorian age not in the age of science. What ever junk science source you are talking about is a totally myth and fabrication based on false data, and unobserved facts.

Photons and electromagnetic radiation, which are photons vibrating at a different frequency travel through empty space, any imaginary ether would block the photons rendering our vision totally useless. We would be living in a total fog with no concept of anything outside of our atmosphere.

Are you the only person who believes in this? Unfortunately no; there are still those who believe that the earth is flat, a fact that ancient Greeks new to not be true. Like P.T. Barnham said "There is a sucker born ever minute."

Answer 2

Well, actually, I don't think we can call it an original idea, since I seem to remember that ether theorists described EM fields as "stresses" in the ether, suggesting that they did indeed think of it as something like a solid.

Answer 3

There certainly are transverse waves in fluids. What the heck do you think water waves are dummy? They're certainly not longitudinal! Another pipe-smoker!

Answer 4

"Does "The Ether" exist all the way by means of the Universe?" i think of you do no longer propose the anesthetic gasoline, precise? You propose "aether". "-For Millenia, the mystics talked of the unknown Ether all approximately us in magic and spirits." And yet they did no longer understand the air had mass. "-interior the Renaissance and New Age of Enlightenment, the Ether replaced into nevertheless believed in, yet called an unseen, unfelt form of rely or potential field. -Then purpose contemporary scientists foo-foo'd the Ether, asserting there exists no longer something pervading our established rely different than easy spectra, magnetism, electric can charge fields and gravity which make bigger into empty area, modernized even into the darkish rely those days chanced on." Aether fails to artwork in "gravitation". in spite of the efforts of many that somewhat need aether to artwork, it makes observable predictions that Nature disagrees with. "....So, The Ether seems to exist lower back, in keeping with probability as a maximum person-friendly undescribed matrix which gravity, easy/radiation, electric fields and magnetism act." No, spacetime isn't stuff. "So,...Why no longer believe interior the Ether lower back," ... "yet, we can nevertheless examine, or with a bit of luck opt to, if Nintendo does not take over thoroughly, or the present overlords of our academic gadget do no longer create an "Idiocracy".(see the movie) ; ]" See above the place you practice us to no longer start up an idiocracy? then you somewhat choose us to "believe" as in "believe without testing", a non secular act. while aether makes quantitative predictions that Nature concurs with, and something less complicated does not, then i will believe.

Answer 5

Transverse acoustic shear waves require a solid medium. EM waves are not acoustic waves. Q.E.D ... not. However it does sound original ... quite :-)

Answer 6

you don't know what an electromagnetic wave is

Communications work well in space

and what is ETHER?
a term used 100 years ago?

Answer 7

for some reason i belive u . no one knows that glass is really a liquid ,but doesnt electromagnetic waves go thru glass. please send me some more info on the ether and your sources i am really intriged by this . i would like to learn more. antn079@yahoo

Answer 8

can electro exist in fluid as electricity, i always thought ether as a vapor

Answer 9

Are you saying that electromagnetism doesn't exist in a fluid? That's your whole argument?

Answer 10

maybe you are right