English Deutsch Français Italiano Español Português 繁體中文 Bahasa Indonesia Tiếng Việt ภาษาไทย
All categories

Quick question regarding the Navy: if a person holds the rank of commodore, can/would they still be referred to as 'captain' while they are aboard a ship of which they are specifically in charge?

2007-09-01 08:35:21 · 10 answers · asked by Alena 2 in Politics & Government Military

10 answers

While the KIDS are correct that the RANK of Commodore was changed to RADM (LH) back in the 1990's, the TITLE of Commodore DOES still exist, and is in usage.

Example: The Commanding Officer of a Destroyer Squadron is typically a Captain (O-6), but holds the TITLE of Commodore of the DesRon. This elevates him to an operational equivalent to a RADM (LH). IF operating off of an aircraft carrier, he would have operational position over the Commanding Officer (an O-6).

This is similar to a Lieutenant Commander (O-4) or Commander (O-5) having command of a vessel, yet holding the TITLE of Captain.

2007-09-01 09:09:45 · answer #1 · answered by mariner31 7 · 0 1

As mentioned by others, the Navy is not currently using the rank of "Commodore". It was brought back for a while in the early 80's, but we went back to "Rear Admiral (lower half)" because the Army and Air Force called their O7 rank a "Brigadier General", and the Navy officers didn't like the equivalent "Commodore Admiral".

Yes, it's all rather silly.

"Captain" in the Navy is either the officer rank O6, and/or the title given to the Commanding Officer of a ship. Since it is extremely rare for an Admiral to be CO of a ship, it really doesn't come up.

An odd bit of trivia. In days past, a Marine Corps Captain (O3) would be referred to as "Major" when assigned to a shipboard unit and dealing with Navy personnel, and a Navy Captain (O6) would be called "Commodore" when assigned aboard a ship where he/she was not the Commanding Officer, even if the CO was a junior officer.

This tradition is widely ignored today, but occasionally you'll run into and old salt that remembers it.

2007-09-01 09:12:50 · answer #2 · answered by Anonymous · 0 1

Commodore is the equivilant of a one-star admiral. The Navy does still reserve the rank-position (vacant). The rank of Commodore is used / appointed only in time-of-war.

On board any U.S. Navy ship, the Commanding Officer of that specific ship is addressed by the TITLE of Captain (regardless of actual Rank). Any other officers (superiors of the "Ship's Captain") would be address by Rank.

2007-09-01 08:59:04 · answer #3 · answered by J Andy A 5 · 0 0

other way around. no such rank as Commodore, it is an honorific given to someone of the same rank as the actual CO of the Ship.

For instance, the CO of a carrier is an O6, Otherwise known as a Captain(yes, the Navy and Coast Guard do things differently then the rest of the services). Now say on board to run an exercise is another O6. that person would be 'bumped' and referred to as Commodore while on the Bridge. ,

2007-09-01 09:20:20 · answer #4 · answered by Mrsjvb 7 · 0 1

Do we still have a rank of commodore?

But, no. Whereas, the skipper of a ship should properly be addressed as Captain regardless of his actual rank, a person with rank above Captain will be in charge of more than one ship: a squadron, a flotilla etc, and should be addressed by his rank.

In fact, a Captain in charge of a squadron should also be addressed as Commodore.

2007-09-01 08:40:55 · answer #5 · answered by VampireDog 6 · 0 1

Commodore was abolished. It's now Rear Admiral (Lower Half). You would address a person of this rank as Admiral.

They are never in charge of a ship and would never be called Captain. TV and Hollywood distort the roles of admirals.

2007-09-01 08:40:26 · answer #6 · answered by Yak Rider 7 · 1 1

I am a Mason - ALL Shriners are Masons and we aren't just a bunch of old men that have Spaghetti Dinners. In Louisiana The Masons operate Dyslexia Clinics to teach kids with that affliction to read. The Shriners have 23 Children's Hospitals that offer free Burn and Orthopedic care to Children, There are other masonic groups that have other charity projects such as for the blind and even one group that provides dental care for the poor children under 18. The masons in other states have their own charitable function. My lodge also has a group of guys that help the elderly with their yard work and household repairs - Free of Charge. I belong to a group that collects food to donate to the food banks and this same group does Christmas caroling in nursing homes and Children's wards at the hospitals,. I can't sing so I play the guitar. We also provide help for disabled veterans. The list goes on and on. The reason many don't trust the masons is because at the beginning of our nation most of the men in power were Masons. George Washington was even the Grand master of Virginia. Many people feared the masons wanted to rule the world and formed the Anti-Masonic Party. Since that time masons aren't even allowed to discuss religion or politics in lodge. But the fear still remains among many people. The fundamentalist churches don't like us because we use non denominatal prayers in our meetings that don't mention Jesus Christ. We simply pray to God and that can be interpreted according to each individuals chosen faith. We are not a religion or a religious organization. We are simply men of faith. As for the religious aspect we take any man over 18 with good character regardless of religion as long as they believe in the existence of God. We just don't take atheists. Most fundamental Muslims hate us and so did the Nazis and The Stalinist Communists. The Nazis tried to wipe out the European Masonic Order. We do however have moderate muslim members. Those that don't preach violence against other nations or religions are welcome. We also have Jews and Buddhists and many other faiths as members around the world. I hope this cleared up a few things for you and for others.

2016-04-02 22:22:15 · answer #7 · answered by Anonymous · 0 0

in the U.S. Navy the title of Commodore is no longer used. it's strictly Captain, It would be to the equivalent to Colonel in the other armed forces.

2007-09-01 08:43:22 · answer #8 · answered by bad_andy16012 2 · 0 1

Commodore is a wartime rank, and at the present time is vacant.

2007-09-02 01:14:39 · answer #9 · answered by WC 7 · 0 1

yes, both is about the same.

2007-09-01 08:39:09 · answer #10 · answered by Heaven Sent 1 · 0 3

fedest.com, questions and answers