Are illegals Immigrant take jobs from US citizen or US citizen are to lazy to work?

Question

Are illegals Immigrant take jobs from US citizen or US citizen are to lazy to work? on hard working demanding job? please dont judge me before you read attached article? where are our hard workig people?
'Guest worker' plan assailed
GOP legislators rip idea to open office in Mexico
STORY TOOLS
Email this story | Print MORE STORIES
'Guest worker' plan assailed
Ritter gives it right back to GOP critics of union stance
Help wanted in Colorado — from Mexico
Idea sounds 'real good' to Brighton farm family
By April M. Washington, Rocky Mountain News
August 25, 2007
Republican lawmakers Friday assailed a bipartisan proposal to open a recruitment office in Mexico to attract seasonal workers, saying it risks making Colorado a magnet for illegal immigrants.
"This is sending the wrong message," said Republican Sen. Greg Brophy, a farmer from the Eastern Plains. "We need to be more creative than just opening up a state-sponsored employment office in Juarez. That's throwing in the towel and saying, 'Come on in.' "

Rep. Marsha Looper, R-Calhan, and Sen. Abel Tapia, D-Pueblo, are floating a plan to recruit seasonal legal workers in Mexico to help Colorado farmers who are struggling to find help to bring in crops. The legislators initially called it a "guest worker" program, but only the federal government can grant visas to foreign workers. The proposal is intended only to help expedite existing visa programs, not create a new one, as some critics have said.

The plan is preliminary, and talks just have gotten under way about introducing legislation in January.

Senate Republicans called the proposal an attempt by Democrats to backslide from recent legislative efforts to stem the flow of illegal immigrants.

"Unless the state is prepared to spend tens of millions of dollars to keep tabs on guest workers to make sure they don't overstay their visas, then this is a bad idea," said Sen. Josh Penry, R-Fruita.

In truth, the proposal came from a Republican.

Looper, a GOP House freshman, approached Tapia about co-sponsoring a bill.

Looper could not be reached for comment Friday, but said earlier she urged her GOP colleagues to put aside partisan politics and do what's best for Colorado's agricultural market.

Looper has been pressured this week by fellow Republicans to back away from the proposal.

Rep. Frank McNulty, R-Highlands Ranch, credited Looper for thinking outside the box, but argues that state-sponsored recruitment of migrant workers only would foster illegal immigration and further weaken attempts to secure the nation's southern border.

"This goes a step too far," he said. "Sometimes you got to beat people back into the box. She has some high hurdles to get through before she gets to the border."

Tapia defended the measure Friday as a creative and sound idea. He said neither he nor Looper is trying to lure undocumented workers or create a pathway to citizenship.

Tapia and Looper have said that the state's crackdown on illegal immigration has caused migrant workers to bypass Colorado, leaving farmers short-handed.

"We only want to expedite the current system," Tapia said.

Looper and Tapia are hoping an office in Mexico can help Colorado farmers draw migrant workers through an existing federal visa program called "H-2A."

That program has no cap on visa numbers, as some other visas do. However, employers must first find the specific foreign employees they want to hire, then have them approved by the U.S. Department of Labor.

The state of Colorado and employers also would have to provide housing and transportation for migrant workers.



washingtonam@RockyMoun tainNews.com or 303-954-5086

So what will be the solution? we know employer wont pay more, (illegal immigrant is the solution what you think?) or are you willing to pay more for your products?

Answer 1

Get a life and stop bothering us.

2 points...woo-hoo!

Answer 2

That is BS.Th problem is that these farmers wanted to pay illegal wages and Americans cant live on that.Unlike the illegal we have to pay taxes, put food on our tables, pay insurance, health care,.So to say that Americans are lazy because they didn't take those jobs is crazy.The farmer would have to cut back a little on his greed and he would have all the help he needed.I know many many people that work on a farm everyday so that dog don't hunt anymore.Illegal lovers love to still use this but they don't have any of the daily living with being an American, they don't have to worry about anything as we tax payers put food on their tables and a roof over their heads.They go to the ER and get all the free health care they need.So there are many many reasons Americans didn't show up and I bet you its because farmer Brown wanted to pay little or nothing, and Americans cant live on that like an illegal can.

Answer 3

Cut the welfare on all people, regardless of legal or otherwise. If there is absolutely no jobs, then the government can use the money they would have spent on welfare and relocate these people out to the western states to pick fruit. Everyone can do something. The government really needs to be helping those who ARE willing to work.

Answer 4

Most the good jobs that use to be in the states left the states along time ago anyway. Not much to work in states now, except moderate to low income wages.

Answer 5

The solution is put the legal migrant workers back in the fields/farms instead of giving them middle class jobs. We still don`t need the illegals. All the bragging how hard they work-then go back to the so-called crummy jobs they should be doing in the first place.

Answer 6

The farmers just need to plan better. If they are unfit to run a farm fire them. There are ways to get all crops picked and shipped.

Answer 7

Americans aren't lazy. The problem is these jobs pay very poorly and they are not enough to survive on in this country. If these employers were willing to pay more, then they wouldn't have any problem attracting American workers.

Answer 8

Illegals get the work that US citizens do not want.

Answer 9

check this link its good


http://workathomefreelancingdataentryworks.blogspot.com/

.