Would Muslims, if they could, impose Islam on the rest of us ? Does their religion justify this ?

Question

I am seeking here to clarify the teachings of the Koran. Does the Koran teach that given a position of power Muslims should impose Islam ? Would they be tolerant and allow democracy to rule ? The contrast here is with America, where Christianity is dominant, but America is not a Theocracy, though admittedly some Christians there would like it to be. The Bible does not have a lot to say about the State and governance whereas the Koran appears to have a lot to say about it. Am I right in saying that Christianity is all about the individual whereas Islam is all about power and control of communities.

Answer 1

yes, they will try,but will not successful.

Answer 2

Good question!

Honestly if I were in power I would try my best to not dissolve the trust between leader and follower; as this is a very special, exclusive relationship. You see, Islam in its truest form allows for a very wide range of governance which caters to all people. So to say I would apply the Shariah to everyone would be not only oppressive and wrong, but abusive and useless!

Islam should provide the ideal state; the Utopian society of this Earth where monotheists unite and atheists can still contribute to the community. Science and the arts would flourish; but unlike America, I do not think my state would be wholly secular. Rather, I would place a strong emphasis on morality; if not for religion, then for the greater good of humanity. Killing, stealing, lying etc. would be taught as wrong from an early age. Abortion and homosexuality (IMO) should be discouraged, but because it is not my right to deny someone their freedom to choose, would still be allowed.

People would not be valued for their money or celebrity status, but for their intelligence, hard work, dedication and genuity. Sex would not be blown out of proportion. We would all be respected as noble creatures (of God). I think the Constitution is very similar to what I would use in my "Islamic" state.

Within my rule I'd have to remember this one verse:
"Let there be no compulsion in religion." (Quran)

Peace.

Answer 3

The Qur'an's teaching is very similar to the teaching of the Bible, and it had been admitted y the scholars since the high Middle Ages.

You are making a mistake a lot of people seem to make these days. When you are talking about Islamists imposing their belief on you, you are talking about the extremist sector of the Islamic faith. Just as being a Jew doesn't mean he/she is a hardcore Zionist and being a catholic Irish doesn't mean he/she is planning armed attacks against the British crown, you are not really thinking about Muslims here.

Unfortunately, due to the complex situation beyond the scope of this question surrounding their nations and cultures, Muslims of radical faith have gained a vocal voice in their societies. This doesn't mean that such extremists are the majority. In fact, many of such extremists would be considered heretical under formal interpretation of the Qur'an.

Current crisis regarding the Muslim population and the United States is primarily a political struggle with lands and resources at stake. Muslims are people who have religion just like everyone else, who have families they love, just like everyone else. We shouldn't fall to the guile of the minority of armed terrorists who wants to make a political war into a war of ideals and religions for the sake of recruitment.

Answer 4

no u r certainly wrong
u dont know anything about islam or quran
the best proof that u r wrong is the anceint times ago when muslims were the greatest, u can read some history and then u will know that u were idiot to ask such a Q
islam is the most tolerant& moderate religion
islam cant force any one to be a muslim
our holy quran says that u r free to be whatever u wanna be , even if u wanna be an athiest it's ur own will
the biggest proof is that in the islamic period of ruling the world , muslims were very tolerant with ppl from allover the world they never forced any one to be a muslim ever
but the fact is that alot of them converted to islam cuz they found the truely right religion
hope i helped

Answer 5

Through governmental control of countries and communities religion came into existence as a way of obtaining compliance. This is why the Koran's validity is questionable.

I agree, it's all about the individual's soul.

Answer 6

Thank you for seeking to clarify something about the teachings of the Qur'an, it's better than assuming something you heard was correct as opposed to seeing if it's true. The fact that many people think they know for sure Islam's stance on this based on the mainstream media and opinion, and have written their answers here in this vein, worries and saddens me.
The simple answer to your question is no. 'Imposing' Islam on others is not part of this religion. The Qur'an tell us that 'there is no compulsion in religion', and teaches that Allah created human beings with free will, and although it is a duty of Muslims to spread the word of Islam, known as Da'wah, it is very wrong to ever force a person to convert. In fact one of the best ways to invite others to Islam is to simply behave the way Islam teaches one to: with morals and manners, gentleness and kindness. The Qur'an says in one Ayah (verse):
"To you be your religion, and to me my religion." (109:6)
This embodies the Qur'anic teaching on your question - Muslims are to adopt this policy of acceptance and respect of other religions, and should never compromise their own.
Consequently, you are wrong in saying Islam is about power and control of communities, in fact it is about peace and respect for others. You will find much more evidence of this in any translation of the Qur'an you happen to pick up, more than what I have written here, although I could easily go on and on about this topic. The Qur'an does offer guidance on every aspect of a person's life, this is part of it's beauty!

Answer 7

I can't give Islamic politics, only a Christians understanding of scripture. It is about the individual in Christianity who recognize Christ as the greatest prophet of God.--De18:18; He 1:1-4. I think Muslims' intent is to convert the world but so is that of Christians. Christ knew this would not happen, but when he returns all people will be impelled to acknowledge him. Everyone will have to bow down to him and profess that "Christ is Lord to the glory of God."--Ro 14:11,12; Isa 45:22,23; Php 2:9,10.

Answer 8

the 1st exchange facilitates one to comprehend or disrespect a faith, as long because it is finished peacefully. as far as deserving comprehend is going, a genuine Muslim isn't a bad individual. in spite of the indisputable fact that, terrorist companies have manipulated the assumption of Jihad into some thing adverse. those doing those adverse issues interior the call of Islam are no longer real Muslims.

Answer 9

As 4 as i understand ur question..................

Islam is all about power & control of communities b/c Quran is not 4 1 person or 4 one individual like bible(as u hav told urself).Quran is 4 whole world there4
Quran Teaches & discuss all matters about life , society, communities & many other things.And also it teaches if a muslim has a power how 2 use this power not in bad way in a good way.(not only 2 muslims but also non-muslims)
----------------------------------------------------

Answer 10

You've recieved many great answers, as well as many rediculous ones. I hope that as your question revolves around Muslims, you would consider the Muslim opinion above those who know no more than what they see on t.v.

In our hearts, we do wish for the world to follow Islam, however we also realize that that is not reality, and we have to face reality in all circumstances. People are going to believe, people are going to reject, people are going to be indifferent. Doesn't matter what the subject is, we will always have these dimensions. We realize this, and it is not our duty to subject people to Islam. It is pointless, and we will be held responsible for forcing people to basically be hypocrits (not believe but say they do out of persecution). It's not worth it to face the punishment of creating such chaos among people.

The Quran teaches us to be just, to keep our honor and dignity, and to respect all, no matter what religion they belong to. In a Muslim-majority society, it is not our duty to convert everyone or kill them, it is not our place to look down upon others who do not wish to be Muslim, it IS our duty to treat everyone equitably and deal justly with them. If the Prophet Muhammad (saws) could be just and equitable with non-Muslims, what on earth posesses us to believe we are above the Prophet?

In addition, you cannot look at "Muslim" countries today and judge them as a Muslim country. They are too ripe with corruption and injustice to even be able to consider themselves a true Muslim country, and it will take far too much work for a change to come about anytime soon. Officials have their hands in the pockets of the people and place it in whomever's pockets will benefit them and their lust for power. This includes placing it into the pockets of so-called religious leaders who are more concerned with promoting political agendas than fulfilling their religious duties. Saudi Arabia is one of my biggest disappointments as it is at the heart of Islam, the Ka'aba. However they've made it into a circus and the royal family the ringmaster. They've morphed religious law so much that it's barely recognizeable to someone with an eye for detail.

Islam isn't about power and control, it's about freedom, responsibility, respect and dignity, and justice. That is why early Muslim empires came to be so great, and it was when greed for power and control took over that caused the collapse of one of the greatest societies in history. A look at history into the earliest days of Islam and the life of the Prophet Muhammad (saws) will show you just how a real Muslim society should operate. Avoid the websites that boast about the sword bull, even Jewish scholars believe the "spread by the sword" story is bunk: http://world.mediamonitors.net/content/view/full/35742
So many unbiased historians praise Muhammad's ways, and we as Muslims should look to his example rather than making up our own and distorting our own religion in the process.

Answer 11

On 'God's Warrior's' on CNN, the Muslim stated they do believe they are the only ones that have the 'correct' religion; and following it is the only way to live. I believe they do wish to impose their 'perfect' religion on the rest of the world. When a mother was asked why she would send her 3rd son to die in battle, she said it was necessary-plain and simple. She said she knew of a mother who's son's head was thrown at her by enemies and she threw it back at them and said "What I give to god, I don't want back". No emotion. Just a way of life-the same with another woman who's son martyred himself. She said that is what they are taught. You become a martyr you go directly to heaven. So everyone wants to become a martyr. Weird! You can watch this again, starting tonight on CNN.