If human creates life, is that a proof against god ?

Question

Recently on yahoo news I read, that within 10 years scientist will be able to create life by just synthetic means. (sing the same substances which form the DNA, creating a cell.

Believers claim, that god is the creator, and everything was created by him, and not by evolution.
Its the old discussion: creation versus evolution.
Now, if a human as well can create life form scratch, I would say, this totally proofs the believers creation argument wrong.

Answer 1

That would be proof that the new life form had a creator.

What would be ironic, is if the new life "evolved" and then had debates about whether or not there was a creator involved.

Of course...they would be so correct when they point to their form of science and say "see...no Creator".

Answer 2

Let me tell you a joke by way of explanation.

A man tells God, "I will have a contest with you. I will create a man." God says, "You're on." The man picks up a handful of dirt. God says, "No, you don't understand! Make your own dirt!"

Nobody has ever created life out of nonliving matter. Believe me, people have tried. They can't even get to first base. They try to create an atmosphere where life could happen spontaneously. Turns out the gases in that environment destroy life, not create it. In the most famous experiment, do you know that they filtered out a few amino acids, and left all the rest of the crud behind? Amino acids are a long ways from being life. They have never created DNA out of nothing. All they have ever done is combine DNA differently. Mutations, whether from radiation, or induced by man, are almost universally harmful, and they do not cause one species to become something very different.

You can wait and see if I am wrong, but don't hold your breath!

Study both sides of the question of evolution and see whose arguments are the most logical and best fit the facts.

Answer 3

I agree. I don't believe that god is the creator of everything. I'm saying that the universe just exists like that or maybe other factors besides god as a creator of it. And you might say how can the universe just exists like that without any creators. Then another question goes to you : Who is the creator of god then? God can't just exists like that right? If God can, then the universe can.

In Science, of course God is not the one who created everything. He is just a human that died in the past and gave good teachings. But somehow I hope this question have no answers to it. Because religion can be a psychological supports to human and His teachings is a guide for humans to be a better person. But believing God will bless you and that He created everything, it's a mistake.

Answer 4

Judges???? .....BOMMMMP!
You just used the word "synthetic". Not admissable when describing "life".
Taking the "believers" side for a moment...if God created man, then everything man "creates" was still created by God. God has granted the means(brains), the method(Physical reproductive organs), and the DNA, lol.

Taking the non-believers side....10,000 years ago, we probably didn't wipe our asses...now look at us. Oh, and we have a tailbone, lol.

Answer 5

I'll wait 10 years to see if they manage first.

Then I'll debate whether the fact humans controlled everything means the new life was created by an intelligent being or natural processes.

Answer 6

Does dying contradict the meaning of existence ? in no way, yet on the choice, dying is a competent pal of existence. please think of with me if we live continuously.... immortality. Then tell me what going to make my existence so effectual. If i'm able to stay continuously, that what's carefully pointless. dying by using fact the top of existence supply us a priceless ingredient observed as Time, and time make us understand that existence - as all of us comprehend it right here - is momentary and we ought to continuously supply each and everything until eventually now leaving. to make it ordinary ... existence is almost a prepare you're in and dying is your stop. and between them there is adventure you should take. the stop does not contradict the prepare or the adventure. the two are exist and you like them the two. As Mr J. Krishnamurti had mentioned "existence and dying are an identical flow" If there is not any God, is existence and existences, evolution of mankind, the universe, our Earth we live to tell the tale and much extra, in basic terms a figment of "nothings" mind's eye? i think of if there is not any god there is not any longer something in any respect. by using fact i think that god is source of each and everything. so if the god do no longer exist how could something would come. To me, my very very own existence is a sturdy poof that there is a god. thank you for asking. thank you Yahoo

Answer 7

Science will always be advancing and proving new methods and theories. Creating human life is one of them that has always interested scientists from all over the world.
They may create a living, functional body, but where does this body recieve it's character, it's feelings, . . . etc.
Where are the scientists getting the materials to do this? Who placed them there?

Answer 8

Not "against" God, per se.

What it would prove is that the creation of life does not require a supernatural "first cause" and is entirely within the possibilities of science, which would offer observable, reproducable evidence that abiogenesis can exist.

Answer 9

He did create everything; to include natural law. Physics, biology, chemistry are all of His creation and He permits natural law until He comes again and then natural law will be replaced by His Law.

Mankind was given the choice to do as they wish with natural law and some are choosing to "be God" but they will find out soon enough their mistakes.

Answer 10

What they are calling life doesn't even qualify as life under the rules of most evolutionists. As a christian I usually wouldn't agree with them but this time I'll have to agree with them. A synthetic one celled, non intelligent, man made thing doesn't qualify as life to me. Even an amoeba has intelligence.