If morality only comes from the Judeo-Christian God...?

Question

If that is the case as I've heard asserted tonight, and otherwise, that the God of Israel is the one and only source of moral behavior and law; why then is the evidence overwhelming that all the civilizations contemporaneous with and pre-dating to the Israelite civilization contained a moral code? If as you say that "morality comes from Judeo-Christian values" why do we have Hammurabi's Code, The Egyptian Book of the dead, and evidence of moral codes in ancient Persia, Africa in the form of the Neubians, and Mesoamerica dating back as far as 1000 BCE (or B.C. for you that prefer)? Why were all these people able to figure out that one shouldn't rape, steal and murder without the help of the God of Israel, and yet you assert that Atheists have no basis for morality because it can only come from God?

Also, were the Israelites wandering the desert with Moses, prior to recieving God's law, under the impression that murder was OK?

Answer 1

Well put... I got nothin'. Wait, what's a nubian?

Answer 2

God of Abraham predates all the moral codes you have mentioned. Obviously Adam and Eve as well as their children looking forward in time to the coming Messiah already knew the idea that only a perfect sacrifice can take away human sin. Hence Abel's sacrifice, as well as Noah's. Later on the elaborate sacrificial system was codified under Moses, yet it predates Abraham. The 10 Commandments as well as the Mosaic law were given to highlight human sin in preparation for the coming Messiah.

You can also approach morality from a different angle. Even without any formal moral code, you inherently know that malicious actions are simply wrong. If you disagree, try to smile the next time someone tries to trip you on purpose when you're in a rush to catch a cab. Believe me, you won't need any moral code to tell you whether the other man's actions were good. Having said that, unless you can control your emotions, he better have medical insurance.

Answer 3

Morality is nearly universal. The Ten Commandments given to Moses "sealed the deal" between YHWH and his chosen people. Of course, people understood that in order to maintain a civil society, there are certain behaviors that must be deemed immoral. But these two tablets placed in the Ark are the guarantee of the covenant between the Jews and their god.

There is no historical evidence that a 40 year exile ever occurred or that a deity landed on a mountain and claimed these people for his/its chosen ones. So I think the whole thing is symbolic at best.

.

Answer 4

The moral codes were spoken to one another before Moses received them from Mt. Sinai. What Moses received was in existence since the beginning of time. Moses received the moral code for the Israelites that just came out of Egypt. They were a stubborn bunch that needed morality to be taught to them.

GOD bless

Answer 5

I'm just a dumb blond, but I have been wondering since reading the first morality question directed at atheists, what morality has to do with religion. The market isn't cornered, they don't own all the stock, why would they even begin to think that they do or even pose such a ridiculous and asinine question to anyone? I was sober when I first read, am getting a buz working on drunk and I still do not understand, is it one of those sobering thoughts that you can't get drunk enough to understand? I'm just saying.......

Answer 6

you should understand, that the human beings God commanded to be killed, have been particularly depraved. They burned their very very own little little ones, as sacrifices to their idols. And to assert that He not at all spared the harmless whilst commanding dying between cities is ridiculous. He warned the harmless in Sodom and Gomorrah to go away until eventually now the destruction of the great city, and He says He does not harm the harmless with the depraved. additionally, no longer all infants are harmless, basically by using fact they are infants. that's not approximately you being gentle and asserting Aww yet they are no longer evil, they are basically little ones. you should understand by using finding on the international right this moment, it relatively is a methods from the fact. little ones murdering different little ones, even people who don't have psychological subject concerns or tousled families, and much extra so in different cultures they are taught from an extremely youthful age to hate human beings. confident, they have been taught to try this, yet having mentioned that they are depraved and God knew back then they does not have replaced their methods. God could have spared the harmless basically like He did in Sodom and Gomorrah. He did no longer kill human beings, rapidly or no longer rapidly, devoid of reason, like human beings do right this moment. that's what thou shall no longer kill skill. do no longer kill human beings devoid of reason. God destroyed human beings, by using fact they have been depraved, and does not exchange their methods. whilst Jesus died on the flow, even the depraved are given an excellent gamble to instruct faraway from their sin, by using fact Christ may be the criminal expert in God's court docket for them. He took the punishment for each ones wickedness on the flow.

Answer 7

I dont know who stated that comment but it is indeed in accurate Morality did not just suddenly appear with Judeo-Christian debut in the world

Answer 8

Sadly, they will say their god was eternal and therefore was there then instead of looking at the facts.

Answer 9

Buddy, dont break their ego like that unless you like being condemned to hell just for you to remind them that they cannot judge nor condemn!

Answer 10

There is no such thing as a Judeo-Xtian.