Can I ask a few Q of Muslims?

Question

The radicals who have attached themselves to your religion believe they will go to paradise by killing themselves--and taking as many innocent lives in their suicide as they can. What does the Quran tell you of the fate of the 5 year old boy who was killed in their attack? What of the 23 year old pregnant woman? Do they go to heaven or hell? Why must innocents be killed? Maybe I am a crazy Christian, but I can not see how an all powerful God (Allah) could take pleasure in the brutal murder of ANY of His children.

Yankeebird--it is not a FEW "Muslims". There are thousands who claim to be acting on their Islamic faith. I know there ARE a FEW Christian fundies out there who've done similar acts--but there are NOT ARMIES of them. And when someone bombs an abortion clinic in the name of God--they are quickly denounced by the majority of all Christians-and they are tried and punished for their crimes against humanity. By remaining silent it seems as though Muslims condone their actions.

Lybian--Did I offend you by trying to understand you/your religon? You are correct--the Christians did kill thousands in the name of God. How many centuries ago was that again?

Arabmuslim--thank you. Although I now have to research your answer-I was not looking for an argument--just answers. I do have to disagree however, with your assessment of the thugs who are murdering in the name of Islam. I don't believe they're Muslim at all. I believe they are demons doing satan's bidding. And look--they have the entire world at war.

Answer 1

Well well , I don't see any explanations .
I asked a Q earlier about Sahih 41 #6985 and got a smattering of results . I asked almost the same question a few days ago and strangely got different answers than I'm getting now . Now it seems that the current answerers want to 'twist' the meaning or deny it altogether . One guy said they are supposed to 'doubt' anything not from Allah . . . . but never clarified how they know it's from Allah and never clarified(not that he can) what 'doubt' is supposed to mean .
Since we're learning so much about the inner working of the Muslim faith , I wonder if God meant this to be . Meant it to expose the irrationality and the hypocrisy of their teachings . I'm not God obviously , so I don't 'know' for sure , but I'm startin to wonder .

Answer 2

Who is saying they will go to paradise?
Islam is a peaceful religion its just that a lot of Muslims are not educated and they don't know the real religion or whats actually written in the Quran, they just memorize it and b/c kids are not educated terrorist organizations (e.g. Al-Qaeda) brainwash these innocent children and use them and the religion, there is nothing like 'Holy war' in Islam unless someone attacks Muslims first...

"If anyone slew a person unless it be for murder or for spreading mischief in the land it would be as if he slew the whole people; and if anyone saved a life, it would be as if saved the life of the whole people."(5/34). This verse explains that killing a person is like killing everyone in the word (whole people) unless its if someone committed murder or someone spread mischief, this is not what these terrorists understand they are not fighting for any religion they are just using a religion and doing what they want...

Answer 3

The child will go to Jinnah. The unborn if it is 4 months old will go to Jinnah. The woman who was pregnant will either go to Jinnah or Jahannam depending on her actions and deeds on Earth. If she performed Salat 5 times a day, did fasting during Ramadan, payed Zakat, and died believing in ALLAH(SWT) and Muhammad(PBUH*). If the unborn died before 4 months gestation then it isn't human and doesn't exist because ALLAH(SWT) breathes the soul into the fetus at 4 months making it a human. The radicals are confused. Martyrdom is not blowing themselves up along with innocents. Martyrdom is dying for the sake of Islam and ALLAH(SWT) like if you get murdered in war.

Answer 4

Hey, libyan_amoona, you are reaching back 1,000 years ago to the Crusades when you talk about violent Christians. Anyway, that was basically a response to the violence propagated by Muslims back then who were murdering Christians. We are talking about today. If your imam told you to kill Christians, would you...oh yeah, I bet you would. You can have your false religion. You are all so holy killing your own children, beheading people, blowing up your countrymen. Oh, yeah, what a group of noble people. By the way, that's sarcasm sister. If I hear someone say that Islam is the "religion of peace" again, I will absolutely VOMIT. A world without the Muslim religion would be next to heaven!

Answer 5

It is sad actually.
When Saddam was there, however, those bad committed suicide in Iraq didn't happen.
I dont know, what GWBush had in mind.
I heard its about oil, which Iraq has plenty of it. And I heard that halliburton ( I hope i spell it right), which Mr Cheney has connected/influence ( I dont know) , their share prices is up up up. ( I only read it here);
When Saddam was around not so many smuggling oil happened, now ....???

Yes it is very sad indeed,
As the bombers (the one committed suicide) cant be acknowledged anymore as that person really in pieces, I heard lots of it were "inside the invader's" job.
It's just to allow more and more troops to get in so the invaders can occupy the oil.

It's sad, and it's a pity, that Saddam did what he did, so he invited the opportunity.

What had happened is fate.
We have to see what will happened next.

I thought the killings in Ireland was bad enough for the British Govt. but Blair did support GWBush.
It was brutal in Ireland too, it's always like that in a war.

It's OK once the US troops stop coming to Iraq, I certainly believe that Iraqies will not kill each other anymore as no more provocateurs .

Answer 6

Along the same line, what about the fundie Christians who kill innocent people when they bomb clinics, etc? Don't forget there are radicals of any faith who often take the lives of innocent people for no good reason at all. You cannot blame this just on Islam and Allah, though I am relieved by the first part of your first sentence - you realize it is just a few radicals rather than all Muslims.

Answer 7

hmm leme try to give an answer to this question The radicals who have attached themselves to my religion might be muslims or chirstian might be a jew do u know only if they say they are muslims dont judge they are muslims BECAUSE islam Bans sucide by any means possible mean yes it means they going to go to what? HELL and i dont say it, its the holy quran, hadith and sunnah says. these ppl are no one to say they are right. 5 year old boy who was killed in their attack as he havent yet reach maturity InsAllah he go to heaven and 23 year old pregnant woman who also died will be judge on her deed.
For the last part of your question
"I can not see how an all powerful God (Allah) could take pleasure in the brutal murder of ANY of His children"
hmm as your are believer you know very well human is set free in this world and will judge in the afterlife. "as we sow,so shall we reap". so this means that god dont take pleasure he takes test, test of our faith.

We shall test your faith by means of fear and hunger and loss of wealth and lives and crops, but give good tidings to those who endured with courage, who in hardship say, "To Allah we belong and to Him shall we return."

-Qur'an, Al Baqara, Surah 2:155-56

Answer 8

I completely agree with you. God can't be happy to see his children murdered.

Answer 9

yeah ok we know they're muslims
but it dosnt mean that their right

the prophet (swt) never killed a child or a women and its a sin to kill innocent people whoever they r

and so u talk about wat muslims do hve u never thought about ur own religion and hw many people killed innocent people in the past

christianty was once a vilont religion so dont go talk about islam before reading about ur own relgion

islam is the true religion

Answer 10

yeah I don't understand them it seems selfish, seems like its all about what they want and death to all others.