Do you think Elton John should have sang the Circle of Life since gays aren't a part of creation?

Question

does he really have any business singing about creating life if he never will?

I never said anything bad about the guy I'm just stating the obvious. Since Gays don't have a man woman relationship they are not a part of the normal way God intended us to bring forth life.

The circle of life is about man and woman creating life.

Answer 1

You truly need to create a new world I mean it and start taking out all the perfect people one by one including yourself. Live and let live. The reason why I dislike organized religion the people that attend scare me totally. They are the ones that judge and God has told you clearly to judge not. He has not asked you to feel superior while you put down another. Live and let live. You are being judgemental and God doesnt want you to be.

Answer 2

By your logic, a woman who has gone through menopause shouldn't sing the song either. What about children who have yet to reach puberty?

If God created EVERYTHING, then He created all human beings, including you and Elton John and in His image.

I'm no Bible scholar, but I remember the Great Commandment's saying to love your neighbor. The Commandment does not say what kind of person the neighbor has to be be either, black or white, male or female, Christian or not, gay or straight. Also, it is the Great COMMANDMENT, not His really nice suggestion. Jesus told his disciples, "they will know you by your love." It sounds like you've got some work to do.

Answer 3

I cannot believe anyone would even think this question up. I am a Christian that believes in what the Bible says about homosexuality, however, I would not dare be so rude as to ask this question. "Gays, aren't a part of creation?" God created ALL people, the people are the ones that choose to sin, no matter the sin. Get real- and instead of pointing fingers so much, look deep within yourself to see what sin you may be harboring. My answer is not saying I agree with the gay lifestyle, however I am saying all of us have things in our life that need working on- so start with yourself, ok?

Answer 4

How do you figure gays are not a part of creation? Gay men are CAPABLE of having sex with women. Their sperm are as likely as any man's sperm to fertilize an ovum. A lot of gay men get married and father children before they come to terms with their homosexuality. Besides, is procreation a requirement for being a part of creation?

- Isaiah 56:3-5
Let not the eunuch say: behold, I am a dry tree. For this I say unto the eunuchs who keep My sabbaths And choose what pleases Me, and hold fast to My covenant: I will give them in My house and within My walls A place and a name which is better than sons and daughters; I shall give him an everlasting name that shall never be cut off.

Answer 5

Technically gays can create life. They have two options: go straight for a couple of minutes and impregnate a woman or give that woman a cup of creation juice. Walla, they created a baby. Not to mention that having been created themselves they are in fact a part of creation.

Answer 6

You are sad. God created all people, just some have choosen to be gay. So gays are part of creation. They all got here through creation, didn't they?! There are many straight people that don't have children, I mean they have choosen not to have children. I have a son but I never wanted kids because I never had that motherly instinct. I never dreamed of getting married and never dreamed of kids. I never had that urge of having to be a mother. If I hadn't gotten married, I'd still be a single woman without a child. And that would have been fine with me. Just like many other heterosexual don't want children. Yet there are many lesbians that have children, so that makes them part of the creation that you are speaking about. I hope you aren't representing Christians because you aren't being Christ-like right now.

Plus any musical artist can sing about whatever they want. It's all part of the art. Elton is gay but he is still talented musically.

Answer 7

Another perfect example of a person who has absolutely no idea what he's talking about, and who doesn't have a clue about life, love and acceptance of all human beings. God is the exact opposite of what you just described. God loves everyone, and everyone on this earth is a part of His creation and circle of life.

Answer 8

Give me a break. Gays aren't part of creation? Where did they come from, thin air? And, so, only people who have children are allowed to sing about life? Does that mean that, since I don't have children, when I watch "Lion King" I'm not allowed to hum along?

Boy. Seems like your world is pretty narrow.

Answer 9

JD - every time you open your mouth, you put both feet in it. most of what you say makes God look BAD. that is a much bigger sin than not believing in God.

as a Christian, you are called to judge other Christians ONLY. that is the Biblical order. judging non-Christians always makes one look like a fool. this is why that rule is in place - - to keep you all from embarassing God and yourselves with your awful, judgemental words.

do you really think your question brought ANYONE closer to Jesus? no - it didn't. your question failed your God.

funny how you will never see that.

i bet you have incredibly bad indigestion from sucking on your feet so long.

Answer 10

You will be judged as you judge, if you are comfortable in judging others in any way at all, go ahead, I do not.
I think anyone has the right to say whatever they want to. In whatever way they want. And who gave you the right to decide he is not part of life? Jesus is the one who will decide, but if you are comfortable doing Jesus' job, go right ahead. I truly mean no meanness here. Just calling it as I see it.
I believe gay people have the same chances we do when it comes to God, heaven, etc.

Blessed Be

Answer 11

There's more to creating life than fornication. He created life in the form of music. It's more of a figurative life-force, such as inspiration. And, seeing that the Earth is past its carrying capacity, don't you think gays are the neutralisers of population?