English Deutsch Français Italiano Español Português 繁體中文 Bahasa Indonesia Tiếng Việt ภาษาไทย
All categories

2007-08-17 06:43:15 · 30 answers · asked by Anonymous in Society & Culture Religion & Spirituality

30 answers

No..........


Though Pd. Dayanand and most of the Hindus believe in rebirth but the Vedic
text enlightens us that theory of reincarnation is baseless.

" Beyond the three skies let him go,whence he shall NEVER COME AGAIN in all years to be long as the sun is in heaven."--[Arthava veda,6:75:3]

"All creatures are one fourth of Him, three fourths what DIETH NOT IN HEAVENS." --[Ibid, 19:6:3]

"Through whom the gods [Humen ancestors of the Aryans] discovered the eternal life."--[Ibid,4:23:6]

"Let the dead remain among the Fathers."--[Ibid,18:4:48]

"Fathers rejoice in the heaven with all yours members."--[Ibid,18:4:64]

Rig Veda confirms that the Creator creates all things of this world and the next , at a certain time :

"The father of the eye, the wise in spirit, created both these worlds."--[Rig veda,10:82:2]

" You will not find Him who produced these creatures : another thing hasarisen in your mind.Enwrapt in misty cloud with lips that stammer,hymn-chanters wander and are discontented."--[ibid,10:82:7]


As per rebirth theory based on Manu's teachings, a person who commits adultery with the wife of another, or causes death of virtuous people,he gets the BODY OF A TREE, on his rebirth.

This is just baseless since a tree can contain several souls if propagated by cutting its branches and growing them separately.Each branch will become another tree.


Even Bhagwat Geeta informs of Shri Krishna, the 8th avatar of Vishnu as saying. " Thinking on that, merged in that, solely devoted to thatTHEY GO WHENCE THERE IS NO RETURN, their signs dispelled by wisdom."--[Bhagwat Geeta,5:17]

" Having come to Me, these mahatmas, COME NOT AGAIN TO BIRTH, the place pf pain, noneternal, they have gone to highest bliss."--[ibid,8:14]

The 9th avatar of Vishnu was Buddha who said, " There is no evidence of an immutable ego-being, which remaineth and migrates from body to body."--[The Gospel of Buddha by Carus,p-23]


"Gautama [Buddha] did not teach the transmigration of souls."--[Hibbert lecture by Rhys Davids, 1880, p-91]

"His [Budhha's] doctrine was not metempsycosis."--[Chiristianity & Buddhism by Sterling Berry,p-75]


In JAINISM also, the rebirth theory is not acceptable;


"We will now adopt the law, after the adoption of which WE WILL NOT BE BORN AGAIN."--[Gyan Sutra, part II s.b.e.XIV,p-65]

"How can it be imagined that he shouild be born again who profess the pure,complete, unparalled law and is a recepticle of the unparalleled law."--[Ibid,pg-331-332]

The Sikh Guru Nanak Sahib also discarded this theory;

" The Lord has become mercyful, COMING AND GOING HAS STOPPED."--[Adi Granth translated by Ernest Trumpp,p-72]

"Praise thou the name of Ram[God], THERE WILL NOT BE AGAIN COMIN AND GOING."--[Ibid,p-52]

" Having become in the way of religion, HE PUTS A STOP OF GYRATION OF DEATH AND LIFE."--[Ibid,p-195]


Scientifically also there is no explanation whatsoever, which can substantiate reincarnation or rebirth.

2007-08-18 02:38:42 · answer #1 · answered by ♪¢αpη' ε∂ïß♪ ♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥ 6 · 0 1

Dear friend,

I will tell you a small event you might have seen or seeing daily.

There is a hen with a dozen chicks around.All are happily moving round the ground plucking their tiny noses or beaks here and there for a grain or worm or insect.

Suddenly there appears a shadow of a kite approaching,immediately it makes a squeak , a peculiar sound and all chicks come and take shelter under the wings of mother hen.She covers them all and and protects.
It will not react to other birds like sparrows,crows in the same way.
How does the hen know that the eagle or kite is an enemy and kill the chicks?The chicks are born a day ago.They have not seen anything at all.
So how does the hen know about the death (impending) to chicks through the eagle?
when did she die to know it?chicks too run and take shelter ?how they know the death.the just born?
Unless the died already once at least they can not know?
You Can not say this is instinct.There are so many other examples.

So there is rebirth.A animate being takes birth after it dies according to its Karma.

2007-08-17 15:52:37 · answer #2 · answered by Radhakrishna( prrkrishna) 7 · 0 0

Whetehr yu belie it or not , the matter of which your body is mad eof is undying and is getting recycled in so manything sas the water you drink is gettin grecycled even to the last drop.not a single drop is lost by any process.
you build yur body by eating the fruits of this earth9 i mean all the substances that is found in the earth) so the earth is made into yur body.at a certain stage like the battry cell loosing its charge , all the cells of your body and all the organs of yur body also become inactive and begin a process of disintegration.They who have been borrowing from the earth statr the proces sof repayment to the earth.the bodily cells become dormant before they start the proicess of disintegration.The disintegration is not a total destuction of he matter of he body.Matter nver gets destroyed but only changed fromone to another .Just like the metal of a vessel that is old and destroyed is recycled and made itnot something else , the matter that goes back to the earth is taken by new lives either directly or through the vegetation that have taken them into themselves and thuis they are remade in new thngs .what sahll we call this process .Is it not re-birth.?rebirth need not necessarily be like the same man- a man into a man , a girl into a girls , an animal into an animal etc . it can be anythng into anythikng else . Tha tis what the Hindus call the re-incarnation. I belive in it and no one can disprove it also .

2007-08-17 07:30:50 · answer #3 · answered by Infinity 7 · 1 2

Those who say, they don't, are the ones who are 'enjoy and make merry' types. They simply have no control over their desires. They have narrow visions and researching into afterlives is an extremely tall order for them.

Pity, they are like a convict avoiding law's arms for short term reliefs.

2007-08-17 20:11:07 · answer #4 · answered by Vijay D 7 · 0 0

I do believe in rebirth because most of the times there is no rational explanation to some of the sufferings humans undergo.

2007-08-17 07:03:56 · answer #5 · answered by KAAL 3 · 1 2

As I use the bible as my final athority, and answer, no. And the bible says in hebrews 9:27 And it is appointted unto men once to die, but after this the judgment. Read the news but study the Bible. Be blessed.

2007-08-17 07:10:53 · answer #6 · answered by Bidasha 1 · 0 0

Yes every one who has taken birth here will have to take rebirth.Only the Almighty who is the supreme father of all human being is freed from this bondage as he never takes birth as we do take.There are a no. of proofs we read in Newspapers about it.Plz. see www.bkwsu.com for details

2007-08-17 18:55:24 · answer #7 · answered by Anonymous · 0 0

Yes i was rebirth. I think my previous life was a cow. o.O

2007-08-17 06:49:18 · answer #8 · answered by Mr. Questionair 2 · 1 0

I believe in afterbirth... hahahaha! Sorry.

Ok, back to your question..

As in reincarnation? No.
As in spiritual rebirth, yes.

2007-08-17 06:47:30 · answer #9 · answered by scruffycat 7 · 2 0

Read "The Search for Bridey Murphy".

2007-08-17 06:48:10 · answer #10 · answered by spider87654 2 · 0 0

fedest.com, questions and answers