American or English Cocker Spaniel?

Question

Which would you pick and why? thanks!

Answer 1

They both have a lot in common, such as their need for high maintenance grooming, etc. But because they have been really popular in the past, they were overbred and there are lots of American Cockers out there who have bad temperments. Because of this, I'd choose the English Cocker, because it has not been so popular and so hasn't had the temperment issue come up. You could get an American Cocker with a good temperment, but you'd just have to be wary of breeders and careful about selecting one. Another option would be to adopt a Cocker Spaniel, since they are usually kept in foster homes and the rescue knows the dog's personality. I volunteer with a Cocker rescue, and I would highly recommend getting a puppy or adult from a rescue. Then you could know the dog's temperment and behavioral habits before you get him. You can look online at petfinder.com for your area, or if you are near Washington, DC, go to cockerspanielrescue.com. I hope you find a good pup!

Answer 2

Hi, my puppy is 14 weeks old and is wonderful.
She is a WORKING English cocker spaniel though, which means her coat is shorter and easier to maintain than the show type. She is very clever and has been easy to train (still working on the lead walking!!!!!!!) and is a very pretty little dog. Passers by always comment on her. She is affectionate without wanting to sit on your lap, and because of her breeding loves water and woody foresty type areas if you're interested in walking yourself.
I dont know what I did before I had her, I wasn't even a dog person but have fallen head over heels for her :))))
Contrary to opinion, cocker spaniels dont need miles and miles of walks, not even the working types.
I know Im biased but I would recommend an English Cocker spaniel, and at the risk of being naughty, I think they are prettier!! Sorry American cocker owners :)))))) ! ! ! !

Answer 3

Both can be good choices for a family companion. I've lived with Cockers for 50+ years now, both breeds. Select your breeder carefully and you'll enjoy the company of an intelligent, biddable and loving family member for many years to come.

What's with the Kavalier Nazi, anyhow? She must really resent Cockers and holds some serious sort of grudge.

Perhaps she can expand upon what can be found under the Cavalier genetic health topics on Wikipedia, re: Mitral valve disease (deadly), Syringomyelia (deadly), and other nasty (debilitating) problems to be found listed there for the CKCS. A sad commentary on THAT breed, indeed.

Answer 4

I like the English cocker myself.I think they have a calmer,more stable temperment,and there isn't as much coat care involved.Also,since they are not as common as the American cocker,you're more likely to get a better bred dog,without any serious health problems.

Answer 5

i would get neither. Both breeds are over bred. Causing them to have lots of medical problems and temperament problems. They do not do well with children. They tend to be fear biters. They are NOT very intelligent making them difficult to potty train or train in general. They are both nervous breeds and they tend to poop and pee themselves every time they get overly excited or scared. Cockers are the Most common pure bred dog found at the dog pound.
You may want to look into getting a Cavalier King Charles Spaniel. They are highly intelligent and make the perfect family dog. They are easily adaptable to any situation. They are like a golden retriever in a small body.

Here is a link to a video about the Cavalier King Charles Spaniel
Scroll down to "toy dogs" Click on it. Then scroll down and click on the Cavalier.....
http://animal.discovery.com/beyond/index.html?playerId=203719213&categoryId=211217098

Answer 6

ive had a english before so i would choose that one. also because there heads arent so squished in like american their more egg like