Atheists and non believers? What is your definition of sin and are you for or against it?

Question

No, I'm asking for you to explain what you think sin is.

Arn't crimes, mistakes, errors in judgment a way of defining the same thing? Why does the word 'sin' elicit such a negative response?

Answer 1

I'm no longer religious, but I feel that, at least from a religious viewpoint, your question is very important. Why should we and, indeed, how CAN we obey a deity's rules if we do not understand their purpose? Similarly, a parent does best if it explains its reasoning to its children when it develops rules.

Sin, from the perspective of many religions, is that which gets in the way of our union with a higher force, be it God, Allah, Krishna, etc. The rules are guidelines to help us make that connection more easily and to lead us away from so-called deceptive paths that merely perpetuate the ego.

And that is another important aspect of sin: the Self. If we are selfish, we are not selfless, which, by the teachings of many religions, is key to spirituality because it is inseparable from universal love. As I have seen, many sins are those things that keep one stuck within the sense of ego, i.e. those that seek personal pleasure alone.

Of course, many rules do seem superfluous, clearly products of their cultural upbringing. But when people try to cast these away, others get worked up, citing infallibility of the text. I wish people would see those books as guides rather than textbooks. Furthermore, there is no proof for the supernatural outside of personal experience, which most of us lack; therefore, the advantages of living a "sinless life" are hard to pin down.

I do recognize how the rules can be helpful, but it is important to note how they can be harmful not only when they have blind adherents who refuse to question, but when they are followed so strictly that compassion and understanding of others are lost.

As a non-believer, I don't put much thought into this "sin" business as it is almost always linked to some reward in the afterlife and/or a God-concept. I am neither for it, as I recognize that it can harm us, nor against it, as I also recognize that it can help us, depending on which set of rules you're following...

Answer 2

If you are asking about sin against some god? There is no such a thing.
If you are talking about sin (breaking the rules, morals, or ethics) of a society? There are laws and punishments already in place for that.

Answer 3

before everything, your questions in this subject count are published interior the biggest checklist, too. they are no longer in trouble-free terms shown of their instant class. 2nd of all, extremely some cases, atheists and agnostics settle directly to ask and answer in the Spirituality section using fact they do have ideals even nevertheless they do no longer join a "faith." like it or no longer, that must be respected. third, whilst atheists and agnostics use the Bible to cajole a Christian to re-evaluate issues, they are in many cases pointing out a contradiction in the religion. that's not that they suspect the two way, yet they are exhibiting that the thought gadget itself is faulted. extremely some the time, they are doing this using fact they easily need to assist the Christian to work out issues clearer and alter right into a extra suitable man or woman in the two techniques and heart. Fourth, have faith it or no longer, non secular divisions themselves are the very source of extremely some disrespect and hatred. What if human beings agreed to appreciate one yet another and do good, inspite of which God is "the genuine God"? do no longer you notice how that would make peace and attain the appropriate consequence? And interior the top, if there's a God, despite his call is, he would be happy that each and every of the individuals of creation are at peace.

Answer 4

oh, my it is going to be a long day -----------

You should already know the answer to this question, considering you "are" asking Atheists - that pretty much classifies us as nonbelievers -- so this would logically tell you Atheists do not believe in sin, god, the bible -- and therefore are neither for or against it.

How can a person be for or against something, they do not believe, in the first place? It seems to me that those who "believe" in sin are against it, because that means they will be held accountable for committing that action.

Answer 5

I have a sense of right and wrong which allows me to function in society without being afraid to do everything I really want to do because I might get thrown into Hell.

I feel sorry for people with such low morality that they need to be frightened to death into behaving properly.

Answer 6

Sin is BS.
No such thing.
Its a made up concept, to make people feel inferior and unworthy and in need of forgiveness by your superiors.

Answer 7

Oh, I'm all for sin! Killing puppies, eating babies, torturing and abusing children--and let's not forget cheating on my wife!

Where do you guys get these ridiculous ideas about Atheists?

We don't call it "sin," we call it "bad behavior." Since we are every bit as capable of love and honor as absolutely anyone else--regardless of what God they pray to--I still fail to see how our morals should constantly be under the microscope.

Besides, Hitler honestly thought he was doing God's will. So your interest in what Atheists consider wrong is....?

Answer 8

Sin is a creation of man, wherein mistakes are deemed to have consequences far more than the mistake might deserve.

I don't believe in sin. I do believe in mistakes. I do believe we can learn from our mistakes. For the gravest of mistakes, religion isn't needed, which is why our judicial system exists.

Answer 9

Sin:
1.the 22nd letter of the Hebrew alphabet.
2.the consonant sound represented by this letter.
3. the Akkadian god of the moon: the counterpart of the Sumerian Nanna
4. Symbol, Trigonometry. arc sine.

Answer 10

Sin (defined as a transgression against God's will or estrangement from God) becomes absolutely meaningless when you don't believe in the existence of any deities.

Hence your question is meaningless.