Muslims, should I believe the words of the prophets or the Qu'ran?

Question

Moses said a prophet must be in agreement with the prophets and the word of God.
Moses said there was a tree of life in the midst of the garden.
Moses said God said let US create man in OUR image. Then God created man with more than flesh but with an eternal spirit and these became a living soul.
Abraham said the lord would provide himself a lamb.
Isaiah said the Messiah would atone for sin.
John the Baptist said Behold the lamb of God.
Jesus agreed with the prophesy of Isaiah and said he was this Messiah and he would fufill this prophesy.
One Muslim said to be a good Muslim one must agree with the prophets of God and the Qu'ran.
How can a man agree with the prophets of God and the Qu'ran?

hello I quoted the prophets of God and these same words were available to Muhammad. If the Qu'ran is in agreement with the prophets of God why do these prophets teach the very things the Qu'ran rejects?

Egypt T It is good to disagree with God's prophets? I am sorry but not accoprding to the God of Abrham that Allah claims to be and I believe even the Qu'ran claims to be in agreement with the prophets of God. Moses taught all prophets logicly would agree with each other how could a prophet disagree with God and still be a prophet of God?

hujan you are coming very close to saying Muhammad is God....Now you say Muhammad's message is making clear my Bible and I say this can not be..
The word of God is not ina greement wiht the word of Allah ...Jesus is the son of God and says he is...How does denying his words make his words more clear?

yaz67 You say that the mesage of the prophets is God is one. This is not the only message of the prophets of God I have written some of the words of the prophets for you and tehse words are avialable to you and were avaialble to Muhammad... Now how does Muhamamd agree with these prophets?
Does Muhamamd and the qu'ran agree that Jesus is the Son of God who atoned for sin? Jesus said he was...Isaiah said he was and Abraham said he was....How does the Qu'ran agree?

mallak glad you answered...Now again does the Qu'ran agree with these words of the prophets...ZIf not you can not be a good Muslim as you answered a question saying a good Muslim must agree with the prophets of God and the Qu'ran , this is what prompted this question...Do you agree with the words of Moses, Abraham, Isaiah, John the Baptist and Jesus? If youd o not believe that the Messiah atoned for sin you are not in agreement with these prophets.

Humble God did not directly talk to Muhamamd, God does not need to directly speak to a prophet but all prophets must be in agreement and Muhamamd and the Qu'ran are not in agreement with the prophets of God.

Humble Read the words of the prophets you speak of they do not agree wiht the Qu'ran...Do not simply believe because Muhamamd says he agrees with them read their actual words and see if Muhamamd is in agreement with Abrham or Moses or Isaiah or Jesus...I assure you theya re not in agreement with Muhamamd or the Qu'ran. All you ahve to do is read the words of the prophets.

Bhola...So I could claim to be a prophet of God and disagree with all scripture and yet still claim to be a prophet of God who is in agrement with the other prophets of God? sir a prophet is required by God to be in agreement with God and the word of God and the [prophets of God this is from the first scriptures God gave to man...and is throughout the word of God...Allah is suposed to be the God of Abraham right? The God of Abraham says a prophet must be in agreement. did Muhamamd over throw God and change the rules? Is it the God of Abraham you worship or Muhamamd?

merosh
John 9:35 Jesus heard that they had cast him out; and when he had found him, he said unto him, Dost thou believe on the Son of God?
36 He answered and said, Who is he, Lord, that I might believe on him?
37 And Jesus said unto him, Thou hast both seen him, and it is he that talketh with thee.
38 And he said, Lord, I believe. And he worshipped him.

Jesus spoke of false prophets but did not mention Muhammad by name only that those who do not believe in him are of the spirit of anti Christ

Sincere, I appeciate your kind words but I do have a persaonla realtionship wiht the true God and I am in agreement wiht all fo God's prophets and do realize that the word of God is protected by God in its truth. God does not allow man to make his word a lie and all the prophets of God thoughout thousands of years are in agreement and in agreement with the word of God. the true God of Abrham does not allow a prophet to deny his word or to disagree with his prophets, Now Allahs says he is the God of Abraham but does not follow the ways of the God of Abraham. If Islam is correct then God is confused.

Answer 1

Good point my friend ...the Quran conflicts with MANY things the Old Testament prophets prophesied....and as you can see from the Muslim responses they clearly ignore that point.


They have to ignore that....because if they said they recognize it then they would be admitting publicly that Muhammed is a 'false' prophet...and all their Muslim buddies would kill them.

Its a self preservation thing...ya know.

Answer 2

Mohammed, pbuh, used to be a monotheist, no longer a Jew or a Christian, however a believer in a single God. There had been a small quantity of monotheists in Makkah on the time, adding additionally Khadija, who come to be the spouse of the Prophet. I do not know that any uncorrupted written scripture has been preserved to these days from see you later in the past. Can you reply what written scripture did Abraham, pbuh, comply with? What do you imply approximately a e-book which refers to prophets however does no longer educate atonement? Muslims are taught to truly repent for his or her sins, however are taught that Allah does no longer opt for blood sacrifices. Sincere repentance comes from inside and manifests itself in a difference of habits. "People of the Book" refers back to the folks who comply with the Torah and the Evangel. There is just one God.

Answer 3

If any reference contradict with the teachings of God can not be considered for acceptance.
Any thing allegedly associated with Prophets, that contradict with Holy Scripture makes Scripture doubtfull itself.
So this is the case of contradictions of reference, not the teachings of God Almighty or Teachings of His Prophets.

Check your references.

Answer 4

Islam is the message of the all the prophets as all the prophets preached that the greatest commandment was to worship only ONE God and not to make partners or images of Him and to follow the prophets. This is the message of Islam - the voluntary submission, acceptance and obedience to the One God in peace who is our creator. And this is what the Quran says.

As for Jesus - Islam believes him to be the messiah and a prophet of God but not the son of God or a part of the trinity. Trinity was not preached by any prophet nor does it appear in the Bible.

Answer 5

Qura'n and Hadees are very clear about Status of God Almighty and Status of Holy Prophet Jesus(pbuh).

If you accept truth and study properly you will get vision and wisdom to clarify your doubts you gets from your references.

I would recommend you to study meterial that is authentic and not corrupted by human being.

You have inquisitive approach , and this is good up to some extent and taking advantage of this nature study authentic meterials, uncorrupted through centuries and still valid as it written for today as well as for future.

If you study Qura'n and authentic Hadees with clear mind without presumptions you will find there are no contradictions.

Prophet Muhammad always gave utmost importance to Qura'n, as direct guidance from Allah. He never tried to overcome teachings of Qura'n but to give explanations to the words of God Almighty.

That is the reason He strictly instructed his companions not to write his hadees during revaluation period of Qura'n to avoid mixing God words and His words or Hadees.

As I said earlear you need a lot of study and proper guidance to understand science of qura'n and Hadees.
Accept Truth and study Holy Scripture under guidance of an authentic Scholar and be a scholar as you wish, and serve Humanity,

I pray for your success, Insha Allah.

Answer 6

God chooses righteous men to be his prophets, and directly communicates truth to them. God commands the prophet to teach everybody the truth. God will bless the people who listen to and believe what the prophet teaches.



Qura'n says several places,

"Atiullah wa Ati ur Rasool" in different words as well.


Al-Qura'n.
Whoever obeys the Messenger, he indeed obeys Allah, and whoever turns back, so We have not sent you as a keeper over them. (Surah An-Nisa, 80)

It is not fitting for a Believer, man or woman, when a matter has been decided by Allah and His Messenger to have any option about their decision: if any one disobeys Allah and His Messenger, he is indeed on a clearly wrong Path. (Surah Al-Ahzab, 36)

Allah has informed in the surah Al-e Imran that the Prophet had the characteristic of teaching the Qur'an and purifying mankind:
Certainly Allah conferred a benefit upon the believers when He raised among them a Messenger from among themselves, reciting to them His communications and purifying them, and teaching them the Book and the wisdom, although before that they were surely in manifest error. (Surah Al-e Imran, 164)


So for Muslims Qura'n ( Direct teachings of Allah), and Sunnah ( Traditions fo Rasool Allah), as explanation of Qura'n, both are important.

Dear Sir, I invite you to accept Truth and follow Prophet Moses, Jesus, and Muhammad, and their True teachings, instead of chasing corrupted materials.

Answer 7

there is no conflict between the words of the Prophets, and the Qur'an. All of the Prophets called to the worship of the one true God. NONE of them called to a trinitarian God. The Qur'an is the final revelation of God sent to mankind.

In the Bible Jesus talks of one who will come after him whose name will be Ahmad (in original manuscript). This is how Muhammad was known. For those with a sincere heart the truth is clear.

May Allah guide you

Answer 8

The place of the Prophet Muhammad, whose light is the first of Allah’s creation, is described in his own words, ‘I am from Allah and the believers are from me’. And Allah, speaking through His Prophet, says: ‘I have created the light of Muhammad from the light of My own existence’. The meaning of Allah’s own existence is His divine Essence manifested in His attribute of the Most Compassionate. This He declares through His Prophet, saying: ‘My compassion far surpasses My punishment’. The beloved Messenger of Allah is the light of the Truth, for Allah says, We sent thee not but as a mercy to the whole creation. (Sura Anbiya’, 107) and

Indeed Our Messenger has come to you, making clear to you much of that which you concealed of the Book and passing over much. Indeed, there has come to you from Allah a light ... (Sura Ma’ida, 15)

The importance of the beloved Prophet of Allah is made clear when Allah speaks to him and says: ‘But for you, I would not have created creation’.

Answer 9

to believe in both that Qu'ran is the word of god revealed to Muhammad and Muhammad is the prophet of god

Answer 10

not agree with them i think he ment to beleive that they are prophets of god .Qu'ran always comes first