Atheists, why are you here?

Question

I respect you and don't mean to offend you.

The section of R & S is meant only for those who believe in God because
1) Religion is obviously related to God.
2) Spirituality contains the element of the Holy Spirit. All religions like Christianity, Hinduism, Buddhism, Islam agree to it.

Therefore, this section is not meant for you. Why don't you atheists go some place else or make your own section titled "ATHEISTS".

When you say that this section is meant for discussion, you're right. But, some of you ( some of us theists, too) have taken a vow to be disrespectful, which is not good.

You're right, spirituality has nothing to do with religion, but it is related to God or to put it another way, a supernatural being or conscience.

Why are millions of people theists (including scientists and engineers) and only a few, atheists?

Yes, Buddhism is a philosophy, but I'd suggest you got to Tibet ( because I've been there ) to get a better understanding of this 'philosophy'.

Correction: # I'd suggest you go to.......

Very well then, I'm linked with Yahoo authorities. I'll recommend a different section for you people.

But, then I've no problems having you here because I know many of my friends who are atheists are indeed law abiding citizens. They're kind, generous and very helpful.

Answer 1

I believe some of them are honestly here to learn about other religions and why we believe what we do. I've encountered some very intelligent and respectful atheists from that group - people I would most likely be friends with in real life.

However, there's another (larger) group of atheists here for the sole purpose of antagonizing believers. It's from that group of atheists that I've encountered people who are bigoted, arrogant to the extreme, and just plain rude. They give lame excuses about how they're here to "educate" us because they feel sorry that we've been brainwashed. Uhh... yeah. They're here to provoke people. They can deny it all they want, but the evidence is clear in their questions and answers.

And, YA is not a discussion forum for religion. It's a place to ask and answer questions regarding Religion and Spirituality. If you're looking to debate or have a productive two-way discussion, this is NOT the appropriate place because YA is not set up to allow it properly. Yes, everyone has opinions, but sometimes you should exercise a little self-control and keep them to yourself. Like when a poster is going through a difficult time and asks specifically for Christian answers, prayer, or encouragement. Those posters aren't asking for your "opinion" that God is "make-believe" and that the Bible is a "fairytale." Those posters are looking for serious answers because they're hurting, and people should respect that.

Answer 2

The word 'religion' encompasses more than just Christianity. You can even be spiritual without being religious. The Religion & Spirituality section is for anyone who wishes to discuss those topics. Therefore, you do not get to dictate who speaks here.

People cannot create their own sections. If they could, I'm sure atheists would indeed make their own. However, I'm also sure that the more obnoxious portion of Christians on Y!A would be overcome with the need to harrass and proselytise there.

Edit: In regards to your edit about scientists - I (not to mention the actual scientific community) am more inclined to believe and trust the research of a scientist who has no religious affiliation, since they are less likely to twist the results to fit their own religious views. The more someone knows about the hard sciences, the more likely they are to be atheist, or at least agnostic.

Answer 3

Sorry, wrong again. This section is for anyone who wants to comment on religion or spirituality.

1. Not all religions believe in one god. Buddhism is more than simply a philosophy.

2. Wrong. Spirituality does not always pertain to the Christian concept involving the trinity known as the "holy spirit."

This section is for anyone. Get used to it.

Answer 4

because you asked a question directed to atheists

is it? where does it say that?

1. yes and so we're not allowed to point out that there isn't one?
2. many atheists are spiritual like buddhists, I'm not but again aren't I allowed to point out that it's bullsh!t?

Thank you for demonstrating why atheists should be in this section. Apparently we're not allowed to have an opinion. I see. Perhaps you'd prefer if we were just locked up in camps somewhere

BTW you might want to next time make use of the search function so you don't waste 5 points

Answer 5

No, spirituality can be any religion or not have to do with religion at all. Atheist implies they don't believe in your God, but may believe in other spiritual things. My Atheist fiance believes strongly in spirits and has seen them, so he is spiritual, but has no religion and does not believe any God exists.

Also, Atheists are here for the same reason you'd go into an Atheist section-- curiosity. Humans are just like that.

I don't believe in your God, but I do believe in Lukaeleroh and it is spiritual, but by your reasoning I have no right to be here? Religion is not related just to one God, but any God that anyone in the human race believes in. Lukaeleroh has nothing to do with the Holy Spirit, neither does Buddism, Paganism, or many others.

Atheism is a belief, and they have every right to be here.

PS-- your name is a Marilyn Manson reference...:)

Answer 6

We are here to help...think of us as the opposition party. Religion is defined as a particular system of faith. My faith is that there is no supreme being or holy spirit. Also, you need to do your homework a bit. Buddhism is a philosophy and not a religion. Buddhism has no creator god and gives a central role to the doctrine of karma. The ‘four noble truths’ of Buddhism state that all existence is suffering, that the cause of suffering is desire, that freedom from suffering is nirvana, and that this is attained through the ‘eightfold’ path of ethical conduct, wisdom, and mental discipline (including meditation).
If you are so confident in your faith then why should atheists upset you so much? You would think that anyone who seeks to challenge your beliefs would be met with your own truths....if they are in fact true.

Answer 7

1) Religion is related to god ... no problem with that
2) Spirituality contains the element of the holy spirit ..... you are quite wrong in that. Buddhism, Taoism, Hinduism has nothing to do with what you call the holy spirit.

3) Now, may I ask you why you often see Christians and hardcore religious people inside Gay and Lesbian forum?

Answer 8

"Spirituality contains the element of the Holy Spirit. All religions like Christianity, Hinduism, Buddhism, Islam agree to it."

haha, nice try... actually spirituality is all about alcoholic spirits. everyone knows that! drink!

Answer 9

Mostly I'm curious.
You all say how God touched you in some way, and now you believe.
Well I'm wondering if it delusional or real.
I was a believer because I didn't know any better.
Then people started to say why they believe, and I never felt that.
So I questioned my faith (not really sure I ever had it).
Why do you believe, did you feel something I'm not capable of doing? Well good for you.
Or was it something you just never really thought about.

Answer 10

Do you feel threatened? Is your belief not strong enough to withstand debate. Spirituality is the belief in spirit (animating or vital principle of person or animal - as per the Oxford dictionary), not specifically the holy spirit. One can be spiritual without being religious, and usually far more open minded for being so. Over the centuries how many wars have been fought in the name of atheism?