Rep. Tom Tancredo suggests that threatening to bomb Muslim holy sites would help deter terrorism. Agree or no?

Question

Colorado Rep. Tom Tancredo believes that threatening Muslim extremists with the possibility of bombings on holy sites such as Mecca and Medina would provide a successful “deterrent” for future terrorist attacks against the United States.

Do you agree or disagree?

Answer 1

What a stupid suggestion, certainly not! you have to be prepaired to back up your threats, by targeting "Holy Sites" you run the risk of such action of turning the more moderate Muslims into U.S. Haters.

Mecca is in Saudia Arabia, and Saudia is not at war with the USA, so that would be an act of Aggression, and a US attack on that site would turn every Muslim in the world against the US and there are far more of them on the planet than Americans.

Any way under the "Rules of Warfare" Churches, Mosques, Shrines, Hospitals etc are out of bounds.
Just because the Insurgents don't respects the rules does not mean we have to lower ourselves to their level.

Answer 2

might desire to you supply a hyperlink on what he suggested specifically? i could choose for to work out him attempt. What stable could that do? What have Muslim holy web pages completed to harm anybody? could therefor Iraqi human beings be justified in bombing christian web pages? Its in basic terms stupid. Bush is a christian might desire to Muslims marketing campaign to bomb christian holy sited then? Its ridiculous the guy might desire to be a moron if it somewhat is what he suggested. I on no account heard of anybody bombing catholic holy web pages whilst the IRA the place terrorizing and bombing my u . s . a . for over a decade. each and every person is terrorists no longer faiths. people who're terrorist might have specific faiths that does no longer propose the religion or different followers of that faith are taught or help such crimes. If he incredibly suggested that then he's an fool with a capital I. i might desire to tension i'm being very woman like in the words i take advantage of to describe him i could choose for to call him extra besides. thank you Da guy :)

Answer 3

Wouldn't work. It's like threatening the Ku Klux Klan by threatening to blow up Protestant churches in the South.
I like Tom Tancredo. But, he's off-base on this one.

Answer 4

That policy statement is just plain thoughtless.

If you threaten to bomb a holy site, you bring the people involved with the extremists.

It would also bring the other Arab nations to the fore.

Answer 5

Totally disagree. They'd destroy it themselves if given half the chance. Major terrorist attacks have taken place in Mecca during the Haj. Thousands have been killed.

Answer 6

Muslims respect power, yes it would work splendidly and no it would never happen in today's politically correct world.

I am glad there was not political correctness during the American Revolution and WW 2.

Answer 7

The man's a fool. This would create millions more terrorists

Answer 8

Stop the talk and walk the arty. Stop pussy footin' around. Go for the throat and lets be done with this PC crap. War is ugly and war is hell...Sooooo....."GET SOME!!"

Answer 9

Tancredo is an idiot.

Answer 10

disagree strongly