shouldn't the JA ( Judge Advocate ) appointed in a court martial be replaced with a high court judge?

Question

JA, under the command and control of the prosecuting auth , acts as the glorified court clerk as well. He records what is been told to be recorded. CAT is yet to be okayed. in the meantime should we not accept high court judges to be the judge advocate?

Answer 1

Sounds like you have never bothered to learn anything about how the military justice system operates.

Answer 2

Ya, i have gone through the most of the answer given by the people with their ego/unthoughtful comments. As far as justice is concerned its true that its speedy and approximately to the point. But often their are cases where the punishment awarded are either too less or unjustified. In such cases the individuals of spl lower ranks dont have the guts to hire civil advocate or reappeal in high court if he wants to continue in service , he would be tortured and his life could be made miserable.
There are instants where the great guns involved are left scot free, by deleating the evidences.
But here too, if the judge is appointed from high court, his accomodation and other facility is done at OM, which would give ample time to other party to get the justice as per their wishes.
Its just a suggestion, its not going to be the rule, one should answer takeing this thing in to consideration.

Answer 3

A key ingredient of military justice is the speed with which justice is dispensed! And, that is very important to the military administration and maintenance of highest standards of discipline in the services! If you bring authorities from outside into the military justice machinery, the leadership image is bound to get affected! Moreover, a JA is not the kind of puppet you make out the JA to be!

Answer 4

Court Martial by its very name is a military court. Why would a civilian hold any power in that court. Read up on the UCMJ Then if think you need to, ask the question again.

Answer 5

I dont think of a choose could get excitement from that remark. you may probable get a harsher sentence even. it may coach which you dont have repect for the regulation of the land. subsequently you wouldnt look sense sorry approximately-complete. that could piss off a choose, no longer a superb area of do once you're at his/her mercy.

Answer 6

now the time has changed... world wars are history now... all the judicial cases except departmental ones should be handed-over to the national judiciary...