1. If we evolved from monkeys...?
2. If atheism isn't a religion...?
3. How can atheists believe the universe evolved...?
4. Is faith required...?
5. Are atheists smarter...?
6. The laws of thermodynamics...?
7. Atheists: look at the world around you...?
8. Why do you criticize...?
9. Can you prove...?
2007-07-31
10:11:38
·
23 answers
·
asked by
Anonymous
in
Society & Culture
➔ Religion & Spirituality
Hey! Some great responses. Thanks for making the end of my workday pleasant, all (well, not "all" but most!).
:)
2007-07-31
10:22:19 ·
update #1
David I: "I have to change a patient's ostomy bag. I suspect that the contents will greatly resemble the fundamentalist interpretation of the universe."
OMG That is one of the funniest things I've ever read on Y!A! Thanks!
2007-07-31
10:46:05 ·
update #2
Antihero: Indeed it was. Thanks a bunch!
2007-07-31
10:46:38 ·
update #3
Sorry, but after 9 drinks, I wouldn't be able to drive home.
2007-07-31 10:13:46
·
answer #1
·
answered by nondescript 7
·
5⤊
0⤋
1) If we evolved from monkeys... then we would have a temporal paradox on our hands. We didn't evolve from monkeys. We share a common ancestor.
2) If atheism isn't a religion... then I'm not the Queen of England. I'm not the Queen of England. Atheism isn't a religion.
3) How can the atheists believe the universe evolved... when the theory of evolution doesn't have anything to do with matter in general? It has to do with the development of life over many many generations, and atheists know this and don't make a silly mistake like that.
4) Is faith required... in a secular nation like the United States? No.
5) Are atheists smarter... than theists? As a group, yes. Atheists as a whole tend to be more educated than the general population. (This is not a stab at individual theists. I'm not saying that all theists are less intelligent than all atheists. I'm saying simply that uneducated people are more likely to the be theist, not that theists are uneducated.)
6) The laws of thermodynamics... have nothing to do with the universe as a whole. Entropy applies to a closed system, which the universe is not because it is expanding.
7) Atheists: look at the world around you... and congratulate yourselves for making more sense than most people.
8) Why do you criticize... atheists when your own beliefs just fill in holes with made up stuff?
9) Can you prove... that some form of deity exists? Of course you can't, so stop being obnoxious, pretending like you know everything.
2007-07-31 10:26:28
·
answer #2
·
answered by Sacred Chao 4
·
3⤊
0⤋
1. If we evolved from monkeys...then explain Paris Hilton.
2. If atheism isn't a religion... then why does the internet exist?
3. How can atheists believe the universe evolved... into a jelly donut?
4. Is faith required... to operate Windows Vista?
5. Are atheists smarter... than grapefruit?
6. The laws of thermodynamics...state that you will shorten the lifespan of the universe by cleaning your room.
7. Atheists: look at the world around you... and find me a beer volcano?
8. Why do you criticize... the other guys who enterprise has made them rise above the guys who criticize?
9. Can you prove... that the Men in Black aren't real?
2007-07-31 11:45:29
·
answer #3
·
answered by Anonymous
·
0⤊
0⤋
For point one, read Darwin. He nowhere says we evolved from apes. He suggests we and the apes evolved from the same genetic parent. The man evolved from apes rubbish came from a bunch of critics who cannot actually understand the science, and cannot be bothered to try.
For point two, atheism is the belief that there is/are no God/Gods. It is a belief structure, but since it has no Deity or metaphysical baisis it cannot be classed as a religion. Certain Deists try to classify it as such, but that indicates their unwillingness to accept ideas contrary to their own opinions. Believing that the Yankees will not win the pennant does not make you a baseball fan.
For point three, atheists no doubt believe all kinds of different things. Many accept evolution as a very likely theory. Some believe we were left by aliens, I bet. Since you are stuck on the evolution theory, may I ask what actual evidence exists that it is not valid? The collected studies of many well intentioned and highly principled scientists have come up with volumes of supporting evidence, but not one antiDarwinist has come up with any refutation beyond blind faith.
Point four deals with faith. Faith is most important to any believer, and agnostic old me considers the atheists and Deists in the same boat there. Lacking any evidence of any Creator(s)' existence, how can anybody be that sure?
Point five begs the question, "smarter than who?" They very likely to be smarter than some individual who believes the Christian misinterpretation of the Torah is the Divinely inspired word of God. Why did the Christers steal a God, but ignore His teachings?
The classic example might be the misinterpretation of the kosher laws in Deuteronomy as a prohibition against medical intervention, but that is only one. Since they otherwise ignore the kosher laws anyway, why should they matter? If they are divinely inspired, why are you eating pork? Christians cannot insist the Old Testament is the word of God, and then ignore the parts they don't like.
The Old Testament also says that each man must find his own way to God, and forbids prozelytizing, yet Christians feel entitled to "testify" at the top of their selfrighteous lungs.
I am running out of patience, and my break is over. I have to change a patient's ostomy bag. I suspect that the contents will greatly resemble the fundamentalist interpretation of the universe.
Please do not try to discuss Darwin before you read him yourself. He was a devout Christian, himself, and insisted there was room for his theory within the faith. Read HIM, not some excrement kicker who gets paid to rant about what he's been told Darwin said.
2007-07-31 10:36:27
·
answer #4
·
answered by Anonymous
·
2⤊
0⤋
1. Why then does Robin Williams still exist
2. Then why do we allow them to get married?
3. From my pants?
4. To answer the phone?
5. Than the average bear?
6. Don't work on refrigerators?
7. and then take a nap.
8. The government, be a drone like I am.
9. that I have an IQ?
2007-07-31 10:32:43
·
answer #5
·
answered by meissen97 6
·
1⤊
0⤋
1....it would explain where our form came from. It wouldn't be in the image of god now, would it?
2....it's just the belief there is no god. We follow what society thinks is right, which is constantly changing through the different generations.
3....who said anything about the universe evolving? we are just talking about us right now, one step at a time.
4....to do what, think on terms of reality and whats not?
5....no one is smarter than anyone. Intelligence isn't a factor when talking about religion or lack there of.
6....shouldn't be part of this.
7....It's full of the things humans have created from the earth. Except nature, that's the planets doing.
8....because you are using your imagination when thinking of god, and not thinking on terms of reality.
9....it has nothing to do with proof. It's called common sense.
2007-07-31 10:35:01
·
answer #6
·
answered by Stevo 2
·
1⤊
0⤋
if you are really bored, go and read a book, I am sure there could be just a single one you have not read yet... if that does not work, perhaps you can play with yourself... if that does not work, find some sheep to molest, your questions are juvenile, inane, simplistic, and mostly very boring...
also, there is a difference between monkeys and apes, somebody with your education should know that...
EDIT:"David I: "I have to change a patient's colostomy bag. I suspect that the contents will greatly resemble the fundamentalist interpretation of the universe."
you are a little POS worm with heart as big as a pin head cold-hearted worm you are... you just may need a colostomy one day and then I hope you will encounter a being like you are...
2007-07-31 10:16:28
·
answer #7
·
answered by Anonymous
·
1⤊
1⤋
*
1. If we evolved from monkeys...you evolved from your second cousin Carl
2. If atheism isn't a religion...than bald isn't a hair color
3. How can atheists believe the universe evolved...from a magical invisible sky god with no respect for consistency
4. Is faith required...NO
5. Are atheists smarter...YES
6. The laws of thermodynamics...blah blah blah
7. Atheists: look at the world around you...it is full of retards
8. Why do you criticize...because I have a brain and I live in a democracy
9. Can you prove...No and neither can you so Shut it!
2007-07-31 10:16:45
·
answer #8
·
answered by Anonymous
·
4⤊
1⤋
1. Because monkeys eat bananas.
2. Because the sky is blue.
3. A little birdie told me to believe it.
4. Only on Saturdays.
5. No, but they're better-looking.
6. No they don't.
7. When pigs fly.
8. Because I can
9. Can you disprove...?
2007-07-31 10:16:31
·
answer #9
·
answered by Anonymous
·
3⤊
0⤋
1...that explains why we're omnivorous and put on stupid displays to impress females.
2...I can be assured that I haven't been sucked into another illogical belief system.
3...when its so easy to just say "God did it"?
4...to win an election below the bible belt?
5...than theists or just more accepting of reality as it is?
6...mean that our energy will continue to feed the natural ecological cycle
7...and see that only an incompetent or malicious creator would put us here.
8...dogmatic theism instead of seeking more of an intellectual challenge?
9...that God doesn't exist? Of course I can't because anyone who's taken philosophy 101 or has a rational mind knows that you can't prove a negative.
2007-07-31 10:29:53
·
answer #10
·
answered by Subconsciousless 7
·
2⤊
0⤋
1. It would explain Bush.
2. Than what is it?
3. From a pickled beet?
4. To be a Bible-thumper? Yes.
5. Than a Bible-thumper? Generally.
6. I'll pass on this one.
7. And it's obvious that God doen't give a rat's @ss.
8. People who try to shove religion down our throats?
9. That there's no God? No. Can you prove there IS one?
2007-07-31 10:19:46
·
answer #11
·
answered by Anonymous
·
2⤊
1⤋