Was Karl Marx just another "Godman"? I don't find any differece between communism and religion!?

Question

They believe in the "No God" deity, hence no name! Other than that there is no difference in ideology!

Answer 1

If you check the history, most of the original communists were Russian Orthodox (Christian).

Answer 2

Marx was a Jew who lived by the Talmud and you really need to read at least some of this book to understand how he gravitated to Atheistic communism.
You can do a search for the `Babylonian Talmud ` online, also you can read the reasons for Marx`s Atheistic communism on several websites, try this one for now; www.savethemales.ca.
Also do a search on the author` Elizabeth Dilling` who shows the direct connection between the Babylonian Talmud and communism and the Jews.
If you do all this I think you may well have your answer.

Answer 3

It's true
Sincere believer give up the fruits of his labor for God's sake (in hinduism and orthodox christianity at least).
Sincere communist give up the fruits of his labor for the sake of others.

Marxism includes the science about a development of material world (=sankhya-darsana in vedic philosophy).


Thereafter a doctrine by Karl Marx is SANKHYA without God.

But still in marxism the clear CONSCIENCE is god and principal criterion of human activities!

Sage Karl Marx muniji? OK, but only after Kapila muni...

Answer 4

Yes .The head and the feet are always connected .The head can survive though with some inconvenience without the feet , the feet cannot survive without the head .Communism is the stage devotee reaches out of frustration . Communism glorifies the equal treatment of all humans with violence which religions has been teaching for centuries with persuation.and reasoning .
communism and religions , both see god in the humans .Communism does nt say it and religion says it .

Answer 5

The question is confusing. How could some one who is God is also a man or "God man"? I think you should read the works of Karl Marx to understand him.

Answer 6

I've seen such comments before, and I just have to ask, what's so bad about communism? In a perfect society, where there is plenty for everyone, no one needs more than they have and no one wants more than they need, communism is the only way to be. If you don't want more than you have, and you have all you need, what's it matter who owns what? There's plenty for everyone, and you're free to stop worrying about who's got what and what you don't have and get on with improving yourself. The only problem with communism in this world is that there is NOT enough to go around, and no one's ever satisfied with what they have, they want it all. Because this is not a perfect society, communism just doesn't work, but that doesn't make communism bad or evil. The same applies to laws. In a perfect society, anarchy (lawlessness) is the ideal state of being because no one does anything that anyone would wish to be illegal, so laws just aren't necessary. Again, this is not the perfect society, so laws are absolutely necessary.

Answer 7

Marx and his followers and experiments are almost dead.
Russia has fallen Stalin' statue has tumbled.
the cruelty and oppressions and the millions murdered.
Marx is in his tomb returned to the earth,
Jesus tomb is empty risen. and seen for 40 days!
documented,
Mark and Stalin and all those poor deceived souls are dead and in hell.
There was no good in what Marx taught,believe and brought death and destruction to countries .
Jesus taught love and forgiveness.
How could two be even remotely alike.
There is no other deity but the one true God Deity, the Trinity, Father, Son and Holy Ghost.
One may not believe in him and that is your right and choice,
i neither condemn nor judge you for it
But what if he does exist and you miss him
you would have missed everything.

I am taking no chances, if he doesn't exist i have lost nothing, if he does exist i have gained everything;
if he exists and you denied him you will hit hell wide open , no stop or sorry God i change my mind, for then it will be too late.
For he said in his word. if you deny me before man i will Deny you before God my father.............

Answer 8

Read "The Undiscovered Self" by Carl Jung. He actually discusses how Communism attempts to take the place of god.

Answer 9

Communism has NOTHING to do with religion.
Communism is an economic theory that has nothing to do with god or the gods. It is a system where social classes don't exist! The wealth is shared by all in society

"A governmental system that encourages the elimination of private property and the equitable distribution of goods to the public. A Communist government maintains central control over banking, business, housing, education, industry, medical care, the military, and regional security forces."

I don't really see where any of that has anything to do with religion. . .

Answer 10

Religion is different than communism. Under religion (excluding the fanatics that kill people, they are an exception) you have free choice to believe.

Under communism your choices are controlled by the point of a bayonet.