Muslim brothers and sisters, how do you feel with all this fitnah in the air?

Question

As salaam alaikum. I just came across what you could call a debate, ( I call it alot of hate), here between muslim brothers and sisters.

I could not beleive some of the things I was reading, and to think that this was muslim against muslim. I admit, I have said some things which some may consider rude or downright mean, to non muslims in retaliation for their hateful spite of Islam, and only in defending my faith, but never to another muslim, calling other muslims kufrs and such... That is for Allah (swt) to judge.

How does all of this make you feel?

I have read throgh answer 16 and alhumdulilah, we all seem to be on the same level.

I have again come across some really offensive questions, or actually posts, and now is the perfect time to say that I am leaving answers for good. I cant understand why so many people are so hateful, it is a shame and quite pathetic.

I cannot and will not be a part of such ahte...astugfurullah.

May the blessings of ALLAH be with you all......salaam alaikum

Answer 1

Strange world when Muslims are arguing with each other. In Palestine they solve differences by throwing each other off roofs. Simply arguing doesn't solve anything.

Answer 2

I've never read such things here, though.
But it sad that Islam is divided into so many sects...
Common people, like us, don't usually fight with each other becaue of sects. But we sometimes spot a mullah who is saying bad words against another sect to spread prejuidice and hatred.
No one can decide that the other is kafir or Muslim... it is up to Allah to decide it.
Actually the so-called molveez (sorry if you don't agree) have limited Islam to rituals. Islam is not ritualism... it's a way of living.
King Akbar The Great is notorious (sort of) because he created another religion, "Deen-e-Ilahi". But if we study the history, we'll see that the creation of this bedaa was because of the condition of most of the ulmaas of that time. They had busied themselves in giving fatwaas against each other.

I'm not suggesting that all the Ulmaas are bad, there are some very good... but the majority is disappointing. Reason is that they are only concentrating on the ritual side of Islam. I mean they can teach you how to stand in Salah (prayer), how to do sajdah etc. but they won't teach you that you shouldn't think of anything else in salah but Allah. To them, ritual is everything. That is why Muslim reciting Quran everyday, but aren't understanding it.

Islam is beautiful
Tafarqa is ugliness (I can't help thinking it).
And Materialistic approach is the root of every misery!

Answer 3

If a gem falls into dirt it is still a gem, but if dirt flies into the air, it is still dirt.

What I mean by this sister, Is that I agree with you. But it is also necessary to correct anyone who acts to be a Muslim and calls others Kafir. That is Allah's job, not ours. Who are we to decide anything. I don't know if you saw my question before,but I was talking about being just regardless if a it is a Muslim or not.

Non-Muslims have all the right to state their opinion. Because they are representing their beliefs.But when another Muslim insults another Muslim. Cursing and name calling. That is hypocrisy. You wouldn't believe how many hateful e-mails I received from some Muslims on here. BUT I am no one to judge them. Maybe they did it because they were angered and offended by something and for that I apologize to whomever. May Allah guide us ALL, and make all of us worthy to represent Islam.

Jazakallah Khair.

Answer 4

I find it sad and unacceptable and I will not participate. I will leave Answers if this continues because I refuse to be associated with such nonsense. This is not what Allah wants from us.

Answer 5

I agree with you sister. Who are we to call each other khafirs? That's for ALLAH(SWT) to decide, not us.

If Muslims against Muslims are tearing those apart, then imagine what a bad reputation Muslims are putting upon themselves, and influencing the western perspectives of Islam.

Answer 6

wa 3alaikom assalaam.

The Prophet said what means: (If a person addresses his fellow Muslim by telling him, "You are a blasphemer", then one of the 2 is a blasphemer. It is either that what the addresser said is true or the addresser himself becomes a blasphemer.)

From this Hadeeth it is known that one might call someone a blasphemer for a reason and would be truthful and one might call someone a blasphemer without a reason and become a blasphemer him/herself as a result.

Answer 7

There should not be any labelling of anyone when answering of questions. We should not be carried away with our Ego and Emotion. Lets forgive and forget the whole issue. Take this opportunity to learn from each other but not otherwise.

Answer 8

i really felt sad and depressed................this is a kind of "Fetna" that took place between us Muslims, especially sisters, today.....and i replied in most of the answers, and also posted a question as a kind of appology on the behalf of another person who caused this Fetna.(YA deleted my question :(

yeah, i wish to stop this Fetna quickly, and stop calling others names, although actually many where so respectable and humble, never said a bad word.

thanks for your post.
peace be upon you.

Answer 9

it really makes me sad..i dn't mind non-believers to offend me....but ti hurts when it comes from a brother or sister....
the debates about sunna is increasing and it shocks me how many muslims are ignorant about their religion,sorry but it's the truth...

but anyhow,this time the prophet told about b4...where fitnah will be increasing,so the muslim holding to his faith as if he's holding a burning stone(gamr).....

i wish we hold on more...and try to learn more about our religion and our prophet....

Answer 10

it depend on what you are referring to.. Kufur.. actually we can said kufur.. to the Muslims who dis Obey Al`Quran.. & Hadis.. Prophet Muhammad(SAW).. Al`Quran & Hadis refer to what our act.. Remember Al~Quran.. is given to Corect the Wrong.. If some1 tell me that the act that i do is again Al`Quran.. & I will become Kufur if i keep on doing it.. I will come in front of him or her with humble & said Please Guide me to The Right Path.. True Muslims will Never ignore the truth of Al`Quran & Hadis Prophet Muhammad(SAW).. But the Kufur will keep on & ignore..

Answer 11

It's why I like to stay away from the R&S section sometimes!


Ppl use 'kufir' way too much --it's like the way ppl say sh*t or something in Englsih. We should work more on bettering oursleves.
But remember we are all human and have out faults...

Anyway, it makes me SICK!!!!!!!