I just wanted to see what others had to say. I asked this question because I see so many people say Harry dies then comes back to life at after the King's Cross chapter. I think based on what was said on pages 707-708 (US edition) that Harry was somewheres between life and death. Opinions?
2007-07-25 18:28:38 · 11 answers · asked by Iljimae Fan 7 in Arts & Humanities ➔ Books & Authors
cornflake#1 Try to keep up. Please read the entire question before attempting an answer. I did not ask you how long the British edition is. I already know it is 607 pages. I specifically state I was referring to the US edition. If you look at these product details from www. barnesandnoble.com you will see they refer to the US edition.
Product Details
# ISBN: 0545010225
ISBN-13: 9780545010221
# Format: Hardcover, 759pp
# Publisher: Scholastic, Inc.
# Sales Rank: 1
2007-07-25 19:32:32 · update #1
ANGEL needs VIKAS !! Thanks for trying but I already knew all that. As I stated in my original question, I have already read the book. I didn't ask who died. I already knew that. I asked for opinions on Harry's death since so many people seem to think he died and came back to life. I couldn't access the link provided but i suspect it doesn't answer the question either.
Please consider revising your answer to include your opinion on Harry's "death" experience. Do you think he died and came back to life like so many people seem to think?
2007-07-26 03:12:12 · update #2
page 707 dumbledore tells harry on the whole he isn't dead. The part of voldemort died. But Harry had a choice to go on. ie: harry at kings cross and he was able to make a choice to board a train,to take him where... dont know =)
2007-07-25 18:55:37 · answer #1 · answered by Heather N 2 · 0⤊ 0⤋
Hmmmmm? < pondering >,
There may be a tardisantium curse on your book, dear. Nothing a good witch or wizard can't handle. My copy of HP & The Deathly Hallows is only 607 pages long - maybe you're just a slow reader. Try to keep up!
You'd better hurry. They do say that size isn't everything, dear. I'd take your own copy round to your local bookshop. Give some of the more magically adept staff a laugh. Better hurry, before you can't carry the thing around on your average wheelbarrow.
Mr. A P Golightly
[Artifact Librarian - muggle section, MoM]
2007-07-25 19:09:30 · answer #2 · answered by cornflake#1 7 · 0⤊ 1⤋
I think he was dead, just not fully and completely, like how sometimes in real life a person's heart stops beating, but doctors can bring them back to life. I would guess Harry was somewhere around there. Still dead, but he comes back.
2007-07-25 18:33:30 · answer #3 · answered by pajaro 4 · 1⤊ 0⤋
The Deathly Hallows are Harry's invisibility cloak which has been passed down from generation to generation, a stone that brings back the dead which is hidden in the snitch Harry first caught in his mouth left to him by Dumbledore in his will and the elder wand hidden in Dumbledore's tomb, which is taken by Voldemort.
R.A.B. is actually Sirius' brother Regulus in spite from what Voldemort did to him. After he died in the cave he left the task to Kreacher to destroy the locket but Kreacher was unable to even open it.
The horcruxes are the locket stolen by Kreacher then by Mundugus then stolen by Umbridge then taken by Harry.Destroyed by Ron with the Gryfindor sword.
The Hufflepuff goblet hidden in Bellatrix Lestrange's vault in Gringotts. Destroyed by Hermoine with a Basilisk fang.
The Diadem of Ravenclaw hiddden in the room of requirement next to where Harry hid the Half-blood Prince potion book. Destroyed by Crabbe's cursed fire spell.
Nangini, Voldemort's snake. Destroyed by Neville with the Grryfindor sword.
And finally Harry's scar. Destroyed with Voldemort's killing curse.
Snape was actually working with Dumbledore the whole time, Dumbledore himslef planned his own death, the curse on his hand was growing more and more every day. Snape was truly repenting sending Voldemort after Harry's mom, he was in love with her, his patronus was even a doe, just like Lily Potter, Harry's mother.
Here's who really dies.
muggle studies teacher Burbage killed be Voldemort
Hedwig killed by a Death Eater
Mad-eye killed by a Death Eater
Tonk's father killed by Death Eaters
the minister of magic Scrimgeour killed by Voldemort and Death Eaters
Wormtail killed by his own silver hand
Dobby killed by Bellatrix LeStrange
Crabbe by his own 'cursed fire' spell
Fred killed by a Death Eater at the final battle at Hogwarts
Lupin (not specified, killed at the final battle)
Tonks (side by side with her husband Lupin)
Snape killed by Voldemort
Colin Crevey by Death Eaters at the final battle
Bellatrix Lestrange killed by Mrs. Weasley.
Harry dies/goes into dream state?? then revives/awakes
Voldemort killed by who else; Harry.
And about 50 students at Hogwarts names not specified.
Harry marries Ginny have 3 kids but also watches over his godson Teddy (Tonks/Lupins child)
Ron marries Hermione have 2 children.
Malfoy marries and has one child
2007-07-25 22:36:42 · answer #4 · answered by ~ ANGEL ~ 5 · 0⤊ 0⤋
No, I dont think he died. I think he was just in a passed out state.
2007-07-26 09:00:14 · answer #5 · answered by BluhBluh 7 · 1⤊ 0⤋
I say he never died and when he was talking to Dumbledore, he was simply unconscious.
2007-07-25 18:33:11 · answer #6 · answered by kristin 2 · 1⤊ 0⤋
I think he was in between too because Dumbledore told him it was happening in his head.
2007-07-25 18:37:46 · answer #7 · answered by Destiny 3 · 0⤊ 0⤋
Yeah, he definitely didn't die. Dumbledore even said he wasn't dead.
2007-07-25 18:33:38 · answer #8 · answered by MinaMay 4 · 0⤊ 0⤋
i see ur point techincally part of him died, the voldermort part..
2007-07-25 18:32:16 · answer #9 · answered by Way too many responsiblities :/ 5 · 0⤊ 0⤋
I agree with you.
2007-07-25 18:50:22 · answer #10 · answered by Pip 3 · 0⤊ 0⤋