do you think should minutemen be in prison for killing someone illegal or not?

Question

regardless they are illegal or not they are human beings and last time i checked killing someone was 50 to life or even deathrow

they is no self defense when an illegal is crossing somebody 50 yards away with a sniper rifle shots them in the head, dont use selfdefense as an escuse

95% of current minutemen carry a li rifle and stand far enough away to never come in contact with them, and you cannot group innocent illegals looking for a better life with drug dealers, and if america was in poverty and you had a better chance in mexico would you appreciate it if somebody was going to kill you soley because you wanted a better life

http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/7006708/
this is the first one that popped up, they arent as good as you think, 60 minutes special that i have yet to find, they kill dont kid you self, they are self-righteous racist

Answer 1

The biggest loudest argument against illegal immigrants is that the aliens violated the law.

By that same argument, anyone else who breaks the law should be equally accountable under the law.

Yes, anyone who commits murder (as defined by law) should be punished under the law.

Answer 2

since 911 america is all together different if these minutemen are deputized they wont serve a day as illegal aliens are enemys at a time when we have to tighten up the hatches its a shame because most mexicans are harmless people but terrorisim messed it up if we let our border open somebody from a hostile country could easily slip in from mexico

Answer 3

Should a mouse gain weight if he swallows a whole elephant? I'll worry about that when it happens.

I have never seen one scintilla of evidence that any minuteman has ever killed anyone. According to every documented account, the waves of violence and injury move in the opposite direction.

Though many illegals come for a life that is a bit better than what they left, it's unfair that we should shoulder that burden, particularly since our voters and elected officials have always fought birthright citizenship for aliens and have always won. Till Plyler v. Doe. But, then, that had nothing to do with voters or with any of our representatives.

Taxpayers are being "murdered" financially with every paycheck deduction - that is an incontrovertible reality. This unfounded allusion to mythical, hateful volunteers killing defenseless (hardly...) law-breakers is yet another flimsy attempt to make lucid people "accept" that the true is false and vice versa... that the earth is flat.

ie: It's a shoddy propaganda-campaign designed to make us disregard the obvious: that we (of every ethnicity) who shoulder the burdens of abiding by the law and paying the tax bill to enforce that law have been disembowled... and to accept - against all logic and fact - that to uphold law is somehow bad. They call it "racist", insensitive, greedy and other off-the-cuff names.

Four trillion dollars given in welfare and services that we (who pay for it) have NEVER received is slaughter enough.

Please apologize for the inference in your question. You have infinite chances to make it right.





qwerty

Answer 4

I think you seriously are reading the funny pages for your information. I, a legal resident, am indeed apart of the Minutemen. And I, in no way, carry any type of weapon. We monitor the border where the Border Patrol cannot (that is pretty much most of it) And yes, the illegal immigrants whatever origin they come from are humans, they are still ILLEGAL! Many of the illegal aliens that do cross have some sort of weapon on them. And after they trek through all the harsh terrain to get to the U.S. they sure as hell wont just run the other way if someone says......"turn around, and go back!" I have not heard of any illegal getting shot by anyone other than a Border Patrol agent. Don't even get me started on 2 agents in prison for shooting an illegal drug smuggler.

Answer 5

What have you been reading? Minutemen don't carry guns and they don't kill people. They report the illegals so that the authorities can detain and deport them. Killing a human being is not justifiable except in self-defense.

Answer 6

Where's the proof show us the site or is this more pro illegal liberal spin.Anyone killing anyone not in self defense. Can be charged with a crime.The minutemen do not kill they protect our borders at no cost to the USA there volunteers. with back ground checks.patriots & help illegals with water, food , first aid. So get your facts correct .

Answer 7

Prove they killed anyone, ever, and they will go to prison unless they can prove self defense. And that is the way it should be.

They don't kill people. I have no idea what you have been reading.

--
edit, do you have ANY proof that they have ever done that? I completely agree that anyone who did that belongs in jail. I have never seen ANY reputable paper or station report that Minutemen have ever done anything like that, however.

Answer 8

If it was murder yes, if it was self defense or defense of someone else no... its all the same legal system we all go by.

Answer 9

The Minutemen don't even carry guns! Where do you get these ideas? They don't condone violence of any kind. Look them up on the internet and see for yourselves.

Answer 10

Well first they need to kill someone, don't you agree?, why would you even think of charging someone with killing when they have not? If ever a minuteman kills someone they will come down on him/her like a ton of bricks, until then its a NON issue.