Who wrote the Quran?

Question

What is your conclusion based on this?

"Those who believe that Prophet Muhammad , was the author of the Quran are absolutely wrong. However, merely saying that they are incorrect is not enough, without providing proofs. If we contemplate the nature of this glorious book (the Quran) and the capabilities of the Prophet , we will realize that these claims are illogical and groundless.



First, Prophet Muhammad , was unlettered. How can an illiterate person come up with such a rich, intellectual, and inspiring text that gained acceptance not only in Arabia, but also throughout the world?



Prophet Mohammad , never went to school! No one taught him. He had no teacher of any kind in any specific subject. How could he acquire the knowledge of Science, astronomy, oceanography, etc. that is contained in the Quran?

(For example, the mention of ocean currents, stars, earth, moon, sun and their fixed paths in Chapter Ar-Rahmaan; and many other scientific statements that are found in the Quran, that cannot be stated in this short article)

http://www.islamweb.net/ver2/archive/article.php?lang=E&id=134499

Answer 1

Allah

Answer 2

The Quran is the unchanged understand Allah and that i trust a number of your factors which questions the Quran.... regardless of the undeniable fact that Muhammed became taught by making use of the Angels that got here to him on the mountain a thank you to study so in ordinary terms some clarifying there :) The Bible became not written by making use of God and that i agree it is an exceedingly unsupported, literal e book which could relatively be fake and that i think of it is as there i'd desire to write a e book asserting i'm able to preform in simple terms about all those miracles and Jesus is me on the earth.... yet there is 0% information of any of this.... not in ordinary terms like the Quran the place information can honestly be discovered as supported by making use of the large Bang as in the Quran it does state what technological know-how is now looking out... :) x

Answer 3

One of the proofs is that he would be physically overcome by the revelation, he would sweat and be overcome by it for a while.

Also the Quranic language in terms of tone is contact throughout the Quran, for 23 years. Any author changes his tone from time to time.

The Quran can be memorised with effort, if it was mans text can anyone memorise the Bible?

Also in terms of language, not a single word of the quran has been changed and all the grammar of Arabic is taken from the Arabic, if this was a book made up, how did he know all the grammar rules of Arabic without studying the rules and forms? When there was no Arabic grammar books written until many years after the Quran was revealed about 20-30 years later when the first texts appeared.

Answer 4

Isn't asking too many questions about Islam dangerous to your health?

I believe Islam is a false religion. If Allah is the one true God, why is his most sacred place a former pagan shrine? In Mohammad's time, the Kabah in Mecca was a pagan shrine for the moon god Hubal, the chief god of 360 gods who's idols occupied the place. Hubal was the god of fertility, the Arabic version of the semitic Baal. During muhammad's time Hubal was also known as Al ilah, "The god". The shorter version Allah was also in use. Muhammad elevated this god to monotheism, destroyed the idols of the other gods, and declared all other religions false.

Answer 5

We should know that Holy Quran is the word of Almighty Allah revealed to Prophet Muhammad (pbuh) and it is preserved through the hearts of men with knowledge. Holy Quran is memorized as it is in all times. Today there are millions of Muslim men and women for have memorized Holy Quran word by word. Suppose we throw away all the scriptures in the ocean including Quran, Holy Quran can be back again in few hours as it is. Without mistakes of a single letter. So at times of Prophet Muhammad (pbuh) there were thousands who memorized Holy Quran and could recite or write them.

Answer 6

Allah [swt] revealed the Quran to Muhammad [saw].

How can men write the Quran, the Quran was revealed 1400 years ago, men knew nothing about space, the universe, they didn't know anything about the Fi'rawn's body, they didn't know anything about the prediction that was going to happen today, There are million proofs that men that long ago couldn't write the Quran. The Qu'ran is the word of the Almighty God.

Answer 7

Has it occurred to anyone that believes he wrote it than ordinarily when someone writes a book that the ulterior motive is to gain power...then wouldnt they put themselves as much as possible in that book...as in the Quran should be practically an autobiography or something of our prophet..and yet he is mentioned in the book hardly at all. Other prophets are mentioned dozens of times...Moses is probably the most mentioned prophet in the Quran along with Abraham and Jesus...and yet wouldnt our prophet want his own name mentioned more in his own thought up religious book just to give himself more power and standing among those other prophets? just makes sense.

Regardless of whether you believe he was illiterate or not....the arabs were known for their poetry...it was the number 1 form of communication in those days...and yet the "poetry" in the Quran is unlike anything seen in Arabia at that time and up til now...nobody has ever been able to repeat that poetic style....and God says that nobody ever will.

Go ahead and try....we are waiting...

Answer 8

The Prophet Mohammad was schooled in a city of major trade, he picked up many philosophies and was a great thinker of his time. He had only a spoken message, like other religions the written-word came later.

Answer 9

Men wrote the Quran.

What Mohammed knew he learned from what came before including from the Christians and Jews.

Like when people continuely cut and paste other peoples thoughts. Almost as if they have no thoughts of their own.

The writers of the Quran also heavily plagiarized Greek scientists and philosophers.

Some Muslims like to go back and rewrite history and give Islam credit for things it does not deserve credit for.

Answer 10

Probably Muhammad. He was a crafty political leader. Most of the q'uran is cannibalized from the Hebrew Torah. If Muhammad didn't write it, he more than likely had one of his slaves do it for him. Or one of his nine year old wives.Thank you.
I noticed that you did not say " blessed be his name" after using the name Muhammad. So either you are a troll or you are not going to get all those virgins when you die. Thank you.

Answer 11

It is well known he dictated what he says Gabriel told him. whether or not he was illiterate is not really of importance to his authorship of the Qu'ran. They real fact you should research is what makes a man a prophet of God. If a man is not a prophet of God then his book itself is of no importance.
How will we recognize prophets of God? The first scriptures God gave to man instructs us of this a prophet can not anounce himself and with this warning If a prophet of God does not agree with the previous prophets and the word of God he can not be a prophet of God. Lets suppose for one moment Muhammad was a legitimate prophet of God and was receiving the word of God through Gabriel as he claimed how would those who were alive in Muhammad's day recognize this as truth? First they would see if Muhammad was in agreement with the existing word of God. Then see if he was in agreement with the words of the previous prophets immediately there would have been problems and inconsistencies the Qu'ran disagrees with the prophets and the word of God and Muhamamd was not announced as a prophet fo God only by his own word which would make him a false prophet and his book worthless.
Muhamamd was not accepted by the Jews nor the Chrsitians he was not in agreement with God and was only bearing witness of himself his book was not consistant with the word of God and was not in agreement with the prophets of God. This makes it impossible for Muhamamd to be a prophet of God or his book to be the word of God. Allah says he is the God of Abraham and could not be the same god. If Allah were the God of Abraham he would have forgotten his own rules and changed his teachings...It is very impossible. If Allah was real he would be schizoprenic...all of these things make it of little imprort who wrote the Qu'ran as it is clear Muhamamd is not a prophet and Alalh is not the God that was worshipped before Muhamamad the fact that he says he is the same God makes it even easier to dismiss.