English Deutsch Français Italiano Español Português 繁體中文 Bahasa Indonesia Tiếng Việt ภาษาไทย
All categories

I want to a talk a week ago, about the evolution, and i wanted to ask so many questions but couldn't.........so i want to ask those here who believe in this 'theory'
If you say that us humans, came from apes/monkeys.........who created those apes, or the spec of germ!!

where do they all come from, the sky? even so, who made the sky!!

2007-07-10 04:58:04 · 30 answers · asked by jasmine D 3 in Society & Culture Religion & Spirituality

BTW 'want' is 'went'!!

but if you get the point DON'T COMPLAIN!!

TOO MUCH PEOPLE COMPALIN ABOUT THE GRAMMER AND AVOID THE QUESTION!

2007-07-10 05:01:56 · update #1

THE BIG BANG THEORY CAN BE PROVEN!!!!

2007-07-10 05:05:19 · update #2

30 answers

and can i also add, if we came from monkeys, why are there still monkeys why are they not human?

2007-07-10 05:02:04 · answer #1 · answered by Jesuslovesmeyesiknow 4 · 4 16

>If you say that us humans, came from apes/monkeys...

To clarify: Humans did NOT evolve from modern apes or monkeys, we evolved from an ancestor which may have been something like modern apes or monkeys. Both us and other modern primates had a common ancestor, probably a few million years ago or thereabouts. This ancestral species evolved from other, earlier organisms.

>who created those apes

They evolved in turn from other organisms.

>or the spec of germ!!

The first life was very simple, and arose out of a mix of complex but nonliving molecules in the water of the early Earth. There are a number of theories as to how this happened, and we might never know the exact process.

>where do they all come from, the sky? even so, who made the sky!!

If you define a subject, try to stick to it. Evolution is about the development of living organisms in response to their environment. The sky is not a living organism, so evolution does not directly deal with it. That said, the Earth originally got its atmosphere (then made mostly of things like carbon dioxide, methane and some amount of nitrogen) as it was forming out of the debris that formed the Solar System. Some chemicals were in a gaseous state at the Earth's surface temperatures, so they became an atmosphere. This atmosphere may have looked sort of brown or purple, perhaps something like Mars' present atmosphere only thicker. When life forms came along a few hundred million years later, the photosynthesizing plants found the carbon dioxide to be a good source of carbon, and so in the process of getting the carbon dioxide and releasing oxygen they altered the atmosphere to something like its present form.

2007-07-10 05:07:27 · answer #2 · answered by Anonymous · 4 1

Yup that's something they can never answer. So basically there was nothing, then there was a BANG! then WOOOOOOOP oh look a little bacteria thing... and O LOOK ITS A MONKEY NOW! and then a human! O yes that makes so much sense. Yet the idea of being created by a God is so unbelievable all of a sudden. lol. Everything is created by something...except God because He is the one and only creator!

See that's what I don't get. The idea of being created is SO RIDICULOUS, yet BANG - out of nowhere universe is created, den BANG all these animals are created blah blah blah is soooooo believable and "scientifically valid" when...oh wait, it's a theory, not a proven fact. None of us were here when all this supposedly happens, so how can we believe all of that happened the way it did when it did...eh?

2007-07-10 12:32:52 · answer #3 · answered by Anonymous · 0 0

i think you misunderstand or where misinformed, the theory of evolution states that we naturally evolve over time though natural selection (similar to selecting to dogs to bred together for certain traits, exept done naturally) and as we are 50% our mother and50% our farther we don't stay 100% the same as its like take 50% water and 50% squash came from those things but its different, and these variations over time cause evolution.
disease kills of certian members of the population and other factors the successful get to mate and have genetically better offspring

with the monkey/ape thing, we are monkeys, how similar are you to a chimpanzee, really? or any of the great apes (thats still makes me chuckle) your about 99% genetically similar to one, and about 50% idenitcial to a grapefruit, honestly no joke its been done but then we know there are only 4 or 6 bases of DNA (i fail to remember) and going by that there can't be that many combinations to make it imposable

we don't think we came from chimps we say common ancestor, that meaning that we both came from the same thing which would have been a monkey but we are monkeys! that in mind we developed (as natural selection would make us) to our ways of living as it adapted the apes to the way they live, look at how well suited they are to their enviroment and us to ours

the big bang theory has supporting evidence such as it doesn't contrivine the first law of thermodynamics though e=mc2 comes into play and a large force must have been appied the the Mass that was already there so something existed before hand and the doppler effect but the steady state theory is also validated by the first law of thermodynmics a lot better, both remain a theory, two possable ways there is no absolute proof for either of them i have a degree in physics so take my word for that unless you have some new evidence that has come up in the last 24 hours i havn't heard of i'd be interested to hear

2007-07-10 05:09:17 · answer #4 · answered by Anonymous · 2 0

Working backwards
Humans (a variety of ape)
Primative (not modern) apes
Plesiadapiformes (early ancestor to the primates)
Cynodonts (early mammals)
Mammaliaformes (precursors to mammals)
Synapsids (a branch of reptiles that led to mammals)
Early amniotes (with a more complex egg than amphibians)
Early terrestrial tetrapods (four legged vertebrates)
Tetrapod lobe finned fish
Simple jawless fish
Primitive chordates
Primitive segmented deuterostome
Sponges
Colonial choanoflagellates
Protozoa (early animal like single cells)
Prokaryotes (simple cells)
Complex pre-life organic chemicals
Simple organic chemicals
Heavy elements (including carbon, formed in stars that went supernova)
Hydrogen and helium
A singularity that contained the mass energy of the universe.

I've skipped billions of steps, and gone back as far as current knowledge can go. Just because I don't know where the singularity came from, doesn't mean it had to be created. It may have always been there.

2007-07-10 06:08:46 · answer #5 · answered by novangelis 7 · 0 0

This is not the place for your questions. It is clear that there are many things you don't understand about the science of evolution.

First, study what "theory" means in scientific study. It doesn't mean "vague idea." In fact, the word "theory" doesn't mean "vague idea" in general usage. When the detective in a mystery novel says he has a theory, he means he has examined the evidence and formed and opinion based on the facts. A scientific theory is the same.

If you research evolution (there are any number of good biology texts in your local library that would help you), you would understand that the process of evolution doesn't require a "creator."

It is difficult to answer your question because there is so much you do not understand about biology and the origins of life. You clearly do not have an understanding of how planets, solar systems, or even the universe was formed.

So, your question can best be answered by you taking the time to learn something about science. No one can answer in detail the questions you have asked in a 1000 words or less.

2007-07-10 05:13:46 · answer #6 · answered by atheist 6 · 3 2

after the big bang [a bunch of random mass and flew together], all there was on the earth was bacteria, oxygen wasn't even around yet. and we didn't "come from apes and monkeys". there was a creature that was probably a cross between a human and a monkey, and eventually over thousands and millions of years it just evolved. No one created "those apes" or "the spec of germ". see that's the difference between creationism and evolutionism, no one created these things they just happened. and thanks to science this 'theory' has over whelming substantial evidence, where creationism has 0.



.

2007-07-10 05:02:05 · answer #7 · answered by lins 5 · 2 0

We have to start at the beginning. There's two camps of thinking about how life started. One is that there was a primordial soup, and with electricity it sparked life. From then on, mutations and evolution started to occur, so from single celled organisms came multi cellular organisms, then came things like the little zooplankton, then small fish, then big fish, then amphibians, then reptiles and mammals, and far down the line came us. There's another speculation that the bacteria was foreign, and came to earth from outerspace. This is relatively new, because they found that in space there are bacteria that are in a state of "hibernation" where they're almost dead, but are still barely alive, and can spring back to an active state when they come in touch with a habitual environment, that is if they survive the heat when they come in contact with our atmosphere.

The sky wasn't created, so the question of who made the sky isn't something I can answer

2007-07-10 05:01:49 · answer #8 · answered by Southpaw 7 · 6 1

Since I don't know how old you are, I won't hold it against you that you don't know anything about evolution. But I would hope that your school teaches biology and science and maybe that subject will come up soon. In the meantime, get a good book on evolution...or if you would prefer, look it up on the net. There are many sites that can explain it in user-friendly language. You need a basis in some form of biology to prepare yourself. When you see what scientist have to say, it might open your eyes to all kinds of wonderful things.

atheist

2007-07-10 05:09:01 · answer #9 · answered by AuroraDawn 7 · 4 1

It sounds to me that you've already decided on an answer. Personally I don't know what to believe, I guess it would be nice to think that everything exists for a reason and some big all powerful 'thing' made us, but that seems like wishful thinking.
In answer to your question though scientists reckon that we started off as bacteria which came from outer space either during the formation of the planet or externally via meteorites and then from there we evolved into more complex organisms. Whether that was the will of god or pure luck who can say?

2007-07-10 05:05:24 · answer #10 · answered by Anonymous · 2 2

we do not come from apes or monkeys. We all (humans, apes, monkeys) come from a common ancestor which existed several million years ago and evolved into several different species which continued to evolve, resulting in modern day humans, apes and mnonkeys. We are still evolving and in another million or so years will probably be very different to we are now.

2007-07-10 05:09:24 · answer #11 · answered by Catwhiskers 5 · 4 0

fedest.com, questions and answers