What about the children of Undocumented Immigrants?

Question

Lou Dobbs likes to talk about the war on the "middle class" and "the american people". He hides every racist and classist remark that comes out of his mouth behind both of these terms. Yet he doesnt think about the millions of AMERICAN PEOPLE born to undocumented immigrants. What about them? If you take away their parents jobs and starve them what will happen to these AMERICAN CITIZENS?? Does Lou DObbs think about this? NO. Because these dont "look" like American children after all. They are not blond or blue eyed. Amenesty for all immigrants.

Answer 1

how is wanting the law enforced racist?

Answer 2

Oh, I see. You mean we should worry about other illegal aliens before our own citizens? And those children aren't American citizens. They're illegal aliens because their parents didn't become citizens. So you can stop pulling the race card and say that anybody who is against illegal immigration is a racist. That's garbage and you know it! I'll give you reasons as to what harm the illegals are causing this great country. The illegals will never get their amnesty. It won't happen. The American people have too much power and people like you don't. So give up. And relax. Because the conservatives have taken back America! GOD BLESS AMERICA!
Here is the damage the illeglas are bringing upon this country:
1) Bankrupting hospitals and schools.
2) Making real and legal American citizens pay taxes for them.
3) Illegals don't pay taxes.
4) Illegals are bringing in third world diseases that have long been eradicated.
5) Illegals are turning this nation into a third world nation. Take a look at the streets in your city and you'll know what I mean.
6) Illegals are taking jobs form real and legal American citizens.
7) Illegals are causing more crime. 30% of our prison population consists of illegals. Illegals are creating more gangs.
8) Finally, they are ruining traditional American culture.

So if you still want amnesty than you need to wake up. And by the way, here's a news flash. The amnesty bill was defeated! So relax and give it up. The show is over for you amnesty supporters. GOD BLESS AMERCIA! Trust me, GOD is on America's side and won't let us go.

Answer 3

It is not our job to take care of other nations people, as for the children if they were born here they are entitled to citizenship under the 14th amendment... or at least the current interpretation of it. The parents are not covered by this, I personally think the 14th amendment needs to be looked at it practically begs women to risk life and limb to make it to the US in order to secure citizenship for the baby and all the benefits that come with that citizenship, its dangerous for the woman, its dangerous for the unborn child..

By the way Lou Dobbs' wife is not from this country, and how does America look?

Answer 4

I think a cap on welfare benefits would be a great idea for all states to follow. No increase in benefits after your first one. Free birth control is also a good idea,although any low income woman can get that at Planned Parenthood. I am disabled and receive SS. I have one child. When he was a minor I got dependent benefits for him. Dependent benefits do not go by how many children you have,it is a set amount depending on the parents check. I would have gotten the same amount of dependent benefits whether I just had him or 10 kids. The same should be done for welfare.

Answer 5

They can take their children with them. We need to change the 14th amendment as every EU country and Canada have gotten rid of automatic birthright citizenship and for the same reason. People use it to 'game' our immigration and benefits laws.

Their parents did this to them, just as anyone else who breaks the law is responsible for separation from their kids if they get sent to jail.

In this case, however, they can take the children with them.

This precedent has drawn way too many who knowingly use childbirth to try to get a claim to stay. We used to allow it, but the numbers are way too big and OUR children's schools and opportunities are failing.

Their children are not more important than our own.

http://www.tehachapinews.com/home/Blog/jimr/7671

Answer 6

The children of illegal immigrants are no different than the children of other criminals. If they cannot be cared for by their parents, they are taken away and given to the state to care for.

Illegal immigrants are criminals. They have shown complete disregard for the laws of our land by trying to bypass the legal way to become a citizen. If we given them amenesty... who's next? Drunk drivers? Thieves? Rapists? Murderers?

At what point do you say - Sure, you've broken the law - but you know what... we're just going to ignore that and welcome you with open arms.

It's absurd. It would only encourage MORE immigrants into illegally entering the US in hopes that they too could get amenesty.

People keep forgetting that these people are criminals. Most illegal immigrants are from Latin america and there are no real oppressive governments. They may have some problems.... but they're not being taken out and shot.

Answer 7

Nobody says that these kids have to stay in the US. Wouldn't loving parents take their children with them if they leave a country?

And, of course...the reason that most of the kids are American citizens is because their mother sneaked into this country illegally...went to a hospital which (because this is a decent country) would not refuse emergency medical treatment...birthed the kid (at American taxpayer expense) and then immediately started collecting welfare from the US taxpayers. All because the country that YOUR culture created is an abject, total failure.

(And Mexican hospitals do NOT accept emergencies if the patient can't pay....even Mexican citizens.)

Answer 8

That's part of the solution, no more instant citizenship just because you are born here. Especially if your parents are undocumented illegals.


This is how it starts and why you can't just give amnesty to 12 million illegals, because the "well what about their families" talk begins and then the bleeding hearts further bankrupt our country by guilt tripping everyone into taking in the who knows how many millions more people that the 12 million have in family in Mexico.

Answer 9

Children are innocent, until they begin to act like their criminal parents.

I believe the term you're looking for is ILLEGAL ALIEN CRIMINAL, and their children are "ANCHOR BABIES."

American citizens' children are not all blue-eyed towheads, so that argument is RACIST.

The parents were being irresponsible by fence-jumping just to give birth. In America, irresponsible parents are punished by jailtime and registering with the child abuse registries.

So, if we are to worry about the anchor babies, who's going to worry about the 2 million+ Truly American children who sit in foster homes each year?

I have no sympathy for criminals. You're barking up the wrong tree.

Answer 10

Oh, you mean the anchor babies? Too bad. Their parents broke the law. Why should their children be our responsibility? Tough luck. Life is unfair, isn't it? Throw them out, all of them!

By the way, Lou Dobbs is married to a Mexican-American.

Answer 11

what happens to the children whose parents were killed by illegals.? What of the parents who live with the pain of their child raped by criminal illegals? What of the hard working people that get "new" neighbors that frighten them so much they never leave the house after dark and can't move because the neighborhood has been destroyed? You are getting no sympathy from me, laws are laws. When you break them you deserve any punishment you get.