Who were the biggest Snubbed All-Star Pitchers and Hitters for AL and NL? (pick 1 of each)?

Question

Jeter is starting over Guillen for 1 thing, and both of them r going to the All-Star game so how the he11 r either of those 2 guys snubbed???????

Answer 1

AL - Cabrera

NL - Rollins

Answer 2

Well, hitters hands down it was Orlando Cabrera. He should be starting. He definitely should have been picked over Michael Young as a reserve. That's terrible!

It's stupid that every team has to be represented by a player. With this system there will always be snubs.

Like Ryan Howard in the NL. Definitely more deserving than Dmitri but since all teams must have at least one player, there ya go!

No pitcher snubs from me. That could take all day, but who would you kick off that's the question. I could not justify dumping anyone over anyone else.

Answer 3

I think it is hard to say. There really are not a lot of pitchers that are having spectacular seasons.

To tell the truth, and this is taking the easy way out, but I don't feel like anyone got snubbed. (at least not pitchers)

I really can't think of any pitchers in either league better than those going to the all-star game, or the 5 that we can still vote in.

If you want my snub, I think Gorzellany from Pittsburgh should have been the Pirates represenative and instead of voting on NL pitchers we should be voting on shortstops.

From the AL, I'm going to go with Matsuzaka. He is better than his 9-5 record would suggest, he just hasn't gone run support in April or June. Plus, he's a fan favorite in both US and Japan. Not saying he should definitly be in the game, but I think he should be in the final 5 instead of Neshek.

Answer 4

The MSNBC poll has Kevin Youkilis the most popular vote as snubbed player.

Answer 5

I think the overall biggest snub would have to be Jimmy Rollins.

Answer 6

Jeter starting instead of Guillen.

And no Brandon Webb.