Why does Allah not agree with the prophets of God that were before Muhammad?

Question

Allah says he is the God of Abraham. The God of Abraham taught a prophet must agree with all of the prophets of God.
Isaiah clearly taught the atonement before the Qu'ran. Why does the Qu'ran disagree with the word of God?

Thanks reportbot I did receive those messages...Yet the God of Abraham did teach that all prophets must be in agreement...apparently he didn't know the word was corrupt.

Murph Allah is not suposed to be a prophet but God himself!

Aishaw isn't that in disagrement with the god that existed before Muhammad? Isn't Allah suposed to be the God of Abraham?

Nunya...Allah teaches differen't than you.
Allah says the Bible is his word and it can't be changed...6:115...If the Qu'ran is the same god how is it they disagree?

Sunshine there is one Bible there are different translations....How many translations are there of the Qu'ran? Seriously,does this mean your book is corrupt?

Muhammad, Abraham was first mentioned by Moses. If you are following the religion of Abraham would you not be in agreement with the books of Moses? did Moses teach the tree of life? Why is this tree of life not in your Qu'ran?

Wanda, that is exactly what I want to hear...it is the only logical answer.

Flexin My point is Muhammad's book the Qu'ran is not ina greement wiht these prophets..If you read the books of Moses and the other prophets you will easily see that the Qu'ran is not in agrement with these prophets...though it says it agrees with them. If Allah is the god thatw as before Muhammad..He would agree with the word of God that was before Muhammad correct?

James Dean while I have my doubts about the fact you are a Jew...Let's consider your Torah... It is your claim that the trinity is a Christian lie.The first book of Moses tells us man is created in God's image...Correct? God said let US create man in OUR image...We see the creation of man that man is more than one part he is flesh and also given a spirit and these make up a living soul...God created man wiht more than one part but man is still ONE..and God is more than one part but is ONE God... Moses showed mans fall from God when man ate of the tree of knowledge of good and evil..What is the knowledge of good and evil? God's law...It shows man could not live up to the law and God said on this day you will surely die

There was another tree in the midst of the garden according to Moses was there not? Why is this tree not mentioned in Muhammad's book?
It shows God's plan of salvation...The tree of life...If they eat of this tree they will live forever...What could this tree possibly mean besides man's salvation?
What was this tree of life? If we fell for God's glory because of the law then we gain back eternal life ...How does this work? The tree of life is the lord and is Jesus Christ who paid the atonement for sinful man. It was God's plan of salvation from before the creation of the world. Now let's consider Abraham's sacrifice of Issac...I guess beings you are converting to Islam you believe that this story is wrong and refered to Ishmael???? but regardless the prophseyr emains the same...Abraham told his son the lord would provide himslef a lamb. Abraham named this place Jehova jireh...because this is where he said the lord would provide himself a lamb.

I hope your still with me because all of this is from YOUR first book of Moses we call Genesis, Now if Moses believed in the tree of life and Abraham believed in the atonement that was to come..How about the prophet Isaiah? Isaiah foretold of the coming of the Messiah the lamb of God who would atone for sin....Apparently now that youa re converting to Islam you surely must agree the Messiah is Jesus...hmm... You must agree the Jews missed this one... What did Jesus say about the prophesies of Isaiah? Jesus refered to Isaiah 53 as prophesy he must fufill.. How does one go from being a Jew to converting to Islam with no knowledge of Chrsit who came between the two?
John the Baptist introduced Christ saying "Behold the lamb of God"
Was Jesus the lamb of God that was foretold by the prophets of God? or is all the word of God corrupt untill Muhammad ...who could not be a prophet of God according to Moses who taught...

A prophet of God had to be in agreement with the prophets of God and had to be in agreement with Gods word. Is Muhammad according to the Word of God that existed prior to Muhammad a prophet of God? No and how does this make his book the word of God? It can not be. Teh word of God that existed before Muhammad says he is a false prophet.. Allah says he is the God of Abrham and author of the Bible is this possible when he does not agree wiht the God that existed before Muhammad? Is God schizophrenic?

Edit to Sunshine the prigian books of the Bible were not written in English but the English translations are many the same with the Qu'ran. Your point is that because we have more than one translation the Bible is corrupt? Then the Qu'ran must surely be corrupt also!

Answer 1

the simplest answer (not what you want to hear) is that it's because allah & God are not the same. I say this not to offend you, but in sincerety--if the Bible & the quran were both the word of God or God inspired, they would agree on all points. God is not schizophrenic, He would not give one Word to one group of people & a completely different Word to another group. If He did He would cease to be God.

EDIT: When I first read the question I mistook you for a muslim. I have since read your profile (& I apologize for my mistake).

Answer 2

The Quran presumes that the previous Scriptures existed in a pure form during Muhammad’s time
The Quran neither states that the Torah was corrupted before the time of Muhammad, nor does it contain any warning or prophecy that such a corruption would happen in the future. It assumes and endorses the authority of the Torah without any reservations.

Quranic Passages Substantiating the Presence and Worth of the Bible
If the Arabs doubt Muhammad's message, they are to appeal to the People of the Book. (6:20,21)

If Muhammad is in doubt, he is to appeal to the readers of previous Scriptures (10:95; 6:115), not to "the People of the Abrogated Scriptures" or "the People of the Corrupted Scriptures" or "the People of the Ascended Scriptures".


The Scriptures of the Jews and Christians are for all mankind. All are to believe in these Scriptures. (3:3,4,187; 2:136

Muhammad - the only witness to the Qur'an and by that merit of Islam - does not qualify biblically as a prophet, particularly since his message differs fundamentally from our Scripture which was revealed to many prophets over a period of 1400 years. There is no other acceptable evidenced reason by which Muhammad could be classified as trustworthy, above the biblical writers whom he contradicts.

If Muhammad was not a prophet of Jahweh Elohim, his book - the qur'an - is not the word of God.

Answer 3

First of all, I am a Jew who's about to convert to Islam. There is no such thing in the Torah that God will be incarnated in a human form and shall descend to this world in order to sacrifice Himself for the salvation of mankind. This is a big lie that many Christians propagate.

The trinity is a big lie and is nothing other than polytheism.

Allah (or Elau or Elohim) is the true God. The Koran is authentic and could not've been composed by man. I have studied the Koran well and what you are saying is nonesense. Isn't it enough that the Koran states that only good things and good actions are permitted while all bad things and actions are prohibited??? Where in the Bible did you read that??!

Listen people: The story of the salvation is like being angered of all dogs just because one dog disobeyed you. You keep on unforgiving all the dogs, till you tell your son to play with a dog who kills him! After your child is killed you forgive and love all dogs!

Muslims! Beware of this man. He is trying to deceive you. Hold firm to the Koran. Let your wits and hearts be your guides.

Answer 4

How about making sure of what you're saying first?

That'll be a good idea.

As for your question, Allah does approve of all the prophets, but the books that are out there now are corrupted. I mean seriously, how many versions of the bible are there?

You do the math.


Peace.

Edit: The Qur'an has different translations in other languages, in Arabic, it's only one book and is read in one language (standard Arabic).

Answer 5

The Quran IS the word of god, it is not been tainted or rewritten or written with an agenda in the first place. The bible is not trustworthy.

Just how many different versions of the bible are there?, huh? There are about 100 different versions of the bible out there. As we speak Germany is rewriting the bible to make it less anitsemetic. THAT IS CHANGING!!! There are gospels writtten by people who never even laid eyes on Jesus, some hated Jesus. Some gospels were completely left out!! The bibles as they are today all 100+ of them cannot be trusted. Jesus never was god or son and after so many rewrites today he is god. This is not the word of God. God clearly said there shall be no other gods but me. But today we stand with three clear gods. The guran is still one book, has not been rewritten, translations are not considered the quran, it is mans interpretation of Gods word. That doesnt count, it isnt good enough. Allah promised to protect the quran from what happened to the bible and he has.

The Bible is NOT trustworthy, it is corrupted.

Answer 6

Say ye, 'We believe in God and what has been revealed to us, and what was revealed to Abraham and Ishmael, and Isaac, and Jacob and his children, and what was given to Moses and Jesus, and what was given to all other Prophets from their Lord. We make no distinction between any of them; and to Him we submit ourselves.'

And who will turn away from the religion of Abraham but he who makes a fool of himself. Him did we choose in this world, and in the next he will surely be among the righteous.

And they say, 'Be ye Jews or Christians, then you will be rightly guided,' Say, 'Nay, but follow ye the religion of Abraham who was ever inclined to Allah; he was not of those who associated gods with God.'

Answer 7

Not sure what do you mean by the question, so this is my assumption of your question: You are asking why does Muslim doesn't believe in prophet before Muhammad?

If that is the question, I should say that, Muslim do acknowledge the prophet before Muhammad. We believe that they are the servant of God and the messenger.

But, we believe that the previous messengers are sent for a particular clan of people while Muhammad, the last messenger is sent for all people of the world.

Answer 8

We believe that we must be forgiven as well, just not through a priiest or the death of Jesus. We ask God for forvigeness, as well as anyone we have wronged.

AKA -- no middle man between us and God.

Answer 9

Does it? It sounds like you've made up your mind so why ask the question? From what I've been reading, Allah was perfectly sincere in what he taught, and did believe in the other prophets, he just believed he was the last prophet.

Answer 10

Because it is a false religion.