Are "illegal" immigrants to america what jews were to Nazi's?

Question

it seems like it.. recent government propaganda campaigns have triggered massive public hatred against them... Theres concentration camps all over the nation for holding them.. So far they haven't been getting gassed but that probably isn't very far off now.... They're even building a giant wall, didn't the soviets do that in east germany?

Answer 1

Not only were the Jews legally admitted to reside in Pre-Nazi Germany, they contributed to the economy by paying taxes.

Unfortunately, the Jews were too successful in business; the Nazis pointed out that many Jews still prospered during the Great Depression; which is how they were targeted as being the cause of the Depression.

Illegal immigrants in America are generally poorly-educated and working menial jobs.

No comparison, Franz.

Answer 2

The recent Government action has been to promote amnesty not hatred.
The differences between the Nazi-Jews and Americans-Illegals is a huge vast gulf. Only a race card playing idiot could make a comparison.
The Jews were already there, the illegals are invading. The Jews had what the Nazi's wanted, (control of the banking), The Americans have what the illegals want,(money and our jobs).The Jews were a race which was targeted for hatred because of what they had and wouldn't give loyalty to there country. The illegals cause law abiding immigrants of their own race to be targeted for hatred because they break the law and maintain loyalty to the country they ran from.
I think with the racist mind set, the problems caused, and the hatred being created, a better comparison would be to compare the illegals to the Nazis, and the Americans to the innocent Jews who were not allowed to defend themselves.

Answer 3

In a sick sort of way only backwards. Views of the people seem to be similar but the Jews didn't want to kill the Germans.......unlike now where too many are talking of killing the citizens here. Bushes grandfather or great grandfather helped fund Hitler and here Bush is pushing this agenda. Then it's the communist party helping fund the illegal immigrant movement......so it almost seems like they're doing the same thing only different.......in a very sick sort of way.

People don't want the illegals hurt....just sent back home. It's been the radicals of their movement talking of killing the whites or like with the middle-east, the Christians. Deportation is a far cry from genocide.

The wall in Germany was to keep Germans from leaving....not to keep the Jews out.

I don't know what propoganda you hear but I hear more propoganda trying to convince me this is a good thing. It's been the people who have come forth with various experiences who are saying it's not. The reality doesn't personally touch the government supporters. I don't think Cheney was left to sit for hours and waiting his turn in the local hospital. Most of their kids are going to private schools. They live in gated communities and locked up estates to where they don't worry if their kid is going to be shot while doing homework at their desk by a drive-by shooting. I don't think there's 35 people living next to Obama with music blaring till the wee hours of the morning and I doubt Mrs. Clinton has beer bottles flung in her front yard or having her yard used as a public rest room. They don't have Jose taking their job. Yet. They don't have the requirement for office of "must speak Spanish". (They have translators provided for them.) They probably have a very nice Juan and Rosa working for them and figure they're all like that. They are protected with a slew of people where they don't see the "other side" of this.

I'm not sure but maybe the Jews were more a threat to the upper-crust of Germany and took too drastic a move. Where here they aren't personally threatned yet......only the regular folk.

Answer 4

Did we skip our medication again today?

How dare you degrade the Jewish people that were victimized in Nazi Germany by likening them to criminals that are in this nation! There is NO (repeat NO) similarities between them.

The Jewish people in Nazi Germany were CITIZENS (LEGAL CITIZENS) that were ostricized by a sociopath and his warped perception of the world. And if you had any clue as to what the Nazi's REALLY did to their great nation, you would realize that the Jewish people were just the "tip of the iceberg". Basically, anyone that didn't fall into Hitler's ideal of the perfect human (or "dominant race") was murdered or forced into slavery - Blacks, Christians (anyone that didn't buy into him being a God was not allowed to live), children, women, old and young, mentally and physically disabled, gays, and so on. He felt that the only ones that were worth anything were his followers (the faithful ones) and the "dominant race". He turned women into breeding machines, and many children were born and never knew who their parents were or where they came from. They grew up only knowing that they were one of many children considered closer to being "perfect" in Hitler's eyes. Others were experimented on, tortured, raped, starved, and tossed asside like yesterday's garbage. And you have the BALLS to liken criminals to the travesties that these people went through?

The difference is the "illegal immigrants" brought all of this on themselves by violating our laws and not following our procedures. The victims of the Nazi's only crimes were being born. And last I checked, that really isn't a crime. But entering our country without going through INS is a crime.

Why don't you educate yourself on what in the hell you are talking about before you go shooting your ideals off in a chat site. It makes you look like an idiot when you don't.

Answer 5

Illegals are illegal and should be deported. It has nothing to do with the race of the illegal. Trying to detract from the facts by throwing the race card is a common tactic by the pro-illegals. So call me a Nazi or a racist it wont change the fact that I am against illegal immigration.

Answer 6

Yes, and we have to keep in mind that the Nazi culture is still very alive!

I hate that Nazi language too!

America is ready for the Nazi's whenever they arise if ever!

Those Nazi's took too many innocent life's and will ever be condemned to hell!

We will protect America from Foreign and Domestic terrorism and Nazism is one of them!

Answer 7

No and I hate these constant comparisons to Nazi Germany. The closest thing in the world to Nazi Germany is the genocide in Darfur, plain and simply.

Answer 8

no they are not , "but what part of get in line like everyone else" does the pro illegals not understand. as far as I'm concerned we just need to know who these people are and give allot more respect to those that come here legally(LIKE MY SWEDISH GRANDPARENTS DID) next time you go to the movies just walk in line ahead of everyone. you re not a bad person but why wait on line just go in , see what happens! no ticket screw them you deserve a break and a movie!

Answer 9

Hell no, the Nazis went in and did those jews BAD, the liberal Americans are willing to give the illegals clothes, welfare, shelter, food, and health care. No comparison at all if you ask me....

Answer 10

no, get real, the Jewish people were citizens of the counties that wanting to do them harm, illegals made a choice to cross our borders for their own reasons for good or bad.. When illegals break our laws why do you make those that want secure borders to be the bad guys