Why should the American tax payer have to pay to stop illegal immigration?

Question

I hear people talk about, Build a wall, Arm that wall, set up patrols, deport them all... etc.
We say this while at the same time poloticians and corporate america is saying,"Come to america we will give you free health care a job a place to live etc..."
THEY should take care of the bill!
Fine businesses corporations who employ them.
Fine apts and others who rent and sell to them.
Fine banks who give them accounts.
Fine credit card companies who give them cards.
Stop hospitals from giving them free health care.
A wall wont work, deportation wont work.
The only thing that will work is cutting off their supply of money.

rssr, I agree a wall would work, I am merely proposing that there may be a more economical way.

Answer 1

In a market driven economy the laws of supply and demand becomes the rules of any issue. Americans are misdirecting their anger towards the supply, which are the Mexicans coming over to fill a demand. The anger should be directed towards the DEMAND or the people, who are paying the Mexicans under the table below minimum wages or sweat shop wages. They're your sell outs, cashing in on the problem...without NO DEMAND then there is NO SUPPLY.

If you treat those Employers like Cocain Dealers...then they straighten up. Rich people fear Prison more than the Devil.

Answer 2

You are very close to the right idea. Deporting and walls are really only expensive band aids for the problem of illegal immigration. If corporations did not offer the work, the illegal aliens would not be coming. They are certainly not climbing fences and swimming rivers for the weather here. It is high time to stop blaming the immigrants for coming to a place that offers them good paying work.
There is no law against foreign nationals opening bank accounts or even getting credit from US banks. This is purely business. Americans have accounts in other countries too. The credit card, bank account, free health care stories are smoke and mirrors to hide the real problem. The problem is greedy employers that hire alien workers for less than they would pay US workers. Some of these hirings, as in the forest industry, are actually legal guest worker programs. As far as taxpayers paying the bill, that is what taxpayers do, pay the bills of the government.

Answer 3

We do not have leaders that will enforce our laws. That is the big problem President Shrub was selected by the powers that be to be our president because he promised them that he would cut taxes for the rich and allow millions of illegal aliens to pour into our country providing cheap labor for business. Bush will not enforce our immigration laws unless Congress forces him to.

The fence with Mexico is a good idea as it will keep out drug and human smugglers, reduce crime, and prevent terrorists from entering our country through Mexico. We should follow a policy of attrition through enforcement to deal with the illegal aliens who are in our country.

Answer 4

A wall will work, it worked for a good many years in Berlin, and would work here if patroled.
How come we are for the wall in Israel, yet against a wall to protect our borders.
If we can waste billions of dollars on these idiotic wars such as Iraq, we could sure afford to spend that money here to protect our borders.
Problem here is there's too damn many bleeding hearts in favor of these illegals, and the hundreds of parasitic politicians willing to give the country and jobs away to get votes, and to hell with the tax paying citizens that put them in office.

Answer 5

We have to pay to stop illegal immigration because it's cheaper than allowing them to stay here. Still, I like your idea of fining everybody who makes a travesty of US immigration law.

To do business only with companies that will not hire illegals, go to www.USPatriotCompanies.com .

Answer 6

Corporate America is saying "come to America to get free health care"???
NO WAY, Jose.
Corporate America won't even give Americans free health care.

The free health care is compliments of the American TAXPAYER who wants them to all go HOME to where they send their money, and STAY there!
/

Answer 7

That's why I say we find a way to stop sending American dollars out of the country for anything other than goods we buy from other nations.

Answer 8

The reason is because it would be less of a taxpayer drain if illegal immigrants were prevented from entering the country in the first place.

Answer 9

The problem with that, is that illegal immigrants are poor, and regardless of how much you fine them, they'd never manage to pay it anyway. If you want them out, but you're not willing to pay for it, you're out of luck.

Answer 10

And then watch in desperation as they all resort to crime in order to survive.

After all, they'd have no money to get back to Mexico.

How genius of you. Keep thinkin.

If a society's rules disregard the poor, so must those poor disregard society's rules. It's about survival. The answers aren't that simple.