israel should let the gaza fatah refugees a shalter in israel???

Question

i really dont know.... it's hard debate, couse after all a year ago they blow-up buses full with people , and now they need us...
i think that we should smile twoard's the one's who stand to kill you, if we denay their need of shalter we killing the chanse of peace,
now it's the time to show the greatness of israel forgivness...

soory for the bad spelling.. i'm late for work...(-:

please no haters just answers

Answer 1

Israel should give assistance to anyone who needs urgent medical attention in an Israeli hospital that cannot be given there.

Other than that, Israel should apply the same amount of security that it always have at the defacto border. Allowing people to come in carte blanche simpy because they are fighting amongst each other is highly risky. And if they did so, rest assured that someone will take advantage of it.

Also, you implication that if Israel does so then that furthers the chance of peace, I highly doubt that will happen. I have history to back me up on that one (see last 14 years).

Answer 2

There could be extra no negotiating with Hamas they're absoloutely commited to destroying Israel and it shows via the their movements. capturing Qassam rockets into Israel and all the hateful propaganda on the state run television. a minimum of Britain had a extra benign entity to barter with. Israel isn't so fortunate and that i say this no longer as a expert israel individual according to say yet i can work out mistake whilst its approximately to take place and im beneficial Israel has already known this aswell. Fatah is corrupt, Fatah is lazy. those are various the justifications Fatah have been given booted out interior the elections. To make genuine substitute they could step as much as the plate and shed off their previous faults and commenced anew. yet i doubt it; the comparable holds authentic of Fatah at present... yet you mustn't forget approximately that Fatah is an armed armed forces like Hamas. I undergo in recommendations listening to soemwhere that Fatah had grenade launchers and Hamas did no longer so as that replaced right into a suprise why Hamas gained the Gaza Strip. yet a number of my criticsm will make extra suitable to international places that neighbour Palestine and Israel. They turn a blind eye to the smugglign of weapons and rockets which in undemanding terms serve to wreck the palestinians the two way they use them. they do no longer likely care with reference to the Palestinians they only care approximately Palestine the peace of realistate. have you ever heard the addage that all of us cares abou Palestine yet no longer the Palestinians? For extra effects in the direction of peace i beleive that Fatah and Hamas no remember if that is managable could be disarmed and in undemanding terms the protection stress be armed with Ak47's and not some armed forces who's loyalties can substitute over night.

Answer 3

Firstly, to respond to WittyWeasel's comment: No, it's not because of that attitude that six million Jews, and millions of non Jews were slaughtered in Nazi Germany. They were murdered because the German people either stood by and let it happen, or actively joined in by joining the Nazi party. The Jews and non Jewish victims themselves had no means of fighting back and if you ever bother to consult a history book, you'll know that the Nazis dressed up the concentration camps to look like holiday camps so that even as the victims were being brought in, they had no idea anything was wrong. At some of the camps, specially selected cheerful, holiday-type music was even played, to lull the victims into a false sense of security.

Now to answer the actual question:

Fatah have been busy killing Israelis. But, they did at least agree to talks with Israel at one point, so they are perhaps ever so slightly preferable to Hamas, those murdering lunatics we're all watching running around with faces covered in masks while they kill and slaughter their own people.

Let's face it, Israel will be condemned whatever she does or doesn't do.

Answer 4

It is a hard debate when you think about it, but I have to say that they shouldn't allow them to seek refuge in an Israeli shelter.
The refugees shelter in Lebanon housed terrorists, and Israel doesn't need that to happen to them too. After all, Lebanon is over half Muslim and yet the terrorists still fight their army, I don't want to think about how bad it would be for Israel.
Of course Israel shouldnt snub these refugees though, they could send them aid packages by air or support a refugee camp that's somewhere else. In this way, they can help the innocent without putting their children in danger.

Answer 5

There are not Fatah refugees real Fatah are in Gaza waiting the right of Palestine to exist too.

Answer 6

if the refugees need medical attention, i think the israelis should help them
but these are people who don't like israel at all... maybe the syrians or egyptians should give them a place to stay.

Answer 7

These "refugees" are the terrorists of one side, who just the previous week were firing rockets at Israel.

They must not be taken in by Israel.

At the other side of Gaza is their border with Egypt, their fellow Arabs.

Will Egypt take them in?


.

Answer 8

I disagree. They may be fleeing for their lives, but that does not mean they respect Israel's right to exist. The enemy of my enemy is not always my friend after all. I would potentially agree to allow them transfer to the West Bank, but as a group they are still a danger to Israel proper and as such one cannot justify their refuge here.

Answer 9

The South Lebanese Army fought and died for Israel and they deserved far more respect and support than they got from the Israeli Government after they wothdrew from Lebanon.

The Fatah are terrorists who have spent, under the banner of the P.L.O., the past forty years slaughtering innocent Israeli civilians as well as murdering thousands of innocents in other countries.

Let the terrorists slaughter each other and, when the dust settles, we'll know how to deal with the survivors.

You say "we'll shatter the chance for peace" if Israel doesn't shelter the Fatah terrorists. That's obscenely funny considering that Ehud Barak was going to give them 98% of their demands * INCLUDING JERUSALEM * and the Fatah, led by Yasser Arafat, turned him down, starting another wave of violence and terror against Israeli civilians.

It's a mentality like yours that led six million Jews to go, on their knees, to the cattle cars...... think about that.

===============================================

*Note to gaminegirl: Yes, it was exactly that attitude that led to the six million deaths. As for "reading history", Here's some facts:

1.) Hitler published his "Mein Kampf" in 1924, 9 (NINE) years before he came to political power. He outlined, in great detail, each and every the moves he subsequently made so the Jews in Germany had NO excuse to say "Gosh, we didn't see that coming...!"
2.) The Jews and others had every opportunity to fight back, witness the Warsaw Ghetto Revolt that, with a few brave Jews, held back a German battalion for weeks. Other Jews just went quietly to the cattle cars. Some even AIDED the Nazis in identifying and arresting other Jews.
3.) Even with the flat-out honesty and transparency of "Mein Kampf", the Union of German Jews ENDORSED Hitler in his run for the Bundestag in 1936, 12 (TWELVE) years after it was published !

How many post-WWII Jews have read "Mein Kampf"? Have you? If not, then the fairy tale you seem to believe about the attitudes of pre-WWII Jewry will ensure a repeat of that horror.

Read "Mein Kampf" and then we'll talk about Ahmedinijad's little rants about Israel and we can compare them to Hitler's rants about the Jews.

I wouldn't be so quick to criticize someone else's knowledge of history until you've done some brushing up on it yourself.

I would suggest:

1.) "Mein Kampf" by Adolf Hitler
2.) "Adolf Hitler" by John Toland ( the best biography )
3.) "Rise and Fall of the Third Reich" by William Shirer
4.) "Inside the Third Reich" by Albert Speer

and, for a non-fantasy background on the Arab-Israeli wars,

1.) "From Time Immemorial" by Joan Peters

and, like "Mein Kampf", another essential book to read is:

1.) The "Quran" by Mohammad

The first iron-clad rule of warfare is,"Know your enemy."

Answer 10

Um...no. At the end of the day, the one thing all Palestinians agree on is that they want all Israelis dead. Should we help Fatah destroy Hamas? Absolutely.