God versus the Big Bang!!! Consider this!?

Question

Now I am not asking you to consider that God was behind it, that is a matter of faith, and for you personally to decide.

Consider this, what made the big bang, why did it happen, where did it come from? What was there before it?

If all matter and energy came from that one moment, where did it come from?!

My point is that if you believe in God or not, all astro physicists say that at the moment of the big bang, the laws of physics broke down. Research it if you want! It's in a Brief History of Time by Hawking.

Basically, any answer to the question i put forward would be as mystical as an answer saying that god did it. So believing in God isn't as irrational as you may think, as with the scientific knowledge we have today, you can't give a rational answer to the question.

Answer 1

I believe in the Big Bang. God said it, and BANG! It happened.

Answer 2

The Big Bang is only a Creation of the Universe theory which stemed out ot the Solution of Einstein's field equation.The solution involves a series of differential equations in the form of tensors using a matrix techniques. Its based on an imaginary geometry called manifold of space time.
Time is supposed to curve with the compression of space.And than space was to envelope a mass that is present. and by puting the curvature of the space envelope around the mass they curve time also.
However the Big Bang never explained how space curved the masses into atomic structures.
Its a Beautiful theory where we can enjoy playing games with ,for the people who know nothing about tensors analysis and the definition of energy ,let alone Understand it.
The Greater 90 % of the world population are ignorant about the theory and wouldnt actually care less about it.

The Concern about Creation is outlined in the Holy Bible which indicate that the Universe came into being because of our Creator.
No big bang theorist was there,Neither was Niels Bohr or Einstein for Quantum mechanics or String Theorists.

The sumation of the whole matter is that no one Understands how the Universe was Created. And most of all I was not there either to make positive identification of the process.

Answer 3

Point well taken. Either everything has always existed (in some form) with no beginning and no end, or everything popped into existence out of nothingness. Neither scenario really works within the framework of human logic, does it? Yet one of them must be true. But to buy into the god myth (actually, one of the many different competing god myths) to explain it all? When there's a complete lack of any legitimate evidence? No. The real answers will come from searching and learning. Not from the safe, easy intellectual laziness of religion.

Answer 4

The***PRAYNOGRAPHER***So what you are saying is that god created all out of chaos,not knowing what the outcome was going to be. Then later try make all believe that he knew exactly what he was doing. I think therefore I can't buy that. If there was never anyone that would question this god or no god thing. The world would still be flat, and men would still be dragging women around by the hair.If i was a god able to create, or design, and if I was as intelligent as you say, or think I was. I think I would of built a Cadillac, not a Volkswagen.

Answer 5

Did you also read in A Brief History of Time where Hawking said that these questions are as illogical as "what's above the highest point?"

You're asking about "cause" and "before." These terms only have meaning within time. When you ask them about the Big Bang, the moment time began, they make no sense.

Answer 6

umm i didnt get what the question was?
i dont know if there even is a god.
with all of the bad things going on in the world, i constantly wonder if there is a god, like, heaven and hell. why would god send people to hell for all eternity?
God is supposed to be forgiving and merciful? how can god allow people to suffer like that?
so yeah, i considered it, and i still cant come up with an answer, and perhaps i never will....


not on a related note, but Yay! Irish people are great!

Answer 7

I DON'T FEEL IT WAS GOD...THAT IS IF THERE IS A GOD........I FEEL THAT IT JUST HAPPENED.....THINGS HAPPEN W/O A REASON....

THAT'S LIKE BLAIMING GOD FOR THE WORLD ENDING....WHEN IT BECOMES A DWARF AND EXPLOADS........HOW ISTHAT HIS FAULT? IT WOULDN'T BE...
AND PLUS...GOD WORKED HARD TO GET WHERE HE IS TODAY...AND YES I WILL ADMIT THE LIFE ISN'T PEACHY QUEEN BUT IT IS GOOD FOR GOD TO HAVE DONE IT ALL ON HIS OWN..........
AND WHY WOULD HE WANT TO HURT THIS? WHY WOULD HE WANT TO RUIN THE BILLIONS OF BILLIONS OF YEARS HE WORKED........

IS IT BECAUSE HE SAID THAT THE WORLD WOULD COME TO AN END WHEN MAN KILLED MAN IN THE STREETS, OR IS IT BECAUSE HE IS DISSAPOINTED IN WHAT HE HAS CREATED..WHICH IS A CRUEL, BLUNT, UNCARING WORLD.............
YOU WERE RIGHT WHEN YOU SAID NO ANSWER TO YOU'R QUESTION WOULD BE RATIONAL.

Answer 8

It's not really god vs the big bang, it's god versus all the other religions gods, the big bang theory, all other scientific theories, and all other scientific theories that we will ever discover as well as any other explanation of how we got here.

Answer 9

What makes you think anyone with a speck of logic could believe in such a wild concept as a big bang in the first place. Why would God need such nonsense to create the world. What utter nonsense. Why don't you go play with your Barby's and let the adults talk.
Kisses BB

Answer 10

Christian version of God-irrational-yes.
Everything worthwhile comes from group participation, from trial and error, not individuals existing in perfection then creating with absolutely no motivation. That is one thing (motivation) a perfect individual would not have.

Answer 11

Sure, a 'god-force' might exist, no doubt, but just not in the religious sense- not in the christian, islamic, hindu, buddhist, etc., sense. the simple fact is that, as humans WITHIN CREATION, we can never really know. if you believe in god/jesus/mohammed/whatever, then you do, but there is NO FACT as to the nature of the creator of the entire universe. It is all hearsay. All religion is man-made. The ultimate truth is beyond us. death might or might not reveal it.