I have the solution to the illegal immigrant problem right here - what does everyone think about it?

Question

Face it, most of the illegal immigrants in the USA would make great American citizens if given the chance. They are generally nice, hard-working, family-oriented people.

What if we gave all the illegals amnesty, but we deported an equivalent number of American residents who don't deserve to live here?

We could start with the Liberals. In light of the war on terror, they've shown their true colors as the traitors that they are. They could be sent to Venezuela or Cuba, so they can see what their beloved Socialism really looks like (and live alongside their fellow America-haters.)

Next we could send all our criminals to war-torn Afghanistan. Instead of preying, and bringing suffering down upon their fellow human beings, they'd be forced to contribute to society.

Anyone who is able-bodied and on welfare would be given the opportunity to work. If they refuse, they'd be sent to Mexico to learn how.

So what's everyone think of my illustrious plan?

Skyhawk - any illegal alien criminals would be promptly pipelined to Afghanistan - **ding** - problem solved.

Hey deckape and Nostra-dummus, we are trying to have a serious discussion here. Quit screwing around.

Answer 1

If in fact they would make good law abiding citizens, boy are they starting out on the wrong foot. There are many in this country that are nationals that don't deserve to live here, that is true. But ignoring one class of people that burden our country in order to promote a political philosophy is not very patriotic in my opinion. Maybe you should give this a little more thought.

Answer 2

I wish those pompous pr@ts would stop going on about how lazy we Brits are, and that we have masses of this and that peoples doing the jobs that we don't want to do. Fact is many of the so-called jobs that we Brits don't want to do are actually done by White Brits and in poor conditions. Fact is more crime is committed by people who are living beyond the law than by people who living with-in the law. Fact is immigration is only a problem when to many people try to live in a country that is already overpopulated and struggling to house all of its people, and this dose not apply to every corner of the World. Fact is most Eastern European workers are not skilled construction workers, some are but most are not, I know that from my own experience. Fact is if you go back in time nearly all the people in any part of the World can be described as immigrants or invaders. Fact is most ethnic minorities don't want to mix with the native population, most want to recreate their homeland inside the UK. Fact is most of these immigrants are not welcome, it is only the politeness of the British people that make these people feel as though they are welcome. Fact is that this New Labour Government does not know what it is doing, if it did it would be trying to help the working conditions of the lowest paid, not making it worse by allowing more and more foreign cheap Labour into the country Fact is when people come to the shores of this country knowing that they are illegal they have no incentive to pay and contribute to society yet they still use the roads, still use public services, still have to policed, still have to be cared for when sick. Fact is Charity begins at home, for me and for them, and for also for a lot of people who live legally in the UK, who are struggling to make ends meet, to put food on their table, and a roof over their families head. Fact is there are times when you have to stand up and be counted, This country has a long and Honourable tradition of balanced argument and anybody who doesn't agree with that right should go and live as a immigrant in another country and leave us be, to manage our own affairs. But the final fact is that some people who live in and never want to leave their ivory tower and live in the real World like the rest of us, make general sweeping and inaccurate statements without really listening and taking into account what the vast majority of the British people are saying and doing all around them in toady's Britain.

Answer 3

Lacks credibility and demonstrates a blind devotion to an Anti-American agenda.

#1 3000 American CITIZENS are murdered every year by illegal aliens.
#2 4000 American CITIZENS are killed every year in auto accidents, where an ILLEGAL ALIEN is at fault.
#3 Fully 1/3 of Federal prisoners are ILLEGAL aliens that have committed serious crimes like murder, rape, etc. , in ADDITION to disregarding immigration laws.
#4 ILLEGAL ALIENS use OUR hospitals, and fail to pay 90% of the time.

So, saying that they are "generally nice and hard-working" is a lie.

How about we send them all back, with a person like you under each arm?


EDIT* Oh, o.k., good. SInce ALL Illegal aliens are criminals, according to OUR laws, they would be sent also, *ding* problem solved.

Answer 4

OK we will deport you first and problem solved, just plain stupid, by the way hard working is not a requirement to be a USA citizen and neither is generally nice & family-oriented people.

Edit
your plan is insane I sorry, I just think China would be a good place to deport you to, sorry

Answer 5

This isn't even a intelligent question. Untill the border is totally secure, I'm against any bill congress may try to pass. WHERE'S THE FENCE?

Answer 6

It would be boring without the liberals. At least with them here you can count on something stupid to be said on a daily basis. Your other idea of amnesty, I would never give it to someone who openly violated our laws to get here.

Answer 7

so, you want to deport 70% of the american population because they disagree with you personally - interesting.

also pretty childish.

how about you grow a set and then get back to us...

Answer 8

Immigration to America in the 17th to 19th century was by decent, hardworking, well intentioned people, heading to America with honorable intentions to build and contribute to society. They created a workable social system with benefits to the deserving and a society of well-intentioned and decent people. But no such people come any more.

Now they come in droves, packing the major cities, causing an increase in crime, congestion, and taxes as real estate rents soar, parking is unavailable or exorbitantly high. Americans who took their entire lives to pay off their home mortgages, now find that the taxes on their homes are so high, they cant afford to live in them any more and the congestion so bad, they cant even find a place to park in front of their own homes. Many have to pack up and move out of the city, just to make ends meet, and then face the arduous daily hours of driving back and forth just to get to work and back home. That is, those that still have jobs, since as this goes on, jobs disappear, either right here where we get laid off, or the whole company moves out to a cheap labor country. And as the hordes make demands for energy needs, power needed to heat and light homes and buildings is insufficient, and cities black out, the demand for gas soars, heating prices skyrocket, and our own supply of gas becomes insufficient to meet our own needs, and we become victims of the arabs, who use the pumps to revenge our policies they don’t like.

They pile over the borders or by plane on visitor visas, preying on the good naturedness of Americans to provide a refuge for the oppressed, they connive the appearance of the downtrodden and persecuted, and then sit down comfortably and stay here, leeching off the health care system which faces bankruptcy in 20 years, the welfare system that us sucker u.s. taxpayers have to pick up the tab for, and which we spent decades to build.

Social parasites from latin america, flock here to live free on us sucker taxpayers, dragging their families and relatives in, once they get green cards and then swamping the health care system with their third world illnesses and birth defects. And the other breed of latinos – criminals of the most evil intensities terrorizing communities in which they rob and kill.

Thieves and common criminals from the countries of eastern Europe and the soviet union, hearing that there is still stuff on store shelves when stores close, that hasn’t been shoplifted or sold, come and steal, with impunity.

Mafia organizations that control Russia and the countries of the former soviet union, setting up foreign crime systems that specialize in grand larceny, weaponry, even nuclear arms materials for sale, stolen from the old soviet system, available for sale to our enemies, raking them million$.

Africans with strange ,deadly diseases walk in, causing epidemics and death to our gay citizens and to innocent people in general and swamping the health care system.

Asians with alien religious philosophies, contrary to Christian monotheism, poisoning the minds of our youth. And they come and take our jobs away here in America, while employers, enticed by cheap labor, move their companies there, leaving us unemployed,.

Terrorists walk in and go about their death tactics with ease and we shudder at what they will do to us next.

All, contributing to crime, violence, social unrest.

Finally, To add insult to this injury, our government picks up the tab for hundreds of
thousands of third world “students” to come, pack our universities tuition free at the expense of us US taxpayers ,while we Americans fall into debt to pay for our own children to get a college education.

AND WE ARE EXPECTED TO PICK UP THE TAB WORLDWIDE
FOR THEM, WHENEVER S--T HAPPENS ANYWHERE.
What kind of fools are running this country?
What kind of fools are we to let this go on?

Answer 9

Absurd is the most polite term I can come up with.

Answer 10

Pure and simple, if you are illegally, LEAVE