Muslims, Is 4:157 in the Qu'ran correct?

Question

Allah says we were made to believe Christ was crucified... Did Allah make us believe this? I asked the question If Allah decieved us and it was deleted. Why can't I agree with the Qu'ran without Muslims deleting my question? Allah says they were made to believe this and it was not true therefore I assume Allah made people believe a lie...Is it wrong to quote Allah on this? What happened to the people from the time of Chrsit to the time of Muhammad 600 years who were made to believe a lie? Is it there fault if Allah made them believe Chruist was crucified? Couldnt he have sent someone wiht the truth a little sooner so that people didnt die believing a lie they were made to believe?

Thanks Julia, I'm not Catholic...not really interested.

Dolly is this not the verse in the Qu'ran is my version corrupt?

4:157. That they said (in boast), "We killed Christ Jesus the son of Mary, the Messenger of Allah.;- but they killed him not, nor crucified him, but so it was made to appear to them, and those who differ therein are full of doubts, with no (certain) knowledge, but only conjecture to follow, for of a surety they killed him not:-
If Allah put his likeness on another man is the not deception?
If It wasnt Allah's deception who deceived them to believe that Christ was killed?

Were they not deceived? If they were decieved did Allah allow this lie to continue 600 years? if they were not deceived then Christ was crucified.

hujan my question was deleted..can you imagine who would be offended by me asking if Allah decieved people?
157 says theyw ere made to believe...Who made them believe Christ was killed?

mr. You say it was made to appear...who made it appear this way?

Ismaeil It was made to appear..who made it appear that way...Allah says clearly it was made to appear that Chrsit was crucified...who made it appear this way?

Why did it take Allah 600 years to fix this deceit? didnt people who believed die believing a lie?

Dolly according to the Qu'ran Allah decieved people to believe chrsit was killed...chrsitians know God does not deceive, trick or mislead people..therefore the Allah of Islam is not the God that was before Muhammad...It then is obvious that Moses, Isaiah and Jesus were correct Christ did atone for sin on the cross.

pretty girl you think Allah decieved people and they were decived their whole lives by Allah and then he judges them for believing a lie that he made?
The true God does not deceive,
Satan is the liar..the truth is Christ was prophesied by Moses and Abraham and Isaiah and Jesus did fufill these prophsies by paying the penalty of sin for all of us who accept his atonement.

Muhammad the Allah of Islam tells lies..not the true God if Abraham. It can not be a lie that dioes good when many were lead to believe in the atonement Allah denies...Allah deliberately led many to believe in the atoanment then Allah says those who believe in the deity of Christ will be punished..He led them astray and then punishes them ...600 years no one had the Qu'ran but only had the crucifiction...What happens to these that Allah mislead?

Muhammad not all Muslims believe what you believe...check my questions and see not all Muslims agree on anything but that Jesus is not the Son of God.

Answer 1

Did not joseph blame his brothers of stealing something they did not, God does as he pleases. Look at it as a white lie, it's a lie that the end result is Good, maks a big diffrence between the 2.

Edit: Not all christians believe what you believe.

Answer 2

That they said (in boast) "We killed Christ Jesus the son of Mary the Apostle of Allah"; but they killed him not nor crucified him but so it was made to appear to them and those who differ therein are full of doubts with no (certain) knowledge but only conjecture to follow for of a surety they killed him not. (Holy Quran:4:157).

It was not Jesus Christ (pbuh) but some one else. Early Christians also belived the same. Who crucified Jesus..Those who knew Him? No, The Romans, Many had the similar looks, so they were in confusion. Bible verses says everything 'According to'..'according to'. if you read it is full of doubts and questions.
Holy Quran was revealed for mankind, it also clears the doubts regarding Jesus Christ, as his birth was a mystery, his end to this world was also a mystery. Holy Quran brings the truth on Jesus Christ (pbuh) and corrects the ways of Christianity on which they followed against teaching of Christ (pbuh). Like Trinity, which never comes in Bible or early Christians never belived in it. Nor any Biblical Propehts knew what this wrod is. Truth before God is one and Universal. That is to worship none but Him. That was the message of all the His Prophets. One Truth-One Message.
Let's all follow the truth. Worship your and my Lord. Who is One and Only.

CRUCIFIXION OR CRUCI-FICTION http://www.jamaat.net/crux/Crux1-5.html

Answer 3

Please, take my words right & understand what i am gonna tell u.

The verse ur talking about says :
" That they said (in boast), "We killed Christ Jesus the son of Mary, the Messenger of Allah.;- but they killed him not, nor crucified him, but so it was made to appear to them, and those who differ therein are full of doubts, with no (certain) knowledge, but only conjecture to follow, for of a surety they killed him not "

Allah didn't make u believe that Jesus (PBUH) was crucified because Jesus (PBUH) - according to the verse - wasn't crucified at all

BUT all of u christians think that he was crucified.
According to the Qur'an, Jesus wasn't crucified BUT the one who was crucified was somebody ELSE - BUT people THOUGHT that he was Jesus (PBUH) - thats what was said in the sentence " it was made to appear to them "

I hope u got what i was telling u above

Answer 4

God didn't want people believe in a lie, that is why God sent Muhammad.

What do you know about history of Islam?

Did you ever heard name of Imam Ali, secend leader of Muslims after Muhammad.

Listen to me, the real story of Christ is like this, people wanted kill him so God hide him and made another man who wanted kill Christ look like him so people in mistake take that man instead of Christ and kill him.

There are always some one who want change the turth.
Even now in Islam we getting different sects and have different opinions.

God sent many leaders, but people killed all of them.
God sent 12 leaders after Muhammad , we Shiet Muslims call them Imam. No one chose them as leader other than God.
People killed all of them but the last one, Baghiatollah is still live. People wanted kill him too, but God save his life just like Christ and hide him from people.

Actualy we can consider ourselves as lost nations, because we don't have any leader from the sky to help us.
In the near of end of the world, when earth getting full of blood and crimes God will send Last savior ( Baghiatollah ) with Christ to save us.

There are a man who have specail sceince( its name is Afagh) he told us, The last savior and Christ will come in very near future.
He also predice many wars and disasters befor they come.

Yes, Some people died and they believed in a lie, but those was not their mistake, and God will show them the truth.
Those who don't try to seek the truth or change the truth will have problem with God in the day of the judgment.

Answer 5

hey.....it is Mentioned in Quran that when the people wanted to kill Esa Alahe Salam (Christ) but from Allah's edict , he was taken into skies and he shall return but not as a Prophet but as a normal human being....
read this...
...They(people) said, “We killed the Messiah Jesus, son of Mary, the messenger of God." They did not kill him, nor did they crucify him, but the likeness of him was put on another man (and they killed that man)... (Qur'an, 4:157)

they killed some1 else instead of Esa (Aleh Salam).........

i dont know where u got that from.....

hope this helps....

Answer 6

I M (Muslim).. now the way i read your question.. is you are accusing (Muslim) for your question being delete.. do you have any prove to said that? so you judge thing by without knowing it! Al`Quran is the word from Allah.. it Never lie.. reads more & learn more.. don`t compair 1st after you know it all..

Answer 7

dont confuse religious people with logic it makes their heads hurt