If The Virgin Mary was born without Original Sin....?

Question

Is She was born without Original Sin, then why did she have to go through the "pains of child birth"?

Because the "pain of child birth" was one of our punishments of Original Sin for Adam and Eve having eaten the forbidden fruit.

But Mary was born without Original Sin so why did she have to suffer?

Answer 1

Mary was not born without original sin. She was human just like all of us. She was chosen by God to be the mother of the messiah. Where does it say she was born without original sin?

Answer 2

The Virgin Mary was the Immaculate Conception(and can be proven thru scriptue). She was born without the stain of original sin. But that does not mean she did not go thru birthing pains. The punishment of Eve had already be cast. Just as when we baptize a baby, we baptize to wash away the stain of original sin. With Mary she was FULL of GRACE, that means she was born without the original sin.

Answer 3

Mary was born normally. According to Christian teachings she GAVE BIRTH without 'original sin' (without having sex). It is only the Christian new testament that says she was a virgin and the Catholic Church's translation of the Old Testament that says, "The Messiah will be born of a virgin"
If you ask a Jew to read the original text, as it was/is written in the TORAH, then the saying reads, "The messiah will be born of a young woman" (nothing about the young woman being a virgin). The Hebrew word for Virgin is very close to that of 'Young Woman', and is an accidental mistranslation.

You need to learn to write correct English, and you also need to learn more about Christianity, including Judaism.

Answer 4

She wasn't born without Original Sin, she was forgiven of it when she agreed to carry Jesus. She was the first one to recieve God's grace (the theif on the cross with Jesus is the 2nd) and the only one to recieve that forgiveness before his death (or birth for that matter).

P.S. She was a Virgin, as an unmarriaged young lady, naturally she had not had sex yet. So the word for Virgin and Young lady are the same word. Harlot is a different word.

Answer 5

Why was Mary in The Magnificat speaking something of a Savior. Why would she need a Savior ? To save her from what ? I believe in God's Word. lets look at Hebrew 10:5 wherefore when he cometh into the world, he saith, Sacrifice and Offering thou wouldest not,but a body hast thou prepared me. No new life was created in Mary's womb . God exist from ALL ETERNITY. Here is His eternal existence, when He said For i came down from heaven, not to do mine own will, but the will of him that sent me. john 6;38. jesus also said Before Abraham was, I AM. John 8 ;58 LASTLY john 17;5 And now O Father, glorify thou me with thin own self with the glory which I had with thee before the world was.i believe. Matthew 11 ;11 jesus disassociates Himself from the normal birth process by stating that there is none greater than JOHN THE BAPTIST of those born of women. How come Jesus never refered to MARY as His mother but always called her WOMAN. The first Adam (the 1st created person) had no mother . the last Adam{the lord jesus in the flesh} had no mother. Lastly Isa.9;6 , For unto us , a child is born,,unto us a son is given and His name shall be called Wonderful, Counselor, The Mighty God, The Everlasting Father, The Prince of Peace

Answer 6

Who said that Mary was born without original sin? I've never heard anyone say that before. She was an ordinary jewish girl, born in the ordinary manner, who God chose to honor. And she was only a virgin until Jesus was born. Jesus had younger siblings who were all born with original sin as well.

Answer 7

Who said she did. It just says he was born in the normal way which means he was born from the normal birth passage. Now for those who say this is proof she was not a Virgin after that, do you not think that if Jesus could go through locked doors like in the upper room he could not go through a small membrane like the hymen without disturbing it?

Why is it you guys feel that the Lord God would put his son in a dirty sinful vessel? You need understanding.

Wow, look at how bad you guys have gone astray, one even says Jesus was born with Original Sin. Geesh!

Answer 8

Mary was not born without original sin, she was young lady, like any other, God found favor in Mary and chose her as the vessel for which Jesus was to be born into this world.

Answer 9

Mary being born without original sin is an immaculate misconception.

Answer 10

Where do you find that Mary wasn't a sinner?

When she went to visit her cousin Elizabeth (se the story in the book of Luke) she sings a song called the Magnificat. In it she declares that God is her Savior...why would she call God her Savior if she was without sin?

And if she was without sin, who within her parents was without sin? And who of their parents... and so on, and so on.
The point is, if this was the case, then there would have to be an entire family line throughout history to be without sin, and if we trace this back to the beginning, who between Adam & Eve was sinless? We know that they BOTH sinned.

So the doctrine of Immaculate Conception is unbiblical and should be cast aside, as anything being taught as dogma that cannot be found in Scripture should.

Answer 11

Mary was not born without original sin. There is no scriptural support for this myth. If she were that would make her God. Even the Holy Roman Catholic church knows they can not support this statement. They mumble something about proof in the "Gospel of James" which is a spurious book. They will call this book "scripture" until you call them on it. They know they are wrong.