Why do we celebrate Thanksgiving day as though the Indians gave us the land as a gift?

Question

Why do we celebrate Thanksgiving day as though the Indians gave us the land as a gift?

Answer 1

you need to read history. Thanksgiving is not about the land. the Indians show us how to make thought the long winter and how to plant our seeds. how to hunt and stay alive. so we could cheat the Indians out of there land and kill off as many as we could before taking there life away from them by putting them on the reservations. but know the facts first OK

Answer 2

That's not the intent of Thanksgiving day. They didn't give us land, the settlers then took it, not right, but they did. The reason the holiday was formed was for the food and kind of friendship the Indians offered at that time. They were thankful to be alive, be healthy, etc. If the Indians had know what our ancestors were going to do to them, I doubt it would have been so peaceful.

Answer 3

That's not the reason we celebrate Thanksgiving.
The first winter for the Pilgrims was very harsh. The land was unforgiving, and the Pilgrims would probably not have survived if it was not for the kindness and compassion of the Native Americans living nearby. Surviving the winter allowed the Pilgrims to plant seed and in the fall reap an abundant harvest. The celebration commemorates that, not the land later given/purchased from the Native Americans.

Answer 4

Did not know that was why we celebrate Thanksgiving. Thought it was for the good harvest and the indians were invited like guest to dine with the workers.

Answer 5

in accordance to the BIA i'm a million/2 to 3/4's a mix of Cherokee, Yuchi and Hitchiti speaking Creek and no one stole something from my predecessors. count of reality some are nevertheless residing on the land that became into theirs whilst it became into defined as Indian Territory. some, plenty, weren't dealt with so nicely nor have been some whites no longer dealt with so nicely yet there are multiple people like me who've names from different communities as did lots of the Indians from until now. meaning that there became right into an excellent type of interaction going on. it form of feels that folk did and do assimilate yet whilst governments get in contact then issues start up. which contain with this cutting-edge push via liberals to regulate each element of our lives. i'm no longer able to declare that i do unlike all particular team because of the fact of previous atrocities . it is often suited to make judgments on somebody foundation. via the way Thanksgiving became into made available via a team of Indians who observed a team of white people ravenous. it incredibly is been a prepare ever because for stable reason. I had turkey and the conventional issues that flatter Thanksgiving, i did no longer spend time thinking approximately became into it appropriate whilst i be attentive to it incredibly is a competent concern. WADO

Answer 6

Thanksgiving is a day of celebration of a good year, and a successful harvest.

Answer 7

we just celebrate it dude