What are your thoughts on the Bible getting more "realistic" after Moses' death?

Question

You know I was thinking. If Moses was the last Isrealite involved in the exodus from Egypt, wouldn't that give him a free pass to re-write history however he wished. His stories tell of magic, and truly improbable scenarios. After his death things get a little more believable. Most of the stories after fit pretty good within the guidelines of our current view of reality.

"If you read your Bible, you will find that Moses was not the Israelite left from the Exodus. There were two others still alive (Joshua and Caleb). Joshua would live another 30 years. Plus it was only those over the age of 30 who had left Egypt who died. 30 for the Jews was the age of "adulthood", the way that 18 is in our culture (21 in some countries/states).

So there were still many many people who had come out of Egypt and witnessed the miracles in the 40 years in the wilderness. Everyone between the ages of 69 and 41.

And even those under 40 would still have witnessed the manna and quails on a daily basis, the cloud of God, and other miracles."

All fair enough, but doesn't change the main question.

Answer 1

realistic? hmm... i'll take whatever it is your smoking!

Answer 2

If you read your Bible, you will find that Moses was not the Israelite left from the Exodus. There were two others still alive (Joshua and Caleb). Joshua would live another 30 years. Plus it was only those over the age of 30 who had left Egypt who died. 30 for the Jews was the age of "adulthood", the way that 18 is in our culture (21 in some countries/states).

So there were still many many people who had come out of Egypt and witnessed the miracles in the 40 years in the wilderness. Everyone between the ages of 69 and 41.

And even those under 40 would still have witnessed the manna and quails on a daily basis, the cloud of God, and other miracles.

Answer 3

the classic Jewish view is that G-d gave the Torah to Moses and Moses only copied it down. yet of direction, we ought to constantly submit to in ideas that Moses had lived for some years in Egypt, and had benefited from the state-of-the-artwork way of existence he experienced there. So some Jews, who do no longer have faith that the Torah is particularly the word of G-d, rather think of Moses became into certainly the 'actual' author. That pronounced, it form of feels particularly logical to end that Moses did no longer write each and all the Torah; there are 2 or 3 distinctive writing varieties and 'voices'. One evaluate many circumstances raised as 'data' that Moses became into no longer the author is that interior the Torah the loss of life of Moses is pronounced, and additionally activities that befell AFTER he died. non secular Jews will counter this via asserting that as Moses became right into a great prophet, he ought to foresee activities interior the destiny. yet in factor of fact: we do exactly no longer know! my own very own view: Moses DID write some, even multiple the Torah. He became into the main knowledgeable and the main intellectually state-of-the-artwork one there. yet another key factor: if the Torah became into no longer given via G-d to Moses, how did the huge accumulating of Israelites all hear the voice of G-d? This national revelation is a key 'experience' in Jewish historic previous. Sorry it relatively is not any longer a definitive answer. The Torah could be study and understood on many distinctive levels; certainly, Jewish classic thought says that 'each and everything' could be discovered interior the Torah. So possibly the answer to it relatively is in there - IF we in basic terms know the place and the thank you to look for it :) wish that enables somewhat to handle your placed up :)

Answer 4

The Books of Moses (Torah) were not written by Moses or anyone even remotely associated. They were oral traditions (at least four or five different ones) until they were later redacted into a single narrative.

The post-Moses books had different origins, less in oral tradition and more in supporting the current government, so they were bound to be less mythological.

Answer 5

THe bible is not a historical account. It is just a story. So, I would not classify any of it as being realistic.

Answer 6

What he wrote before his death came from the Ancient Egyptians.

Answer 7

I agree..one minute god is walking and talking to participants and the next he's speaking through prophets.

Answer 8

I think realism and the bible are mutually exclusive, just like realism and Grimm's fairy tales.

Answer 9

"Realistic"
Not before and not after