Rate These Boxers?

Question

joe louis rocky marciano george foreman prime mike tyson jack johnson lennox lewis sonny liston ali

rate these boxers on: power
speed
agility
stamina
chin
body
heart
cuts
rate all of them out of 100

for example ali
power 80
speed 70
agility 60
etc

Answer 1

Joe Louis: speed 90, agility 80, stamina 95, chin 90, body 90, heart 95, cuts 95 Total = 92.5

Rocky Marciano: Power 96, Speed 85, agility 80, stamina 100, chin 90, body 80, heart 100, cuts 80, Total = 90

George Forman: Power 100, speed 75, agility 75, stamina 95, chin 85, body 95, heart 95, cuts 90, total = 90

Mike Tyson: Power 90, speed 90, agility 75, stamina 60, chin 65, body 85, heart 25, cuts 65, Total = 65

Jack Johnson: Power 95, speed 95, agility 98, stamina 95, chin 95, body 93, heart 100, cuts 90, Total = 95

Lennox Lewis: Power 90, speed 95, agility 85, stamina 90, chin 70, body 90, heart 80, cuts 90, Total = 85

Sonny Liston: Power 99, speed 80, agility 75, stamina 75, chin 80, body 99, heart 85, cuts 85, Total = 88.5

Muhammed Ali: Power 85, speed 100, agility 100, stamina 100, chin 95, body 85, heart 100, cuts 90 Total = 96

Great question, thanks for the memories.

Answer 2

I have changed "agility" to "quickness" and "body" to "defense" because I'm not really sure what the original words mean.

Louis Marciano Foreman Tyson Johnson
Power 100 100 90 100 80
Speed 75 85 80 85 80
Quickness 85 85 80 95 95
Stamina 85 100 70 70 100 Chin 90 90 90 90 85
Defense 90 80 85 95 95
Heart 95 100 95 90 95
Cuts 95 90 95 85 95
Total 715 730 685 710 730

Lewis Liston Ali
Power 90 100 80
Speed 80 75 100
Quickness 85 85 100
Stamina 90 90 100
Chin 80 100 100
Defense 90 95 95
Heart 95 95 100
Cuts 100 100 100

Totals 700 740 775

My ratings are based largely on one question: How did this fighter compare to the other top fighters of his time? I looked at these guys in their primes, not at the tail end of their careers, so I am really looking at comparative dominance among their peers. So I did not try to compare Joe Louis to Rocky Marciano or any of the other fighters listed and try to figure out who would have beaten whom.

If anyone wants to argue about my ratings, e-mail me. :)

Answer 3

Joe Louis - power: 96 speed: 65 agility: 60 stamina: 85 chin: 75 body: 80 heart: 95 cuts: 95.

Rocky Marciano - power: 98 speed: 55 agility: 57 stamina: 99 chin: 90 body: 80 heart: 100 cuts: 38.

George Foreman - power: 100 speed: 57 agility: 56 stamina: 65 chin: 92 body: 89 heart: 84 cuts: 86

Mike Tyson - power: 98 speed: 72 agility: 65 stamina: 66 chin: 74 body: 81 heart: 62 cuts: 88.

Jack Johnson - power:76 speed: 85 agility: 84 stamina: 97 chin: 91 body: 90 heart: 98 cuts: 90 (hard to guage different syle of fighting during the early 20th century).

Lennox Lewis - power: 88 speed: 70 agility: 70 stamina: 85 chin: 75 body: 81 heart: 84 cuts: 88.

Sonny Liston - power: 99 speed: 69 agility: 65 stamina: 70
chin: 87 body: 87 heart: 64 cuts: 71.

Muhammad Ali - power: 71 speed: 99 agility: 100 stamina: 100 chin: 100 body: 96 heart: 100 cuts: 96.

Answer 4

1. Louis - power 90, speed 85, agility 80, stamina 90, chin 90, body 85, heart 95, cuts 100

2. Marciano - power 95, speed 60, agility 65, stamina 100, chin 95, body 90, heart 100, cuts 55

3. Johnson - power 90, speed 80, agility 85, stamina 75, chin 80, body 85, heart 75, cuts 95

4. Foreman - power 100, speed 60, agility 70, stamina 75, chin 85, body 90 (prime), heart 85, cuts 100

5. Lewis - power 85, speed 80, agility 85, stamina 85, chin 85, body 90, heart 80, cuts 95

6. Liston - power 100, speed 90, agility 80, stamina 70, chin 80, body 85, heart 65, cuts 85

7. Tyson - power 100, speed 95, agility 90, stamina 75, chin 85, body 95, heart 60, cuts 85

Answer 5

I think that bundini did an all around great job, but I would give Marciano 10 better on speed and maybe 5 or 10 better on cuts (that's just because I wouldn't rate any of these fighters below a 60 in any one category). Also, Lewis's stats seem a bit high overall.

By the way, you guys play Fight Night R3 too much. :)

Answer 6

1. joe louis (prime) 2. mike tyson (prime) 3. rocky marciano (prime) 4. lennox lewis (prime) 5. sonny liston (prime) 6. jack johnson (prime) 7. george foreman (prime)

Answer 7

johnson: speed-100, agility-100, stamina-100, chin-90, body-85, heart-95, cuts-95

louis: speed-85, agility-75, stamina-90, chin-85, body-100, heart-100 cuts-100,

marciano: speed-75, agility-60, stamina-100, chin-100, body-100, heart-100, cuts-20

foreman: speed-75, agility-70, stamina-70, chin-90, body-90, heart-95 cuts-95

ali: speed-100, agility-100, stamina-100, chin-100, body-100, heart-100, cuts-100

sorry but lewis, liston, tyson not worthy to be on this list so i did not rate them.

Answer 8

Louis:
power: 100
speed: 80
agility: 70
stamina: 90
chin: 70
heart: 85

Marciano:
power: 100
speed: 75
agility: 65
stamina: 90
chin: 90
heart: 100

Foreman:
power: 100
speed: 60
agility: 55
stamina: 75
chin: 85
heart: 80

Tyson:
power: 100
speed: 90
agility: 80
stamina: 90
chin: 90
heart: 80

Johnson:
power: 80
speed: 80
agility: 80
stamina: 100
chin: 90
heart: 85

Lewis:
power: 95
speed: 80
agility: 75
stamina: 80
chin: 75
heart: 80

Liston:
power: 100
speed: 80
agility: 80
stamina: 75
chin: 80
heart: 70

Ali:
power: 75
speed: 100
agility: 100
stamina: 90
chin: 100
heart: 100

Answer 9

Iron mike in his prime all the way

Answer 10

1.Eddie Chambers-more proven oppenents 2.Chris Arreola-not as proven as Eddie would be a good fight 3. J.D. Chapman-he only fights people who are average and have average records