Do you think the world would be better off if we were all Amish?

Question

I have seen all kinds of questions here about outlawing plastic bags, race cars and so on. Everybody has a pet peeve that is a waste and should not be allowed. So, I was curious. How many people thing the world would be a better place if we all gave up cars, electricity, and all that stuff to live like the Amish, farming small plots of land by hand.

I meant "think" and not "thing" of course, but both "thing" and "think" real words and so pass the spell check.

And I wasn't so much interested in learning if you yourself wanted to be Amish as much as wondering if you think the world would be better if everyone ELSE were Amish. Of course if you say yes but you don't want to be Amish yourself, I will call you names!

Answer 1

Well, yes, to answer your question, the world would more likely be a better place - I lived and worked with the Amish in Pa. and they are wonderful people and make excellent neighbors. They also have a wonderful sense of humor and when they needed a ride to the hospital they did not hesitate to call on me for a ride in my car... there are many off shoots and different branches and beliefs amongst the community as to what is permissable... and as to being better off mentally as well as environmentally, to spend an evening sitting in a home with no hum of electric and the lovely calm glow of a gas lamp, well, it imbues an all is right with the world feeling of serenity...

Answer 2

I think their way of life is mostly better for the environment I probably wouldn't survive as Amish since I am a vegetarian. I don't think the Amish as a whole are against plastic bags. Yahoo and many other companies would really have to change their reliance on technology if everyone lived like the Amish. I like some technology, so living more like the Amish would work for me, as long as their was some technology.

Answer 3

Well yes the world would definately be better of if we lived like the Amish

But we dont actually have to be Amish.

They have some boring attitudes about social life
and their clothes are less than groovy

But their behaviour towards the Environment is to be recomended.

Answer 4

i think it wud be good. the amish are all so healthy and they live a long time too. the kids take care of their parents wen they become old. they just dont ship them off to nursing homes and forget about them. about the waste and stuff , yea, im sure it cud reduce that by all being amish, not that amish always are super recyclers, but ya., they also get a LOT of excercise and stuff but farming and doing stuff by hand. also their families seem much closer that many of todays families. i wudnt object and im only 14

Answer 5

Hmmmm - the methane that cows produce do contribute to global warming :)

I live in Lancaster and seeing them every day makes me think we'd be better off living like them. We'd all be thinner, that's for sure! I don't think people could go from living our current lifestyle to how the Amish live. You have to be raised that way.

Hypothetically, the world would be a better place. But we're all spoiled!!! :)

Answer 6

No (sorry to the Amish) but the world runs in a forward thinking way making it positive. Do you want to farm every day cause I don't.

Answer 7

OMG THAT IS SUCH A GOOD IDEA!!!!!! i sorta live near lots of amish and they look so happy. Our world is really spoiled with all the stuff we have i think we should!. They are fine with no electricity or cars!!!!! along with the world people would be healthier!! instead of driving theres farm work and you could bike every where and there wouldnt be french fries and other mickey ds food!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Answer 8

The environment would certainly be better off if we were all Amish. And better still if we were all dead.
But maybe a more practical solution is that we all try to be more mindful of what we're consuming and the rate at which we're poisoning our environment and look for reasonable solutions to those problems.

Answer 9

Not me. I respect the Amish but would not want to be one. We need people not to be as wasteful, but that's a bit extreme.

Answer 10

Thats one the quirks of many faiths. you're able to try this, you won't be able to do this. blah blah yadda yadda. hear...autos isn't a sin. They declare that's. yet... Did you spot Horse drawn ambulances? i think so sorry for the families and ladies. yet. See what occurs once you face a existence and loss of life situation. hastily possibly issues are not a sin. whilst loss of life faces you or a family individuals member.....your religon can substitute my pal. . . .Amish thought: the international: they have faith in final quite break free something of the international, bodily and socially. component to this could be led to via the thought association with others -- in many circumstances noted as "The English" -- could be polluting. section could be as a results of bright persecution experienced via their ancestors as a consequence of government oppression. Amish properties do no longer draw ability from the electric grid. They sense that that could excessively connect them to the international. Nonresistance: They reject involvement with the militia or conflict. they have faith that Amish ought to by no ability motel to violence or to take up hands in conflict. besides the shown fact that, they do no longer many times view themselves as pacifists, because of the fact this might contain them in political action to sell peace. Their rejection of violence would not amplify to the disciplining of their infants. the religion venture homestead in Virginia housed mentally retarded infants and adults. They used actual punishment to regulate the youngsters. It took "...the form of slapping the hand various circumstances or spanking the buttocks a optimal of four strokes with the hand or a 'undemanding mild paddle." 3 Bruises on a youthful lady led to the state branch of psychological wellbeing and psychological Retardation procuring an injunction which prohibited using stress via team interior the homestead. The case led to Professor Alvin Esau to remark: "there is definitely great irony in this situation, as communities such because of the fact the Amish and Hutterites use actual punishment, sometimes excessively, whilst supposedly believing in nonviolence in human relationships." 4 it relatively is okay to disconnect from the international till whilst? you desire them. yeah dazzling. .